Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Using PACKAGECONFIG

DISCUSSION Gary Thomas 2 participants 4 messages Apr 9, 2015

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

I'm trying to extend PACKAGECONFIG for a recipe (vlc). The
main recipe contains this:
PACKAGECONFIG ?= " live555"
PACKAGECONFIG[mad] = "--enable-mad,--disable-mad,libmad"
PACKAGECONFIG[a52] = "--enable-a52,--disable-a52,liba52"
PACKAGECONFIG[jack] = "--enable-jack,--disable-jack,jack"
PACKAGECONFIG[live555] = "--enable-live555,--disable-live555,live555" PACKAGECONFIG[libass] = "--enable-libass,--disable-libass,libass"
PACKAGECONFIG[mkv] = "--enable-mkv,--disable-mkv,libmatroska libebml" PACKAGECONFIG[postproc] = "--enable-postproc,--disable-postproc,libpostproc" PACKAGECONFIG[opencv] = "--enable-opencv,--disable-opencv,opencv" PACKAGECONFIG[libva] = "--enable-libva --enable-avcodec,--disable-libva --disable-avcodec,libva libav"

I'd like to only add "libva" to the default, so I wrote this in my local.conf:
PACKAGECONFIG_pn-vlc_append = " libva"
Inspecting it

  $ bitbake vlc -e | grep ^PACKAGECONFIG
  PACKAGECONFIG=" libva"

Oops. Just to be sure, I tried
PACKAGECONFIG_pn-vlc = "live555 libva"
which gives

  $ bitbake vlc -e | grep ^PACKAGECONFIG
  PACKAGECONFIG="live555 libva"

Note: I tried
PACKAGECONFIG_append_pn-vlc = " libva"
which does work. However, I've also used
PACKAGECONFIG_pn-chromium_append = " component-build"
for a different recipe that does work... VERY CONFUSED

What am I doing wrong? How do I correctly add to the default list?

Signature · 4 lines
------------------------------------------------------------
Gary Thomas                 |  Consulting for the
MLB Associates              |    Embedded world
------------------------------------------------------------
#1 lore raw

Hi Gary,

Quoted 28 lines · On Thursday 09 April 2015 07:45:47 Gary Thomas wrote:

I'm trying to extend PACKAGECONFIG for a recipe (vlc). The main recipe contains this:
PACKAGECONFIG ?= " live555"
PACKAGECONFIG[mad] = "--enable-mad,--disable-mad,libmad" PACKAGECONFIG[a52] = "--enable-a52,--disable-a52,liba52" PACKAGECONFIG[jack] = "--enable-jack,--disable-jack,jack" PACKAGECONFIG[live555] = "--enable-live555,--disable-live555,live555" PACKAGECONFIG[libass] = "--enable-libass,--disable-libass,libass" PACKAGECONFIG[mkv] = "--enable-mkv,--disable-mkv,libmatroska libebml" PACKAGECONFIG[postproc] =
"--enable-postproc,--disable-postproc,libpostproc" PACKAGECONFIG[opencv] = "--enable-opencv,--disable-opencv,opencv" PACKAGECONFIG[libva] = "--enable-libva --enable-avcodec,--disable-libva --disable-avcodec,libva libav"

I'd like to only add "libva" to the default, so I wrote this in my local.conf:
PACKAGECONFIG_pn-vlc_append = " libva"
Inspecting it

   $ bitbake vlc -e | grep ^PACKAGECONFIG
   PACKAGECONFIG=" libva"

Oops. Just to be sure, I tried
PACKAGECONFIG_pn-vlc = "live555 libva"
which gives

   $ bitbake vlc -e | grep ^PACKAGECONFIG
   PACKAGECONFIG="live555 libva"
Quoted 7 lines

Note: I tried
PACKAGECONFIG_append_pn-vlc = " libva"
which does work. However, I've also used
PACKAGECONFIG_pn-chromium_append = " component-build"
for a different recipe that does work... VERY CONFUSED

What am I doing wrong? How do I correctly add to the default list?

In general, for a conditional append, you must use _append_<override> - the other way around will not do an append, AFAIK it will just set the value.

There are some other valid options that you didn't mention above:

1) Set it outright to list all of the options you want instead of appending. At least you know exactly what is going into the value. (I know some people don't like this.)

2) Set it using += or _append from a bbappend.

