Skip to contentSkip to conversation

"raid" versions of hard drives for software raid?

DISCUSSION Dan Christensen 4 participants 7 messages Jul 2, 2008 – Jul 3, 2008 MD RAID

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

I'm looking at either the Western Digital 500G RE2 drives or the cheaper 500G SE16 drives. I have read that for use with a hardware raid card, the RE2 drives are more appropriate, and I'm wondering if the same is true for software raid.

I am planning to get two drives, and may use the entire drives as RAID1, or I might partition the drives and use most of the partitions in a RAID1 configuration, but leave a few of the partitions without RAID.

Suggestions appreciated (even suggestions for another drive I should consider).

I do like the 5 year warranty on the RE2 drives and the increased MTBF, as I do have a long history of drive failures...

Thanks,

Dan

#1 lore raw
Quoted 4 lines · Dan Christensen

I'm looking at either the Western Digital 500G RE2 drives or the cheaper 500G SE16 drives. I have read that for use with a hardware raid card, the RE2 drives are more appropriate, and I'm wondering if the same is true for software raid.

It's a mechanical property- vibration tolerance and whatnot. No difference between software and hardware raid in this sense.

Quoted 9 lines

I am planning to get two drives, and may use the entire drives as RAID1, or I might partition the drives and use most of the partitions in a RAID1 configuration, but leave a few of the partitions without RAID.

Suggestions appreciated (even suggestions for another drive I should consider).

I do like the 5 year warranty on the RE2 drives and the increased MTBF, as I do have a long history of drive failures...

I have 5 400GB RE2 drives in a RAID5 array (software raid, naturally). That 5 year warranty has come in handy- only 1 of the original drives still remains. 5 RMAs in under 3 years. Maybe the 500GB is better.

Signature · 1 line
Brendan Conoboy / Red Hat, Inc. / [email protected]
#2 lore raw
Quoted 12 lines · Brendan Conoboy
Quoted 4 lines · Dan Christensen

I'm looking at either the Western Digital 500G RE2 drives or the cheaper 500G SE16 drives. I have read that for use with a hardware raid card, the RE2 drives are more appropriate, and I'm wondering if the same is true for software raid.

It's a mechanical property- vibration tolerance and whatnot. No difference between software and hardware raid in this sense.

Quoted 4 lines

I am planning to get two drives, and may use the entire drives as RAID1, or I might partition the drives and use most of the partitions in a RAID1 configuration, but leave a few of the partitions without RAID.

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 5 lines

Suggestions appreciated (even suggestions for another drive I should consider).

I do like the 5 year warranty on the RE2 drives and the increased MTBF, as I do have a long history of drive failures...

I have 5 400GB RE2 drives in a RAID5 array (software raid, naturally). That 5 year warranty has come in handy- only 1 of the original drives still remains. 5 RMAs in under 3 years. Maybe the 500GB is better.

That's a lot of RMA's, bad PSU or vibration issues, or a bad lot of drives?

#3 lore raw
Quoted 1 line · Justin Piszcz

That's a lot of RMA's, bad PSU or vibration issues, or a bad lot of drives?

My educated case is that it was a bad batch of drives (Bought them sooner after their introduction). Drives in the enclosure from other MFR's have held up reliably and heat has been a non-issue.

Dan might want to see if hdparm has a tunable for the TLER setting he's concerned about. Modern mdadm versions will attempt to rewrite a sector if there's a read error using parity or mirrors to reconstruct the data.
For this purpose having a short timeout before getting an error would
be preferable to waiting a couple minutes.

Signature · 1 line
Brendan Conoboy / Red Hat, Inc. / [email protected]
#4 lore raw
In reply to Brendan Conoboy
Quoted 8 lines · Brendan Conoboy
Quoted 4 lines · Dan Christensen

I'm looking at either the Western Digital 500G RE2 drives or the cheaper 500G SE16 drives. I have read that for use with a hardware raid card, the RE2 drives are more appropriate, and I'm wondering if the same is true for software raid.

It's a mechanical property- vibration tolerance and whatnot. No difference between software and hardware raid in this sense.

The difference that is most commonly described, and that I should have highlighted, is TLER: Time-Limited Error Recovery. Apparently, the SE16 drives can take a long time to recover from an error (up to two minutes, I believe), and hardware raid controllers can kick the drives out of the array when it would instead be better for the drive to return a read/write error and let the raid controller deal with it.

My question is really whether this logic applies to linux software raid.

One other point is that I also read that TLER can be enabled and disabled for both SE16 and RE2 drives using Windows software. Not sure if it runs under wine. See

http://www.hardforum.com/archive/index.php/t-1285254.html

Dan

#5 lore raw
Quoted 6 lines · Dan Christensen
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 4 lines · Dan Christensen

I'm looking at either the Western Digital 500G RE2 drives or the cheaper 500G SE16 drives. I have read that for use with a hardware raid card, the RE2 drives are more appropriate, and I'm wondering if the same is true for software raid.

Quoted 8 lines

The difference that is most commonly described, and that I should have highlighted, is TLER: Time-Limited Error Recovery. Apparently, the SE16 drives can take a long time to recover from an error (up to two minutes, I believe), and hardware raid controllers can kick the drives out of the array when it would instead be better for the drive to return a read/write error and let the raid controller deal with it.

My question is really whether this logic applies to linux software raid.

One more reference:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time-Limited_Error_Recovery

It certainly sounds to me like TLER is also appropriate for software raid, so I'm going to go ahead and get the RE2 drives.

Dan

#6 lore raw
Quoted 16 lines · Dan Christensen
Quoted 5 lines · Dan Christensen
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 4 lines · Dan Christensen

I'm looking at either the Western Digital 500G RE2 drives or the cheaper 500G SE16 drives. I have read that for use with a hardware raid card, the RE2 drives are more appropriate, and I'm wondering if the same is true for software raid.

Quoted 8 lines

The difference that is most commonly described, and that I should have highlighted, is TLER: Time-Limited Error Recovery. Apparently, the SE16 drives can take a long time to recover from an error (up to two minutes, I believe), and hardware raid controllers can kick the drives out of the array when it would instead be better for the drive to return a read/write error and let the raid controller deal with it.

My question is really whether this logic applies to linux software raid.

Quoted 8 lines

One more reference:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time-Limited_Error_Recovery

It certainly sounds to me like TLER is also appropriate for software raid, so I'm going to go ahead and get the RE2 drives.

Dan

If you were trying to salvage as much data as possible off of a drive TLER would also be nice, since it would lower the time to get a bad sector error.

I don't really understand how much use it is to try that many times, the drive should be able to try 1x per rev, so at 7200, 120 times per second, I would wonder how many times that they get a good read after having failed the first 120 times, much less after the first 7 seconds (960 failures) of trying, or even longer periods without TLER.

In fact I would think for a RAID drive one would want even lower than 7 seconds.

Roger