Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Bmcweb redfish multiple host support

DISCUSSION Naveen Moses S 2 participants 4 messages Jul 1, 2021 – Jul 7, 2021

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hello All,

I need your suggestion on implementing support for multiple computer systems or hosts under redfish implementation of BMCWEB.

Redfish schema supports multiple computer systems under redfish path "/redfish/v1/Systems/"

Currently in bmcweb redfish core Computer systems path are is configured for as singlehost

The redfish path computer system is given below
"/redfish/v1/Systems/system”

In case of multiple hosts can we use the following format.

"/redfish/v1/Systems/system1”
"/redfish/v1/Systems/system2”
"/redfish/v1/Systems/system3”
"/redfish/v1/Systems/system4”

these paths should be populated based on the number of available hosts/computer systems

Possible options to identify the host count are as given below:
1.pass the OBMC_HOST_INSTANCES as a macro definition to bmcweb
2.Query dbus objects which has individual instance available for each host using object mapper.

Is there any other alternate way available for identifying host instances at runtime under bmcweb?

if we use the above format then can we change the computer system for single host

as given below

"/redfish/v1/Systems/system0”

Code reference : https://github.com/openbmc/bmcweb/blob/master/redfish-core/lib/systems.hpp

method : requestRoutesSystemsCollection

Thanks

#1 lore raw
Quoted 19 lines · Naveen Moses S

Hello All,

I need your suggestion on implementing support for multiple computer systems or hosts under redfish implementation of BMCWEB.

Redfish schema supports multiple computer systems under redfish path "/redfish/v1/Systems/"

Currently in bmcweb redfish core Computer systems path are is configured for as singlehost

The redfish path computer system is given below
"/redfish/v1/Systems/system”

In case of multiple hosts can we use the following format.

"/redfish/v1/Systems/system1”
"/redfish/v1/Systems/system2”
"/redfish/v1/Systems/system3”
"/redfish/v1/Systems/system4”

Quoted 4 lines

these paths should be populated based on the number of available hosts/computer systems

Possible options to identify the host count are as given below:
1.pass the OBMC_HOST_INSTANCES as a macro definition to bmcweb

Please don't do this. In general we only use configure options for things that cannot be dynamically discovered on dbus or via the mapper, or where different implementations of things exist that meet the same API (like log service). I don't think multi-host falls into either of those categories, as it can be seen on dbus.

Quoted 1 line

2.Query dbus objects which has individual instance available for each host using object mapper.

This would far and above be my preference, as it's similar to how the rest of the bmcweb URIs function.

Quoted 9 lines

Is there any other alternate way available for identifying host instances at runtime under bmcweb?

if we use the above format then can we change the computer system for single host

as given below

"/redfish/v1/Systems/system0”

I would much prefer these are just based on the dbus path names instead of trying to explicitly pick a name. That keeps bmcweb consistent with other resources, and systems that only implement a single host can choose to keep the same odata.id (system) if they want.

Quoted 8 lines

Code reference : https://github.com/openbmc/bmcweb/blob/master/redfish-core/lib/systems.hpp

method : requestRoutesSystemsCollection

Thanks

Looking forward to seeing the patches. Thanks for looking into this.

-Ed

#2 lore raw

Hi Ed,

Thanks for your insights. we will work on it accordingly.

If possible could you also clarify the following :

In redfish, /redfish/v1/Systems/system is used to store host/server related information.
For LogServices, journal based logs are stored under the below path.
/redfish/v1/Systems/system/LogServices/EventLog/Entries
But few logs like sensor & FRU logs are related to BMC, which is displaying under system path. Could you please clarify why these logs are stored under this system path. Whether can we take this under different path.

Thanks

On 01-Jul-2021, at 9:58 PM, Ed Tanous <[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>> wrote:

On Thu, Jul 1, 2021 at 9:10 AM Naveen Moses S <[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>> wrote:

Hello All,

I need your suggestion on implementing support for multiple computer systems or hosts under redfish implementation of BMCWEB.

Redfish schema supports multiple computer systems under redfish path "/redfish/v1/Systems/"

Currently in bmcweb redfish core Computer systems path are is configured for as singlehost

The redfish path computer system is given below
"/redfish/v1/Systems/system”

In case of multiple hosts can we use the following format.

