Skip to contentSkip to conversation

powertop putting far too much blame on wifi

Powertop Peter F. Patel-Schneider 5 participants 7 messages Dec 30, 2013 – Jan 7, 2014

lore
Share & tools
lore

Peter F. Patel-Schneider

author
#0 lore raw

Hi:

I just got a Lenovo Yoga 2 Pro, and I'mrunning Fedora 20 on it.

I'm trying to get power usage down with powertop, but it is producing some
screwy numbers. When I run the machine with wifi on, I get idle consumption
just under 7.2W but almost 5W of that is assigned to the WiFi interface, even though there is little traffic. When I turn the wifi off, power consumption only drops to just under 7W. I don't think that there is a phantom WiFi that is still consuming power, so it appears to me that powertop is assigning too much blame to the WiFi interface.

Is there away of fixing the assignment of blame here?

peter

PS: Here are truncated typical powertop outputs, first with wifi on and then with wifi off.

1/
The battery reports a discharge rate of 7.15 W The estimated remaining time is 3 hours, 39 minutes

Summary: 251.9 wakeups/second, 4.2 GPU ops/seconds, 0.0 VFS ops/sec and 1.6% CPU use

Power est. Usage Events/s Category Description
4.82 W 1.2 pkts/s Device Network interface: wlp1s0 (iwlwifi) 1.72 W 10.0% Device Display backlight
131 mW 13.1 ms/s 188.4 Process /usr/lib64/thunderbird/thunderbird
11.7 mW 398.5 µs/s 19.9 Process [irq/61-iwlwifi]

2/
The battery reports a discharge rate of 6.92 W The estimated remaining time is 3 hours, 42 minutes

Summary: 453.6 wakeups/second, 23.2 GPU ops/seconds, 0.0 VFS ops/sec and 3.0% CPU use

Power est. Usage Events/s Category Description
1.47 W 10.0% Device Display backlight
205 mW 14.4 ms/s 197.5 Process /usr/lib64/thunderbird/thunderbird 184 mW 2.2 ms/s 34.1 Process /usr/bin/xfce4-terminal 110 mW 2.4 ms/s 164.4 Interrupt PS/2 Touchpad / Keyboard / Mouse

#1 lore raw
Quoted 46 lines · Peter

Hi:

I just got a Lenovo Yoga 2 Pro, and I'mrunning Fedora 20 on it.

I'm trying to get power usage down with powertop, but it is producing some
screwy numbers. When I run the machine with wifi on, I get idle
consumption just under 7.2W but almost 5W of that is assigned to the WiFi interface, even though there is little traffic. When I turn the wifi off, power consumption only drops to just under 7W. I don't think that there is a phantom WiFi that is still consuming power, so it appears to me that powertop is assigning too much blame to the WiFi interface.

Is there away of fixing the assignment of blame here?

peter

PS: Here are truncated typical powertop outputs, first with wifi on and then with wifi off.

1/
The battery reports a discharge rate of 7.15 W The estimated remaining time is 3 hours, 39 minutes

Summary: 251.9 wakeups/second, 4.2 GPU ops/seconds, 0.0 VFS ops/sec and 1.6% CPU use

Power est. Usage Events/s Category Description
4.82 W 1.2 pkts/s Device Network interface: wlp1s0 (iwlwifi) 1.72 W 10.0% Device Display backlight
131 mW 13.1 ms/s 188.4 Process /usr/lib64/thunderbird/thunderbird
11.7 mW 398.5 µs/s 19.9 Process [irq/61-iwlwifi]

2/
The battery reports a discharge rate of 6.92 W The estimated remaining time is 3 hours, 42 minutes

Summary: 453.6 wakeups/second, 23.2 GPU ops/seconds, 0.0 VFS ops/sec and 3.0% CPU use

Power est. Usage Events/s Category Description
1.47 W 10.0% Device Display backlight
205 mW 14.4 ms/s 197.5 Process /usr/lib64/thunderbird/thunderbird 184 mW 2.2 ms/s 34.1 Process /usr/bin/xfce4-terminal 110 mW 2.4 ms/s 164.4 Interrupt PS/2 Touchpad / Keyboard / Mouse

Quoted 4 lines

_______________________________________________
PowerTop mailing list
PowerTop(a)lists.01.org
https://lists.01.org/mailman/listinfo/powertop

Yeah. The computation algorithm seems totally off for me.

Currently I get 16.8W for backlight while total is 24W, and CPU is reported to consume 0W despite ~70% usage.

Signature · 1 line
Ivan Shapovalov / intelfx /
#2 lore raw
Quoted 13 lines · Ivan Shapovalov
Quoted 12 lines · Peter

Hi:

I just got a Lenovo Yoga 2 Pro, and I'mrunning Fedora 20 on it.

I'm trying to get power usage down with powertop, but it is producing some
screwy numbers. When I run the machine with wifi on, I get idle
consumption just under 7.2W but almost 5W of that is assigned to the WiFi interface, even though there is little traffic. When I turn the wifi off, power consumption only drops to just under 7W. I don't think that there is a phantom WiFi that is still consuming power, so it appears to me that powertop is assigning too much blame to the WiFi interface.

Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line

Is there away of fixing the assignment of blame here?

Unfortunately, it's not just you. I've reported the same problem multiple times over the last year, but not heard back from anyone yet (except you saying you see the same).

I had this on a T530, and now it's even worse on a T540:
The battery reports a discharge rate of 28.5 W The estimated remaining time is 1 hours, 53 minutes

Summary: 689.5 wakeups/second, 214.0 GPU ops/seconds, 0.0 VFS ops/sec and 10.4% CPU use

Power est. Usage Events/s Category Description

  15.3 W     95.8%                      Device         Display backlight
  2.07 W     36.0 ms/s     642.4        Process        /usr/bin/enlightenment
  115 mW      4.5 ms/s      62.3        Interrupt      PS/2 Touchpad / Keyboard / Mouse
 86.8 mW      0.9 ms/s      37.0        Process        xfce4-terminal -T window11 --role=window11 --tab
 71.3 mW     35.4 ms/s      36.2        Process        /usr/bin/X :0 vt7 -br -nolisten tcp -auth /var/r
 51.2 mW      0.8 ms/s      27.9        Timer          hrtimer_wakeup

15W for my backlight at mid brightness? I don't think so.

Last time, I was getting unrealistic values for a USB key, then other things, it's just all over the map :(

Marc

Signature · 4 lines
"A mouse is a device used to point at the xterm you want to type in" - A.S.R.
Microsoft is to operating systems ....
                                      .... what McDonalds is to gourmet cooking
Home page: http://marc.merlins.org/                         | PGP 1024R/763BE901
#3 lore raw

Hi,

Quoted 13 lines · On Sun, Jan 05, 2014 at 12:00:02PM -0800, powertop-request(a)lists.01.org wrote:

From: Marc MERLIN <marc_powertop(a)merlins.org>

Unfortunately, it's not just you. I've reported the same problem multiple times over the last year, but not heard back from anyone yet (except you saying you see the same).

I had this on a T530, and now it's even worse on a T540:
The battery reports a discharge rate of 28.5 W The estimated remaining time is 1 hours, 53 minutes

Summary: 689.5 wakeups/second, 214.0 GPU ops/seconds, 0.0 VFS ops/sec and 10.4% CPU use

Power est. Usage Events/s Category Description

Quoted 8 lines
  15.3 W     95.8%                      Device         Display backlight
  2.07 W     36.0 ms/s     642.4        Process        /usr/bin/enlightenment
  115 mW      4.5 ms/s      62.3        Interrupt      PS/2 Touchpad / Keyboard / Mouse
 86.8 mW      0.9 ms/s      37.0        Process        xfce4-terminal -T window11 --role=window11 --tab
 71.3 mW     35.4 ms/s      36.2        Process        /usr/bin/X :0 vt7 -br -nolisten tcp -auth /var/r
 51.2 mW      0.8 ms/s      27.9        Timer          hrtimer_wakeup

15W for my backlight at mid brightness? I don't think so.

600+ wakeups/second sounds like the usual intermediate activity due to touchpad/mouse movement (that figure is exactly what I usually got on my machine), and if that is the case
(what happens if the human part gets its dirty fingers off the machine? :) then it's strange to see this otherwise *very high* value (642.4) attributed to /usr/bin/enlightenment (a very seasoned/stable WM, for crying out loud) rather than mouse as in the *directly following*
PS/2 Touchpad / Keyboard / Mouse
line.

Or, in other words, this example hints at a rather mischievous mixup of data, e.g. an off-by-1 or a post-insert of certain items without accounting for other columns (within the data model, of course), or perhaps (the column data values might even support such a suspicion) even completely wrong (re-sorted) display of data.

Perhaps I should actually test/investigate a recent powertop version... ;)

Andreas Mohr

Signature · 1 line
GNU/Linux. It's not the software that's free, it's you.
#4 lore raw
Quoted 3 lines · Andreas

Hi,

On Sun, Jan 05, 2014 at 12:00:02PM -0800, powertop-request(a)lists.01.org

Quoted 42 lines · wrote:
Quoted 17 lines

From: Marc MERLIN <marc_powertop(a)merlins.org>

Unfortunately, it's not just you. I've reported the same problem multiple times over the last year, but not heard back from anyone yet (except you saying you see the same).

I had this on a T530, and now it's even worse on a T540:
The battery reports a discharge rate of 28.5 W The estimated remaining time is 1 hours, 53 minutes

Summary: 689.5 wakeups/second, 214.0 GPU ops/seconds, 0.0 VFS ops/sec and 10.4% CPU use

Power est. Usage Events/s Category Description

  15.3 W     95.8%                      Device         Display backlight
  2.07 W     36.0 ms/s     642.4        Process       
Quoted 8 lines

/usr/bin/enlightenment
115 mW 4.5 ms/s 62.3 Interrupt PS/2 Touchpad /
Keyboard / Mouse>
86.8 mW 0.9 ms/s 37.0 Process xfce4-terminal -T
window11 --role=window11 --tab 71.3 mW 35.4 ms/s 36.2
Process /usr/bin/X :0 vt7 -br -nolisten tcp -auth /var/r 51.2 mW
0.8 ms/s 27.9 Timer hrtimer_wakeup>
15W for my backlight at mid brightness? I don't think so.

