Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Minimal images: kernel config

DISCUSSION Darren Hart 6 participants 8 messages Feb 18, 2011 – Apr 28, 2011

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

I've been getting more and more questions regarding flash footprint, memory footprint, and boot time. All of these fall under the "minimal image" heading in my head.

Currently, poky-image-minimal is a simple subset of poky-image-sato. It uses busybox, but is still dynamically linked and uses the same somewhat-generic kernel build. By somewhat-generic I mean we have named features that often cover more drivers than are stricly necessary for a given board (usb-net comes to mind). I'd like to see minimal become a truly minimal image from both the userspace and kernel side point of view.

Here's my take on this. From userspace this means uclibc and a staticly linked busybox. From the kernel this means a static build (no modules) with nothing more than is required for the board's built-in peripherals to function, with the possible exception of something like usb-storage. I'd like to see a < 10M flash size and a <8M memory footprint.

Thoughts on this direction?

Signature · 3 lines
Darren Hart
Intel Open Source Technology Center
Yocto Project - Linux Kernel
#1 lore raw
Quoted 11 lines · Darren Hart

I've been getting more and more questions regarding flash footprint, memory footprint, and boot time. All of these fall under the "minimal image" heading in my head.

Currently, poky-image-minimal is a simple subset of poky-image-sato. It uses busybox, but is still dynamically linked and uses the same somewhat-generic kernel build. By somewhat-generic I mean we have named features that often cover more drivers than are stricly necessary for a given board (usb-net comes to mind). I'd like to see minimal become a truly minimal image from both the userspace and kernel side point of view.

Quoted 7 lines

Here's my take on this. From userspace this means uclibc and a staticly linked busybox. From the kernel this means a static build (no modules) with nothing more than is required for the board's built-in peripherals to function, with the possible exception of something like usb-storage. I'd like to see a < 10M flash size and a <8M memory footprint.

Thoughts on this direction?

That sounds more like a "micro" rather than the current minimal. Minimal is designed to be extended by the user, what you describe above is a lot harder to extend.

So my take is that minimal is ok as it is stands from the dynamic linked busybox perspective and static linking doesn't buy you what you might expect it to. mklibs will probably have just as much effect.

For kernel modules, I suspect even for a micro, you still want them since you can then start booting the kernel faster and only have what you need in memory (say USB peripherals).

I'm not against a micro type target but its smaller that what we've been aiming for an introduces a new element into the Yocto test matrix.

Having said all that, I expect there are ways to reduce minimal further than it is today as its not something anyone has looked hard at so far...

Cheers,

Richard

#2 lore raw
Quoted 32 lines · Richard Purdie
Quoted 11 lines · Darren Hart

I've been getting more and more questions regarding flash footprint, memory footprint, and boot time. All of these fall under the "minimal image" heading in my head.

Currently, poky-image-minimal is a simple subset of poky-image-sato. It uses busybox, but is still dynamically linked and uses the same somewhat-generic kernel build. By somewhat-generic I mean we have named features that often cover more drivers than are stricly necessary for a given board (usb-net comes to mind). I'd like to see minimal become a truly minimal image from both the userspace and kernel side point of view.

Quoted 7 lines

Here's my take on this. From userspace this means uclibc and a staticly linked busybox. From the kernel this means a static build (no modules) with nothing more than is required for the board's built-in peripherals to function, with the possible exception of something like usb-storage. I'd like to see a < 10M flash size and a <8M memory footprint.

Thoughts on this direction?

That sounds more like a "micro" rather than the current minimal. Minimal is designed to be extended by the user, what you describe above is a lot harder to extend.

So my take is that minimal is ok as it is stands from the dynamic linked busybox perspective and static linking doesn't buy you what you might expect it to. mklibs will probably have just as much effect.

For kernel modules, I suspect even for a micro, you still want them since you can then start booting the kernel faster and only have what you need in memory (say USB peripherals).

Quoted 6 lines

I'm not against a micro type target but its smaller that what we've been aiming for an introduces a new element into the Yocto test matrix.

Having said all that, I expect there are ways to reduce minimal further than it is today as its not something anyone has looked hard at so far...

The keys to reducing minimal further is eglibc configurability -- which we do not yet have implemented, and use of mklibs. Shared memory will likely be both smaller disk and memory footprint then static binaries in this configuration. (If not, it will be very close...)

The size of the kernel and modules is also a factor -- but as Richard mentioned, it's fairly typical to have a lightly configured kernel as the boot kernel and then load a lot of modules once the system comes alive.

My goal for a busybox / glibc based system is around 8 MB of disk usage... This should be easily achievable when eglibc is able to be configured, mklibs is run and a reasonable set of modules is available.

--Mark

Quoted 10 lines

Cheers,

Richard

_______________________________________________
poky mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.yoctoproject.org/listinfo/poky

#3 lore raw
Quoted 45 lines · Mark Hatle
Quoted 32 lines · Richard Purdie
Quoted 11 lines · Darren Hart

I've been getting more and more questions regarding flash footprint, memory footprint, and boot time. All of these fall under the "minimal image" heading in my head.

