Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Distros supporting older kernels?

DISCUSSION Steffen Sledz 4 participants 9 messages Jun 9, 2011 – Jun 15, 2011

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hi Distro Maintainers,

as you could read in earlier messages of mine, we're forced to use an older kernel version (2.6.24) for our hardware. This brings a lot of problems as you can imagine (e.g. we're also bound to udev-141).

Until now we've used angstrom-2008.1 with some own patches according to the linux-libc-headers and udev versions for our hardware which were reasonably not accepted by the Angstrom maintainers (see discussions [1] or [2]).

In there current situation (angstrom-2008.1 is deprecated, the new layer concept will come up) we're looking for a new, better, less hacky solution.

My first question therefor is if there are any distros explicitely supporting older kernels (pre 2.6.27) yet? Or are willing to work on it?

[1] <http://thread.gmane.org/gmane.comp.handhelds.openembedded/32375>
[2] <http://thread.gmane.org/gmane.comp.handhelds.openembedded/42628>

Thx,
Steffen

PS: Does anybody know a good overview which Linux Kernel API changes were made in which kernel version?

Signature · 7 lines
DResearch Fahrzeugelektronik GmbH
Otto-Schmirgal-Str. 3, 10319 Berlin, Germany
Tel: +49 30 515932-237 mailto:[email protected]
Fax: +49 30 515932-299
Geschäftsführer: Dr. Michael Weber, Werner Mögle;
Amtsgericht Berlin Charlottenburg; HRB 130120 B;
Ust.-IDNr. DE273952058
#1 lore raw

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Quoted 6 lines · Steffen Sledz

Hi Distro Maintainers,

as you could read in earlier messages of mine, we're forced to use an older kernel version (2.6.24) for our hardware. This brings a lot of problems as you can imagine (e.g. we're also bound to udev-141).

Quoted 6 lines

Until now we've used angstrom-2008.1 with some own patches according to the linux-libc-headers and udev versions for our hardware which were reasonably not accepted by the Angstrom maintainers (see discussions [1] or [2]).

In there current situation (angstrom-2008.1 is deprecated,

Ehm, 2008.1 is not deprecated, it's still fully supported in the 2011.03 maintenance branch.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.5 (Darwin)

iD8DBQFN8MbPMkyGM64RGpERAgF7AKCGjnsrW63s4rBTAH/ZUVzFAGbRWACeM/Kc Bc88jtYjU/yuLsJ3Knh9KLc=
=gpMW
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

#2 lore raw
Quoted 4 lines · Koen Kooi
Quoted 1 line

In there current situation (angstrom-2008.1 is deprecated,

Ehm, 2008.1 is not deprecated, it's still fully supported in the 2011.03 maintenance branch.

OK, you're right. Sorry.

But i think it's still a good reason to look for a better solution.

BTW: Would it be a good idea to create a little overwiew page (in the wiki?) where we can list all the distros using OE with their targets, requirements, limitations, ...?

Signature · 7 lines
DResearch Fahrzeugelektronik GmbH
Otto-Schmirgal-Str. 3, 10319 Berlin, Germany
Tel: +49 30 515932-237 mailto:[email protected]
Fax: +49 30 515932-299
Geschäftsführer: Dr. Michael Weber, Werner Mögle;
Amtsgericht Berlin Charlottenburg; HRB 130120 B;
Ust.-IDNr. DE273952058
#3 lore raw
In reply to Steffen Sledz
Quoted 11 lines · Steffen Sledz

Hi Distro Maintainers,

as you could read in earlier messages of mine, we're forced to use an older kernel version (2.6.24) for our hardware. This brings a lot of problems as you can imagine (e.g. we're also bound to udev-141).

Until now we've used angstrom-2008.1 with some own patches according to the linux-libc-headers and udev versions for our hardware which were reasonably not accepted by the Angstrom maintainers (see discussions [1] or [2]).

Quoted 6 lines

In there current situation (angstrom-2008.1 is deprecated, the new layer concept will come up) we're looking for a new, better, less hacky solution.

My first question therefor is if there are any distros explicitely supporting older kernels (pre 2.6.27) yet? Or are willing to work on it?

I guess a machine layer on top of oe-core could be something you can work out and add/override needed recipes in this layer.

Quoted 9 lines

[1] <http://thread.gmane.org/gmane.comp.handhelds.openembedded/32375>
[2] <http://thread.gmane.org/gmane.comp.handhelds.openembedded/42628>

Thx,
Steffen

PS: Does anybody know a good overview which Linux Kernel API changes were made in which kernel version?