"/redfish/v1/Systems/system1”
"/redfish/v1/Systems/system2”
"/redfish/v1/Systems/system3”
"/redfish/v1/Systems/system4”

these paths should be populated based on the number of available hosts/computer systems

Possible options to identify the host count are as given below:
1.pass the OBMC_HOST_INSTANCES as a macro definition to bmcweb

Please don't do this. In general we only use configure options for things that cannot be dynamically discovered on dbus or via the mapper, or where different implementations of things exist that meet the same API (like log service). I don't think multi-host falls into either of those categories, as it can be seen on dbus.

2.Query dbus objects which has individual instance available for each host using object mapper.

This would far and above be my preference, as it's similar to how the rest of the bmcweb URIs function.

Is there any other alternate way available for identifying host instances at runtime under bmcweb?

if we use the above format then can we change the computer system for single host

as given below

"/redfish/v1/Systems/system0”

I would much prefer these are just based on the dbus path names instead of trying to explicitly pick a name. That keeps bmcweb consistent with other resources, and systems that only implement a single host can choose to keep the same odata.id<http://odata.id/> (system) if they want.

Code reference : https://github.com/openbmc/bmcweb/blob/master/redfish-core/lib/systems.hpp

method : requestRoutesSystemsCollection

Thanks

Looking forward to seeing the patches. Thanks for looking into this.

-Ed

#3 lore raw
Quoted 11 lines · Naveen Moses S

Hi Ed,

Thanks for your insights. we will work on it accordingly.

If possible could you also clarify the following :

In redfish, /redfish/v1/Systems/system is used to store host/server related information.
For LogServices, journal based logs are stored under the below path.
/redfish/v1/Systems/system/LogServices/EventLog/Entries
But few logs like sensor & FRU logs are related to BMC, which is displaying under system path. Could you please clarify why these logs are stored under this system path.

Because this path was analogous to the SEL log, and that part didn't really matter at the time when there was only a single host; It likely could be improved, although maintaining backward compatibility is going to be difficult.

Quoted 1 line

Whether can we take this under different path.

I'd need more details on what you're thinking here before I can render an opinion.

Quoted 76 lines

Thanks

On 01-Jul-2021, at 9:58 PM, Ed Tanous <[email protected]> wrote:

On Thu, Jul 1, 2021 at 9:10 AM Naveen Moses S <[email protected]> wrote:

Hello All,

I need your suggestion on implementing support for multiple computer systems or hosts under redfish implementation of BMCWEB.

Redfish schema supports multiple computer systems under redfish path "/redfish/v1/Systems/"

Currently in bmcweb redfish core Computer systems path are is configured for as singlehost

The redfish path computer system is given below
"/redfish/v1/Systems/system”

In case of multiple hosts can we use the following format.

"/redfish/v1/Systems/system1”
"/redfish/v1/Systems/system2”
"/redfish/v1/Systems/system3”
"/redfish/v1/Systems/system4”

these paths should be populated based on the number of available hosts/computer systems

Possible options to identify the host count are as given below:
1.pass the OBMC_HOST_INSTANCES as a macro definition to bmcweb

Please don't do this. In general we only use configure options for things that cannot be dynamically discovered on dbus or via the mapper, or where different implementations of things exist that meet the same API (like log service). I don't think multi-host falls into either of those categories, as it can be seen on dbus.

2.Query dbus objects which has individual instance available for each host using object mapper.

This would far and above be my preference, as it's similar to how the rest of the bmcweb URIs function.

Is there any other alternate way available for identifying host instances at runtime under bmcweb?

if we use the above format then can we change the computer system for single host

as given below

"/redfish/v1/Systems/system0”

I would much prefer these are just based on the dbus path names instead of trying to explicitly pick a name. That keeps bmcweb consistent with other resources, and systems that only implement a single host can choose to keep the same odata.id (system) if they want.

Code reference : https://github.com/openbmc/bmcweb/blob/master/redfish-core/lib/systems.hpp

method : requestRoutesSystemsCollection

Thanks

Looking forward to seeing the patches. Thanks for looking into this.

-Ed