Currently, poky-image-minimal is a simple subset of poky-image-sato. It uses busybox, but is still dynamically linked and uses the same somewhat-generic kernel build. By somewhat-generic I mean we have named features that often cover more drivers than are stricly necessary for a given board (usb-net comes to mind). I'd like to see minimal become a truly minimal image from both the userspace and kernel side point of view.

Quoted 7 lines

Here's my take on this. From userspace this means uclibc and a staticly linked busybox. From the kernel this means a static build (no modules) with nothing more than is required for the board's built-in peripherals to function, with the possible exception of something like usb-storage. I'd like to see a< 10M flash size and a<8M memory footprint.

Thoughts on this direction?

That sounds more like a "micro" rather than the current minimal. Minimal is designed to be extended by the user, what you describe above is a lot harder to extend.

So my take is that minimal is ok as it is stands from the dynamic linked busybox perspective and static linking doesn't buy you what you might expect it to. mklibs will probably have just as much effect.

For kernel modules, I suspect even for a micro, you still want them since you can then start booting the kernel faster and only have what you need in memory (say USB peripherals).

Quoted 6 lines

I'm not against a micro type target but its smaller that what we've been aiming for an introduces a new element into the Yocto test matrix.

Having said all that, I expect there are ways to reduce minimal further than it is today as its not something anyone has looked hard at so far...

The keys to reducing minimal further is eglibc configurability -- which we do not yet have implemented, and use of mklibs. Shared memory will likely be both smaller disk and memory footprint then static binaries in this configuration. (If not, it will be very close...)

Quoted 7 lines

The size of the kernel and modules is also a factor -- but as Richard mentioned, it's fairly typical to have a lightly configured kernel as the boot kernel and then load a lot of modules once the system comes alive.

My goal for a busybox / glibc based system is around 8 MB of disk usage... This should be easily achievable when eglibc is able to be configured, mklibs is run and a reasonable set of modules is available.

In that case, perhaps we can accomplish my goals without a new type of image (micro as rp called it - which is a heckuvalot bigger than a yocto I should add ;-).

Something to add to the "to investigate" list.

Signature · 3 lines
Darren Hart
Intel Open Source Technology Center
Yocto Project - Linux Kernel
#5 lore raw
In reply to Darren Hart
Quoted 11 lines · Darren Hart

I've been getting more and more questions regarding flash footprint, memory footprint, and boot time. All of these fall under the "minimal image" heading in my head.

Currently, poky-image-minimal is a simple subset of poky-image-sato. It uses busybox, but is still dynamically linked and uses the same somewhat-generic kernel build. By somewhat-generic I mean we have named features that often cover more drivers than are stricly necessary for a given board (usb-net comes to mind). I'd like to see minimal become a truly minimal image from both the userspace and kernel side point of view.

Quoted 5 lines

Here's my take on this. From userspace this means uclibc and a staticly linked busybox. From the kernel this means a static build (no modules) with nothing more than is required for the board's built-in peripherals to function, with the possible exception of something like usb-storage. I'd like to see a < 10M flash size and a <8M memory footprint.

From the kernel angle, I have a profile/solution for this lurking in the 2.6.34 kernel, and one that we've been updating for the 2.6.37 kernel.

There's a kernel feature called "small", that when overlayed on top of any BSP, converts it to a tuned for small systems BSP. Other than that, we have to hold the line on BSP configurations. Keep them tuned and specific by default and add kernel configurations for optional features when request, not by default.

That's the approach we've been taking without our 150 or so BSPs, and it has worked out really well for producing a general/debug BSP + something that is tuned for a truly embedded deployment.

Bruce

Quoted 3 lines

Thoughts on this direction?

#4 lore raw
In reply to Mark Hatle
Quoted 36 lines · Mark Hatle
Quoted 35 lines · Richard Purdie
Quoted 11 lines · Darren Hart

I've been getting more and more questions regarding flash footprint, memory footprint, and boot time. All of these fall under the "minimal image" heading in my head.

Currently, poky-image-minimal is a simple subset of poky-image-sato. It uses busybox, but is still dynamically linked and uses the same somewhat-generic kernel build. By somewhat-generic I mean we have named features that often cover more drivers than are stricly necessary for a given board (usb-net comes to mind). I'd like to see minimal become a truly minimal image from both the userspace and kernel side point of view.

Quoted 7 lines

Here's my take on this. From userspace this means uclibc and a staticly linked busybox. From the kernel this means a static build (no modules) with nothing more than is required for the board's built-in peripherals to function, with the possible exception of something like usb-storage. I'd like to see a< 10M flash size and a<8M memory footprint.

Thoughts on this direction?