#4 lore raw
Quoted 12 lines · Khem Raj
Quoted 11 lines · Steffen Sledz

Hi Distro Maintainers,

as you could read in earlier messages of mine, we're forced to use an older kernel version (2.6.24) for our hardware. This brings a lot of problems as you can imagine (e.g. we're also bound to udev-141).

Until now we've used angstrom-2008.1 with some own patches according to the linux-libc-headers and udev versions for our hardware which were reasonably not accepted by the Angstrom maintainers (see discussions [1] or [2]).

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 6 lines

In there current situation (angstrom-2008.1 is deprecated, the new layer concept will come up) we're looking for a new, better, less hacky solution.

My first question therefor is if there are any distros explicitely supporting older kernels (pre 2.6.27) yet? Or are willing to work on it?

I guess a machine layer on top of oe-core could be something you can work out and add/override needed recipes in this layer.

I think it's not that easy.

For kernels prior to 2.6.27 you can't use a lot of core components (e.g. udev with versions higher than 141 or eggdbus) which *a lot of other components* depend on.

The underlying problem are some kernel API functions like inotify_init1 or epoll_create1. Some distros (e.g. Angstrom) use linux-libc-headers 2.6.31 which is higher then 2.6.27 (what in my opinion conflicts with [1]). So there's no chance to detect the mentioned kernel functions correctly at compile time. :(

As a consequence you have to check this in *all* programs at runtime. This is a good wish but hard to realize. E.g. the udev maintainers itself rejected a related patch[2] and say that they are not willing to support older kernel versions.

So in my opinion there are two possible ways:

1. Use only the old supported versions of the components (udev-141 and glib-dbus instead of eggdbus) with all the consequences for other programs.

2. Determine *all* critical kernel functions, look for *all* the places where these are used, and patch them.

Both are a lot more than some override recipes. So i think this needs an own distro with all the maintenance and testing.

Regards,
Steffen

[1] "but a program built against newer kernel headers may not work on an older kernel" <http://git.kernel.org/?p=linux/kernel/git/torvalds/linux-2.6.git;a=blob_plain;f=Documentation/make/headers_install.txt;hb=HEAD>
[2] <http://thread.gmane.org/gmane.linux.hotplug.devel/16590>

Signature · 7 lines
DResearch Fahrzeugelektronik GmbH
Otto-Schmirgal-Str. 3, 10319 Berlin, Germany
Tel: +49 30 515932-237 mailto:[email protected]
Fax: +49 30 515932-299
Geschäftsführer: Dr. Michael Weber, Werner Mögle;
Amtsgericht Berlin Charlottenburg; HRB 130120 B;
Ust.-IDNr. DE273952058
#5 lore raw

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Quoted 43 lines · Steffen Sledz
Quoted 16 lines · Khem Raj
Quoted 15 lines · Steffen Sledz

Hi Distro Maintainers,

as you could read in earlier messages of mine, we're forced to use an older kernel version (2.6.24) for our hardware. This brings a lot of problems as you can imagine (e.g. we're also bound to udev-141).

Until now we've used angstrom-2008.1 with some own patches according to the linux-libc-headers and udev versions for our hardware which were reasonably not accepted by the Angstrom maintainers (see discussions [1] or [2]).

In there current situation (angstrom-2008.1 is deprecated, the new layer concept will come up) we're looking for a new, better, less hacky solution.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines

My first question therefor is if there are any distros explicitely supporting older kernels (pre 2.6.27) yet? Or are willing to work on it?

I guess a machine layer on top of oe-core could be something you can work out and add/override needed recipes in this layer.

I think it's not that easy.

For kernels prior to 2.6.27 you can't use a lot of core components (e.g. udev with versions higher than 141 or eggdbus) which *a lot of other components* depend on.

The underlying problem are some kernel API functions like inotify_init1 or epoll_create1. Some distros (e.g. Angstrom) use linux-libc-headers 2.6.31 which is higher then 2.6.27 (what in my opinion conflicts with [1]). So there's no chance to detect the mentioned kernel functions correctly at compile time. :(

As a consequence you have to check this in *all* programs at runtime. This is a good wish but hard to realize. E.g. the udev maintainers itself rejected a related patch[2] and say that they are not willing to support older kernel versions.

So in my opinion there are two possible ways:

Quoted 8 lines

1. Use only the old supported versions of the components (udev-141 and glib-dbus instead of eggdbus) with all the consequences for other programs.

2. Determine *all* critical kernel functions, look for *all* the places where these are used, and patch them.

Both are a lot more than some override recipes. So i think this needs an own distro with all the maintenance and testing.