Cheers,
Paul

Signature · 2 lines
Paul Eggleton
Intel Open Source Technology Centre
#2 lore raw
Quoted 54 lines · On Thursday 09 April 2015 15:16:58 Paul Eggleton wrote:

Hi Gary,

Quoted 40 lines · On Thursday 09 April 2015 07:45:47 Gary Thomas wrote:

I'm trying to extend PACKAGECONFIG for a recipe (vlc). The

main recipe contains this:
PACKAGECONFIG ?= " live555"
PACKAGECONFIG[mad] = "--enable-mad,--disable-mad,libmad" PACKAGECONFIG[a52] = "--enable-a52,--disable-a52,liba52" PACKAGECONFIG[jack] = "--enable-jack,--disable-jack,jack" PACKAGECONFIG[live555] = "--enable-live555,--disable-live555,live555" PACKAGECONFIG[libass] = "--enable-libass,--disable-libass,libass" PACKAGECONFIG[mkv] = "--enable-mkv,--disable-mkv,libmatroska libebml" PACKAGECONFIG[postproc] =

"--enable-postproc,--disable-postproc,libpostproc" PACKAGECONFIG[opencv] = "--enable-opencv,--disable-opencv,opencv" PACKAGECONFIG[libva] = "--enable-libva --enable-avcodec,--disable-libva --disable-avcodec,libva libav"

I'd like to only add "libva" to the default, so I wrote this

in my local.conf:
PACKAGECONFIG_pn-vlc_append = " libva"

Inspecting it

   $ bitbake vlc -e | grep ^PACKAGECONFIG
   PACKAGECONFIG=" libva"

Oops. Just to be sure, I tried

PACKAGECONFIG_pn-vlc = "live555 libva"

which gives

   $ bitbake vlc -e | grep ^PACKAGECONFIG
   PACKAGECONFIG="live555 libva"

Note: I tried

PACKAGECONFIG_append_pn-vlc = " libva"

Quoted 7 lines

which does work. However, I've also used

PACKAGECONFIG_pn-chromium_append = " component-build"

for a different recipe that does work... VERY CONFUSED

What am I doing wrong? How do I correctly add to the default list?

In general, for a conditional append, you must use _append_<override> - the other way around will not do an append, AFAIK it will just set the value.

Quoted 7 lines

There are some other valid options that you didn't mention above:

1) Set it outright to list all of the options you want instead of appending. At least you know exactly what is going into the value. (I know some people don't like this.)

2) Set it using += or _append from a bbappend.

(although I hasten to add, += from a bbappend will only work if the original value is set with ?= rather than ??=... probably safest to stick with _append)

Cheers,
Paul

Signature · 2 lines
Paul Eggleton
Intel Open Source Technology Centre
#3 lore raw
In reply to Paul Eggleton
Quoted 42 lines · Paul Eggleton

Hi Gary,

Quoted 28 lines · On Thursday 09 April 2015 07:45:47 Gary Thomas wrote:

I'm trying to extend PACKAGECONFIG for a recipe (vlc). The main recipe contains this:
PACKAGECONFIG ?= " live555"
PACKAGECONFIG[mad] = "--enable-mad,--disable-mad,libmad" PACKAGECONFIG[a52] = "--enable-a52,--disable-a52,liba52" PACKAGECONFIG[jack] = "--enable-jack,--disable-jack,jack" PACKAGECONFIG[live555] = "--enable-live555,--disable-live555,live555" PACKAGECONFIG[libass] = "--enable-libass,--disable-libass,libass" PACKAGECONFIG[mkv] = "--enable-mkv,--disable-mkv,libmatroska libebml" PACKAGECONFIG[postproc] =
"--enable-postproc,--disable-postproc,libpostproc" PACKAGECONFIG[opencv] = "--enable-opencv,--disable-opencv,opencv" PACKAGECONFIG[libva] = "--enable-libva --enable-avcodec,--disable-libva --disable-avcodec,libva libav"

I'd like to only add "libva" to the default, so I wrote this in my local.conf:
PACKAGECONFIG_pn-vlc_append = " libva"
Inspecting it

    $ bitbake vlc -e | grep ^PACKAGECONFIG
    PACKAGECONFIG=" libva"

Oops. Just to be sure, I tried
PACKAGECONFIG_pn-vlc = "live555 libva"
which gives

    $ bitbake vlc -e | grep ^PACKAGECONFIG
    PACKAGECONFIG="live555 libva"
Quoted 7 lines

Note: I tried
PACKAGECONFIG_append_pn-vlc = " libva"
which does work. However, I've also used
PACKAGECONFIG_pn-chromium_append = " component-build"
for a different recipe that does work... VERY CONFUSED

What am I doing wrong? How do I correctly add to the default list?

In general, for a conditional append, you must use _append_<override> - the other way around will not do an append, AFAIK it will just set the value.

Quoted 7 lines

There are some other valid options that you didn't mention above:

1) Set it outright to list all of the options you want instead of appending. At least you know exactly what is going into the value. (I know some people don't like this.)

2) Set it using += or _append from a bbappend.

Thanks for the explanation - I'll make sure to use the correct form from now on (and fix my incorrect uses for chromium!)

Signature · 4 lines
------------------------------------------------------------
Gary Thomas                 |  Consulting for the
MLB Associates              |    Embedded world
------------------------------------------------------------