Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Required/preferred multichannel order for ALSA

DISCUSSION Ricardo Neri 4 participants 7 messages Apr 26, 2012 – Apr 29, 2012

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hi Takashi, list,

I am implementing multichannel support for HDMI on Texas Instruments' OMAP4. I would like to know if ALSA mandates a specific channel order or has a preferred one.

I tried to find some guidance in alsa-lib or in the alsa driver. All I could find is the order described in speaker-test:
FL/FR/RL/RR/C/LFE/SL/SR. This order seems to be in use due to historical reasons [1]. It was also mentioned that an API to set/get the channel mapping was going to be implemented [2]; I tried to find it without success. As [1] and [2] are very old posts, I was wondering if the situation has changed.

My question arises from the fact that HDMI audio uses the channel ordering defined in CEA-861 section 6.6.2, which is different from what speaker-test expects. This also different from the order that SMPTE 320M specifies. OMAP4 is able to alter the channel mapping, so I could match what ALSA expects if such required/preferred order exists.

Thanks in advance for your comments.

Ricardo

[1].http://www.spinics.net/lists/alsa-devel/msg24444.html [2].http://www.spinics.net/lists/alsa-devel/msg24495.html

#1 lore raw
Quoted 20 lines · Ricardo Neri

Hi Takashi, list,

I am implementing multichannel support for HDMI on Texas Instruments' OMAP4. I would like to know if ALSA mandates a specific channel order or has a preferred one.

I tried to find some guidance in alsa-lib or in the alsa driver. All I could find is the order described in speaker-test:
FL/FR/RL/RR/C/LFE/SL/SR. This order seems to be in use due to historical reasons [1]. It was also mentioned that an API to set/get the channel mapping was going to be implemented [2]; I tried to find it without success. As [1] and [2] are very old posts, I was wondering if the situation has changed.

My question arises from the fact that HDMI audio uses the channel ordering defined in CEA-861 section 6.6.2, which is different from what speaker-test expects. This also different from the order that SMPTE 320M specifies. OMAP4 is able to alter the channel mapping, so I could match what ALSA expects if such required/preferred order exists.

Quoted 7 lines

Thanks in advance for your comments.

Ricardo

[1].http://www.spinics.net/lists/alsa-devel/msg24444.html [2].http://www.spinics.net/lists/alsa-devel/msg24495.html

A lot of hardware now can remap channels to suit the use case so it would probably be good to have an ALSA API to get/set the mappings.

This seems like it would be a good subject for the BoF.

Liam

#2 lore raw
Quoted 2 lines · Liam Girdwood

A lot of hardware now can remap channels to suit the use case so it would probably be good to have an ALSA API to get/set the mappings.

As well as being able to reorder things there's also the cases where a multi-channel link can be assigned to send several independant streams rather than actually be a multi-channel link.

Quoted 1 line

This seems like it would be a good subject for the BoF.

Yes.

#3 lore raw

At Fri, 27 Apr 2012 10:57:34 +0100,

Quoted 9 lines · Mark Brown
Quoted 2 lines · Liam Girdwood

A lot of hardware now can remap channels to suit the use case so it would probably be good to have an ALSA API to get/set the mappings.

As well as being able to reorder things there's also the cases where a multi-channel link can be assigned to send several independant streams rather than actually be a multi-channel link.

True. OTOH, separating to different streams can be done mostly without extra configuration. The driver may neeed to handle the open/close race, but basically splitting can be done uniquely just by the number of channels. Of course, there might be other excpetions and corner cases, though.

Takashi

#4 lore raw
Quoted 11 lines · Takashi Iwai
Quoted 3 lines · Mark Brown

As well as being able to reorder things there's also the cases where a multi-channel link can be assigned to send several independant streams rather than actually be a multi-channel link.

True. OTOH, separating to different streams can be done mostly without extra configuration. The driver may neeed to handle the open/close race, but basically splitting can be done uniquely just by the number of channels. Of course, there might be other excpetions and corner cases, though.

Yes, I think it's mostly just a slight generalisation of the same problem from an implementation point of view.

#5 lore raw
In reply to Liam Girdwood

At Fri, 27 Apr 2012 10:21:37 +0100,

Quoted 27 lines · Liam Girdwood
Quoted 25 lines · Ricardo Neri

Hi Takashi, list,

I am implementing multichannel support for HDMI on Texas Instruments' OMAP4. I would like to know if ALSA mandates a specific channel order or has a preferred one.