That sounds more like a "micro" rather than the current minimal. Minimal is designed to be extended by the user, what you describe above is a lot harder to extend.

So my take is that minimal is ok as it is stands from the dynamic linked busybox perspective and static linking doesn't buy you what you might expect it to. mklibs will probably have just as much effect.

For kernel modules, I suspect even for a micro, you still want them since you can then start booting the kernel faster and only have what you need in memory (say USB peripherals).

I'm not against a micro type target but its smaller that what we've been aiming for an introduces a new element into the Yocto test matrix.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Having said all that, I expect there are ways to reduce minimal further than it is today as its not something anyone has looked hard at so far...

The keys to reducing minimal further is eglibc configurability -- which we do not yet have implemented

While not yet being used heavily, this does exist in OE today thanks to Khem. Perhaps this would be a good candidate for oe-core?

Signature · 2 lines
Tom Rini
Mentor Graphics Corporation
#6 lore raw
In reply to Bruce Ashfield
Quoted 18 lines · Bruce Ashfield
Quoted 11 lines · Darren Hart

I've been getting more and more questions regarding flash footprint, memory footprint, and boot time. All of these fall under the "minimal image" heading in my head.

Currently, poky-image-minimal is a simple subset of poky-image-sato. It uses busybox, but is still dynamically linked and uses the same somewhat-generic kernel build. By somewhat-generic I mean we have named features that often cover more drivers than are stricly necessary for a given board (usb-net comes to mind). I'd like to see minimal become a truly minimal image from both the userspace and kernel side point of view.

Quoted 5 lines

Here's my take on this. From userspace this means uclibc and a staticly linked busybox. From the kernel this means a static build (no modules) with nothing more than is required for the board's built-in peripherals to function, with the possible exception of something like usb-storage. I'd like to see a < 10M flash size and a <8M memory footprint.

Quoted 4 lines

From the kernel angle, I have a profile/solution for this lurking in the 2.6.34 kernel, and one that we've been updating for the 2.6.37 kernel.

Hi Bruce,

Quoted 5 lines

There's a kernel feature called "small", that when overlayed on top of any BSP, converts it to a tuned for small systems BSP. Other than that, we have to hold the line on BSP configurations. Keep them tuned and specific by default and add kernel configurations for optional features when request, not by default.

We are working on "minimal image". Right now we try to reduce rootfs size, but we think there are relationships between kernel configurations and rootfs, because rootfs also contains some kernel modules. So would you send us a copy of kernel "small" configuration, more detail will be appreciated.

Thanks and Regards,
Kai

Quoted 16 lines

That's the approach we've been taking without our 150 or so BSPs, and it has worked out really well for producing a general/debug BSP + something that is tuned for a truly embedded deployment.

Bruce

Quoted 3 lines

Thoughts on this direction?

_______________________________________________
poky mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.yoctoproject.org/listinfo/poky

#7 lore raw
Quoted 31 lines · Kang Kai
Quoted 19 lines · Bruce Ashfield
Quoted 12 lines · Darren Hart

I've been getting more and more questions regarding flash footprint, memory footprint, and boot time. All of these fall under the "minimal image" heading in my head.

Currently, poky-image-minimal is a simple subset of poky-image-sato. It uses busybox, but is still dynamically linked and uses the same somewhat-generic kernel build. By somewhat-generic I mean we have named features that often cover more drivers than are stricly necessary for a given board (usb-net comes to mind). I'd like to see minimal become a truly minimal image from both the userspace and kernel side point of view.

Quoted 5 lines

Here's my take on this. From userspace this means uclibc and a staticly linked busybox. From the kernel this means a static build (no modules) with nothing more than is required for the board's built-in peripherals to function, with the possible exception of something like usb-storage. I'd like to see a < 10M flash size and a <8M memory footprint.

Quoted 4 lines

From the kernel angle, I have a profile/solution for this lurking in the 2.6.34 kernel, and one that we've been updating for the 2.6.37 kernel.

Hi Bruce,

Quoted 5 lines

There's a kernel feature called "small", that when overlayed on top of any BSP, converts it to a tuned for small systems BSP. Other than that, we have to hold the line on BSP configurations. Keep them tuned and specific by default and add kernel configurations for optional features when request, not by default.

Quoted 5 lines

We are working on "minimal image". Right now we try to reduce rootfs size, but we think there are relationships between kernel configurations and rootfs, because rootfs also contains some kernel modules. So would you send us a copy of kernel "small" configuration, more detail will be appreciated.

Not ignoring this. Just swamped. I'll dig this up ASAP and send it your way.

Bruce

Quoted 20 lines

Thanks and Regards,
Kai

Quoted 16 lines

That's the approach we've been taking without our 150 or so BSPs, and it has worked out really well for producing a general/debug BSP + something that is tuned for a truly embedded deployment.

Bruce

Quoted 3 lines

Thoughts on this direction?

_______________________________________________
poky mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.yoctoproject.org/listinfo/poky