Skip to contentSkip to conversation

POSIX's "tables of the law"

DISCUSSION DENIEL Philippe 3 participants 3 messages Oct 12, 2010

Subsystems (2)
lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hi,

on many aspects, knowing the POSIX standard and behavior is quite important when working on implementing something like NFSv4. There a problem occur : if I need information on NFS (whatever version) or any "related" protocol (RPCSEC_GSS, ONCRPC, ...) I can easily find a document that is the absolute reference to use. But what about POSIX ? I must have missed something but I never see such a reference. Do you have book references to provide me with about this subject ?

Regards,

Philippe

#1 lore raw

DENIEL Philippe wrote:

on many aspects, knowing the POSIX standard and behavior is quite important when working on implementing something like NFSv4. There a problem occur : if I need information on NFS (whatever version) or any "related" protocol (RPCSEC_GSS, ONCRPC, ...) I can easily find a document that is the absolute reference to use. But what about POSIX ? I must have missed something but I never see such a reference. Do you have book references to provide me with about this subject ?

The posix spec situation is confused because there are many different specs published at different times, and the ones that are most important (like acls) were never ratified as far as I know, so are still in draft form. Originally they were ISO specs, which cost big money, which is why you won't find them on the web. More recently I think the Open Group has been working on them, maybe you'll find copies there: www.opengroup.org

#2 lore raw
Quoted 10 lines · Jim Rees

DENIEL Philippe wrote:

on many aspects, knowing the POSIX standard and behavior is quite important when working on implementing something like NFSv4. There a problem occur : if I need information on NFS (whatever version) or any "related" protocol (RPCSEC_GSS, ONCRPC, ...) I can easily find a document that is the absolute reference to use. But what about POSIX ? I must have missed something but I never see such a reference. Do you have book references to provide me with about this subject ?

Quoted 6 lines

The posix spec situation is confused because there are many different specs published at different times, and the ones that are most important (like acls) were never ratified as far as I know, so are still in draft form. Originally they were ISO specs, which cost big money, which is why you won't find them on the web. More recently I think the Open Group has been working on them, maybe you'll find copies there: www.opengroup.org

I think you want:

http://www.unix.org/single_unix_specification/

You have to fill out a form but there's no charge.

Of course you can also write little test programs and such to find out what other filesystems or platforms do. No spec is perfect, alas.

--b.