600+ wakeups/second sounds like the usual intermediate activity due to touchpad/mouse movement (that figure is exactly what I usually got on my machine), and if that is the case
(what happens if the human part gets its dirty fingers off the machine? :) then it's strange to see this otherwise *very high* value (642.4) attributed to /usr/bin/enlightenment (a very seasoned/stable WM, for crying out loud) rather than mouse as in the *directly following*
PS/2 Touchpad / Keyboard / Mouse
line.

Or, in other words, this example hints at a rather mischievous mixup of data, e.g. an off-by-1 or a post-insert of certain items without accounting for other columns (within the data model, of course), or perhaps (the column data values might even support such a suspicion) even completely wrong (re-sorted) display of data.

Quoted 3 lines

Perhaps I should actually test/investigate a recent powertop version... ;)

Andreas Mohr

IMHO, the usage and event counters seem to be valid. What's wrong is energy
estimation: it is done entirely in software, using some strange semi-heuristic guesswork.

Signature · 1 line
Ivan Shapovalov / intelfx /
#5 lore raw
Quoted 66 lines · Andreas
Quoted 3 lines

Hi,

On Sun, Jan 05, 2014 at 12:00:02PM -0800, powertop-request(a)lists.01.org

Quoted 50 lines · wrote:
Quoted 11 lines

From: Marc MERLIN <marc_powertop(a)merlins.org>

Unfortunately, it's not just you. I've reported the same problem multiple times over the last year, but not heard back from anyone yet (except you saying you see the same).

I had this on a T530, and now it's even worse on a T540:
The battery reports a discharge rate of 28.5 W The estimated remaining time is 1 hours, 53 minutes

Summary: 689.5 wakeups/second, 214.0 GPU ops/seconds, 0.0 VFS ops/sec

and

Quoted 3 lines

10.4% CPU use

Power est. Usage Events/s Category

Description

Quoted 2 lines

15.3 W 95.8% Device Display

backlight

Quoted 5 lines

2.07 W 36.0 ms/s 642.4 Process
/usr/bin/enlightenment
115 mW 4.5 ms/s 62.3 Interrupt PS/2 Touchpad /
Keyboard / Mouse>
86.8 mW 0.9 ms/s 37.0 Process xfce4-terminal

-T

Quoted 2 lines

window11 --role=window11 --tab 71.3 mW 35.4 ms/s 36.2
Process /usr/bin/X :0 vt7 -br -nolisten tcp -auth /var/r 51.2

mW

Quoted 2 lines

0.8 ms/s 27.9 Timer hrtimer_wakeup>
15W for my backlight at mid brightness? I don't think so.

600+ wakeups/second sounds like the usual intermediate activity due to touchpad/mouse movement (that figure is exactly what I usually got
on my machine), and if that is the case
(what happens if the human part gets its dirty fingers off the machine? :)
then it's strange to see this otherwise *very high* value (642.4) attributed to /usr/bin/enlightenment (a very seasoned/stable WM, for crying out loud) rather than mouse as in the *directly following*
PS/2 Touchpad / Keyboard / Mouse
line.

Or, in other words, this example hints at a rather mischievous mixup of data, e.g. an off-by-1 or a post-insert of certain items without accounting
for other columns (within the data model, of course), or perhaps (the column data values might even support such a suspicion) even completely wrong (re-sorted) display of data.

Quoted 4 lines

Perhaps I should actually test/investigate a recent powertop version... ;)

Andreas Mohr

IMHO, the usage and event counters seem to be valid. What's wrong is energy
estimation: it is done entirely in software, using some strange semi-heuristic
guesswork.

Quoted 6 lines

--
Ivan Shapovalov / intelfx /_______________________________________________ PowerTop mailing list
PowerTop(a)lists.01.org
https://lists.01.org/mailman/listinfo/powertop

Try disabling the device and rerunning PowerTOP see if there is a difference there. You could send the debug output to find out what are your wifi parameters.

Thank you,
Alexandra.

#6 lore raw
Quoted 5 lines · Alexandra Yates
Quoted 5 lines

IMHO, the usage and event counters seem to be valid. What's wrong is energy
estimation: it is done entirely in software, using some strange semi-heuristic
guesswork.

For me, the most likely incorrect usage report just shifts to another line if it's a device I can remove (although most often it's integrated in the laptop, so I can't remove it).

Marc

Signature · 4 lines
"A mouse is a device used to point at the xterm you want to type in" - A.S.R.
Microsoft is to operating systems ....
                                      .... what McDonalds is to gourmet cooking
Home page: http://marc.merlins.org/                         | PGP 1024R/763BE901