I tried to find some guidance in alsa-lib or in the alsa driver. All I could find is the order described in speaker-test:
FL/FR/RL/RR/C/LFE/SL/SR. This order seems to be in use due to historical reasons [1]. It was also mentioned that an API to set/get the channel mapping was going to be implemented [2]; I tried to find it without success. As [1] and [2] are very old posts, I was wondering if the situation has changed.

My question arises from the fact that HDMI audio uses the channel ordering defined in CEA-861 section 6.6.2, which is different from what speaker-test expects. This also different from the order that SMPTE 320M specifies. OMAP4 is able to alter the channel mapping, so I could match what ALSA expects if such required/preferred order exists.

Thanks in advance for your comments.

Ricardo

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 2 lines

[1].http://www.spinics.net/lists/alsa-devel/msg24444.html [2].http://www.spinics.net/lists/alsa-devel/msg24495.html

A lot of hardware now can remap channels to suit the use case so it would probably be good to have an ALSA API to get/set the mappings.

This seems like it would be a good subject for the BoF.

Yes. As I added to LPC 2012 wiki page, it's a topic I'd like to discuss in the audio microconf, too. It's a long-standing issue, not only for embedded devices but also PCs, especially with HDMI/DP.

Actually I've had a few different (partial) implementations, but nothing was so convincing yet.

BTW, for the time being, the remapping itself is done in alsa-lib route plugin. This works when the driver is unique and supports only a single configuration. Then you can define the routing table beforehand. Take a look at alsa-lib/src/conf/cards/*.conf based on old AC97 codecs.

OTOH, if the driver is generic (e.g. HD-audio) and supports different configurations, it doesn't work so easily. A more generic API is mandatory in such a case.

Takashi

#6 lore raw

Thanks to everyone for replying!

Quoted 41 lines · Takashi Iwai

At Fri, 27 Apr 2012 10:21:37 +0100,

Quoted 27 lines · Liam Girdwood
Quoted 25 lines · Ricardo Neri

Hi Takashi, list,

I am implementing multichannel support for HDMI on Texas Instruments' OMAP4. I would like to know if ALSA mandates a specific channel order or has a preferred one.

I tried to find some guidance in alsa-lib or in the alsa driver. All I could find is the order described in speaker-test:
FL/FR/RL/RR/C/LFE/SL/SR. This order seems to be in use due to historical reasons [1]. It was also mentioned that an API to set/get the channel mapping was going to be implemented [2]; I tried to find it without success. As [1] and [2] are very old posts, I was wondering if the situation has changed.

My question arises from the fact that HDMI audio uses the channel ordering defined in CEA-861 section 6.6.2, which is different from what speaker-test expects. This also different from the order that SMPTE 320M specifies. OMAP4 is able to alter the channel mapping, so I could match what ALSA expects if such required/preferred order exists.

Thanks in advance for your comments.

Ricardo

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 2 lines

[1].http://www.spinics.net/lists/alsa-devel/msg24444.html [2].http://www.spinics.net/lists/alsa-devel/msg24495.html

A lot of hardware now can remap channels to suit the use case so it would probably be good to have an ALSA API to get/set the mappings.

This seems like it would be a good subject for the BoF.

Yes. As I added to LPC 2012 wiki page, it's a topic I'd like to discuss in the audio microconf, too. It's a long-standing issue, not only for embedded devices but also PCs, especially with HDMI/DP.

Quoted 8 lines

Actually I've had a few different (partial) implementations, but nothing was so convincing yet.

BTW, for the time being, the remapping itself is done in alsa-lib route plugin. This works when the driver is unique and supports only a single configuration. Then you can define the routing table beforehand. Take a look at alsa-lib/src/conf/cards/*.conf based on old AC97 codecs.

Thanks for the advice! I could remap the channels succesfully with the alsa-lib route plugin. It increased the CPU usage when using speaker-test, though; from 2% to ~5%, according to top. I guess this is acceptable for now.

Quoted 4 lines

OTOH, if the driver is generic (e.g. HD-audio) and supports different configurations, it doesn't work so easily. A more generic API is mandatory in such a case.

Maybe I can statically remap the channels in the driver to align with speaker-test and post in omappedia how to remap if someone needs to. This in case their HDMI sinks supports a different HDMI layout.

Thanks!

Ricardo

Quoted 3 lines

Takashi