3) Cut your losses and update your kernel port. At some point it just isn't economically feasible aymore to bend userspace against an obsolete kernel.

I'm still stuck with 2.6.32 at work for a lot of customers, which is accumulating more and more backports.

regards,

Koen
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.5 (Darwin)

iD8DBQFN9KdhMkyGM64RGpERArsBAKCcIqGbU9C7qjirf9YAU4xUBdAKMACfV50G GOjNf7icEEzOcx81w0N64Uk=
=SMzJ
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

#6 lore raw
Quoted 53 lines · Koen Kooi

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Quoted 49 lines · Steffen Sledz
Quoted 16 lines · Khem Raj
Quoted 15 lines · Steffen Sledz

Hi Distro Maintainers,

as you could read in earlier messages of mine, we're forced to use an older kernel version (2.6.24) for our hardware. This brings a lot of problems as you can imagine (e.g. we're also bound to udev-141).

Until now we've used angstrom-2008.1 with some own patches according to the linux-libc-headers and udev versions for our hardware which were reasonably not accepted by the Angstrom maintainers (see discussions [1] or [2]).

In there current situation (angstrom-2008.1 is deprecated, the new layer concept will come up) we're looking for a new, better, less hacky solution.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines

My first question therefor is if there are any distros explicitely supporting older kernels (pre 2.6.27) yet? Or are willing to work on it?

I guess a machine layer on top of oe-core could be something you can work out and add/override needed recipes in this layer.

I think it's not that easy.

For kernels prior to 2.6.27 you can't use a lot of core components (e.g. udev with versions higher than 141 or eggdbus) which *a lot of other components* depend on.

The underlying problem are some kernel API functions like inotify_init1 or epoll_create1. Some distros (e.g. Angstrom) use linux-libc-headers 2.6.31 which is higher then 2.6.27 (what in my opinion conflicts with [1]). So there's no chance to detect the mentioned kernel functions correctly at compile time. :(

As a consequence you have to check this in *all* programs at runtime. This is a good wish but hard to realize. E.g. the udev maintainers itself rejected a related patch[2] and say that they are not willing to support older kernel versions.

So in my opinion there are two possible ways:

1. Use only the old supported versions of the components (udev-141 and glib-dbus instead of eggdbus) with all the consequences for other programs.

2. Determine *all* critical kernel functions, look for *all* the places where these are used, and patch them.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines

Both are a lot more than some override recipes. So i think this needs an own distro with all the maintenance and testing.

3) Cut your losses and update your kernel port. At some point it just isn't economically feasible aymore to bend userspace against an obsolete kernel.

You can believe me, we would like to do nothing more than this.

But unfortunately we got only one big patch of more than 10000 lines against 2.6.24 from the CPU manufacturer (ex Oxford Semiconductors, now PLX Technology).

We do not have the power to split up and port this code to newer kernel versions and the manufacturer is not willing to do it. :(

Regards,
Steffen

Signature · 7 lines
DResearch Fahrzeugelektronik GmbH
Otto-Schmirgal-Str. 3, 10319 Berlin, Germany
Tel: +49 30 515932-237 mailto:[email protected]
Fax: +49 30 515932-299
Geschäftsführer: Dr. Michael Weber, Werner Mögle;
Amtsgericht Berlin Charlottenburg; HRB 130120 B;
Ust.-IDNr. DE273952058
#7 lore raw
Quoted 66 lines · Steffen Sledz
Quoted 58 lines · Koen Kooi

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Quoted 54 lines · Steffen Sledz
Quoted 19 lines · Khem Raj
Quoted 18 lines · Steffen Sledz

Hi Distro Maintainers,

as you could read in earlier messages of mine, we're forced to use an older kernel version (2.6.24) for our hardware. This brings a lot of problems as you can imagine (e.g. we're also bound to udev-141).

Until now we've used angstrom-2008.1 with some own patches according to
the linux-libc-headers and udev versions for our hardware which were reasonably not accepted by the Angstrom maintainers (see discussions [1]
or [2]).

In there current situation (angstrom-2008.1 is deprecated, the new layer
concept will come up) we're looking for a new, better, less hacky solution.

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines

My first question therefor is if there are any distros explicitely supporting older kernels (pre 2.6.27) yet? Or are willing to work on it?

I guess a machine layer on top of oe-core could be something you can work out and add/override needed recipes in this layer.

I think it's not that easy.

For kernels prior to 2.6.27 you can't use a lot of core components (e.g. udev with versions higher than 141 or eggdbus) which *a lot of other components* depend on.

The underlying problem are some kernel API functions like inotify_init1 or epoll_create1. Some distros (e.g. Angstrom) use linux-libc-headers 2.6.31 which is higher then 2.6.27 (what in my opinion conflicts with [1]). So there's no chance to detect the mentioned kernel functions correctly at compile time. :(

As a consequence you have to check this in *all* programs at runtime. This is a good wish but hard to realize. E.g. the udev maintainers itself rejected a related patch[2] and say that they are not willing to support older kernel versions.

So in my opinion there are two possible ways:

1. Use only the old supported versions of the components (udev-141 and glib-dbus instead of eggdbus) with all the consequences for other programs.

2. Determine *all* critical kernel functions, look for *all* the places where these are used, and patch them.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines

Both are a lot more than some override recipes. So i think this needs an own distro with all the maintenance and testing.

3) Cut your losses and update your kernel port. At some point it just isn't economically feasible aymore to bend userspace against an obsolete kernel.

Quoted 8 lines

You can believe me, we would like to do nothing more than this.

But unfortunately we got only one big patch of more than 10000 lines against 2.6.24 from the CPU manufacturer (ex Oxford Semiconductors, now PLX Technology).

We do not have the power to split up and port this code to newer kernel versions and the manufacturer is not willing to do it. :(

Create a linux-libc-headers recipe which builds out of your 2.6.24 kernel that can fix glibc compatibility and lot other userspace problems unless some apps really really need new features from kernel. Then you
have to either backport that functionality in kernel or use older version of app which does not depend on the new functionality so this way you can probably have something

If a standard distro should support it or not depends on distro userbase for that machine

Quoted 4 lines

Regards,
Steffen

#8 lore raw
In reply to Steffen Sledz

2011/6/12 Steffen Sledz <[email protected]>

Quoted 58 lines · Khem Raj
Quoted 18 lines · Steffen Sledz
Quoted 16 lines

Hi Distro Maintainers,

as you could read in earlier messages of mine, we're forced to use an older kernel version (2.6.24) for our hardware. This brings a lot of problems as you can imagine (e.g. we're also bound to udev-141).

Until now we've used angstrom-2008.1 with some own patches according to the linux-libc-headers and udev versions for our hardware which were reasonably not accepted by the Angstrom maintainers (see discussions [1] or [2]).

In there current situation (angstrom-2008.1 is deprecated, the new layer concept will come up) we're looking for a new, better, less hacky solution.

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines

My first question therefor is if there are any distros explicitely supporting older kernels (pre 2.6.27) yet? Or are willing to work on it?

I guess a machine layer on top of oe-core could be something you can work out and add/override needed recipes in this layer.

I think it's not that easy.

For kernels prior to 2.6.27 you can't use a lot of core components (e.g. udev with versions higher than 141 or eggdbus) which *a lot of other components* depend on.

The underlying problem are some kernel API functions like inotify_init1 or epoll_create1. Some distros (e.g. Angstrom) use linux-libc-headers 2.6.31 which is higher then 2.6.27 (what in my opinion conflicts with [1]). So there's no chance to detect the mentioned kernel functions correctly at compile time. :(

As a consequence you have to check this in *all* programs at runtime. This is a good wish but hard to realize. E.g. the udev maintainers itself rejected a related patch[2] and say that they are not willing to support older kernel versions.

So in my opinion there are two possible ways:

1. Use only the old supported versions of the components (udev-141 and glib-dbus instead of eggdbus) with all the consequences for other programs.

2. Determine *all* critical kernel functions, look for *all* the places where these are used, and patch them.

Both are a lot more than some override recipes. So i think this needs an own distro with all the maintenance and testing.

Regards,
Steffen

Quoted 8 lines

[1] "but a program built against newer kernel headers may not work on an older kernel" <
http://git.kernel.org/?p=linux/kernel/git/torvalds/linux-2.6.git;a=blob_plain;f=Documentation/make/headers_install.txt;hb=HEAD

Quoted 1 line

[2] <http://thread.gmane.org/gmane.linux.hotplug.devel/16590>

Steffen, I feel it really depends on what you are aiming at. For our

products we typically freeze on a certain version; if there are bugs that hurt us we either fix them (backporting a patch) or move to a newer version of that specific recipe (and stick it in a local overlay).

E.g. some of our maintenance is done on a monotone revision that was frozen a few years ago.
I feel if you have to use an older kernel and have a dedicated image (e.g. because you are doing a real embedded control system) you might be better off doing the same.
The newest packages are not necessarily better for you, and typically newer versions tend not to become smaller (but ofc exceptions exist).

Frans