Proposed k3-binman.dtsi and k3-binman-capsule.dtsi cleanup
Hello,
We've got a device that's making it's way upstream "AM62Lx" that will break the current assumption in k3-binman.dtsi that specific binaries should or should not be produced based on the selected *architecture*.
Right now I've seen we're just adding a platform specific "*-binman.dtsi" to get around that, but realistically speaking it's not defining anything *new*.
I've got 2 ideas on how to clean this up a little bit. Wondering if this is worth doing and if so, which way we'll want to go.
---
1. New Kconfig options
I've seen that sunxi-u-boot.dtsi has a nice Kconfig parameter for their binary definitions. A pattern that rockchip-u-boot.dtsi has adopted mostly (with one exception that's still checking the compilation architecture).
I like this pattern. I think it's very clear that none of the binman definitions are actually architecture specific, it's just a byproduct of the specific device's boot-flow.
We could easily replicate this with a TI_K3_TIBOOT, TI_K3_TISPL, and TI_K3_UBOOT (or similarly named) Kconfig options to remove both the proposed platform specific binman.dtsi and the current k3-binman-capsule-r5.dtsi in one go.
It wouldn't require touching that many files, and we can keep a single clean include at the top of the u-boot.dtsi files. It'll also clean up the current conditional includes used for EFI capsule support.
---
2. Reuse existing Kconfig options
Almost every K3 platform supporting capsules already has an ifdef for the A53 and R5 target platform variants in their corresponding u-boot.dtsi. We could reuse that pattern and simply split the current k3-binman.dtsi into two parts.
This would be a little weird if we kept the r5 naming convention for the files though, as the new platform doesn't have an r5 involved in the boot process. I kind of want to use "primary" and "secondary" naming since the split would appear to be arbitrary without this whole explanation.
This also means we'll have to add this pattern to any platform's u-boot.dtsi that wasn't already supporting capsules. It'll result in an immediate line count increase across multiple files and a rather messy diff.
---
Curious what opinions people have before I start shuffling files on my end.
Regards,
Randolph
Hi Randolph,
Quoted 46 lines · Randolph Sapp
Hello,
We've got a device that's making it's way upstream "AM62Lx" that will break the current assumption in
k3-binman.dtsithat specific binaries should or should not be produced based on the selected *architecture*.Right now I've seen we're just adding a platform specific "*-binman.dtsi" to get around that, but realistically speaking it's not defining anything *new*.
I've got 2 ideas on how to clean this up a little bit. Wondering if this is worth doing and if so, which way we'll want to go.
---
1. New
KconfigoptionsI've seen that
sunxi-u-boot.dtsihas a niceKconfigparameter for their binary definitions. A pattern thatrockchip-u-boot.dtsihas adopted mostly (with one exception that's still checking the compilation architecture).I like this pattern. I think it's very clear that none of the binman definitions are actually architecture specific, it's just a byproduct of the specific device's boot-flow.
We could easily replicate this with a
TI_K3_TIBOOT,TI_K3_TISPL, andTI_K3_UBOOT(or similarly named)Kconfigoptions to remove both the proposed platform specificbinman.dtsiand the currentk3-binman-capsule-r5.dtsiin one go.It wouldn't require touching that many files, and we can keep a single clean include at the top of the
u-boot.dtsifiles. It'll also clean up the current conditional includes used for EFI capsule support.---
2. Reuse existing
KconfigoptionsAlmost every K3 platform supporting capsules already has an ifdef for the A53 and R5 target platform variants in their corresponding
u-boot.dtsi. We could reuse that pattern and simply split the currentk3-binman.dtsiinto two parts.This would be a little weird if we kept the r5 naming convention for the files though, as the new platform doesn't have an r5 involved in the boot process. I kind of want to use "primary" and "secondary" naming since the split would appear to be arbitrary without this whole explanation.
Quoted 7 lines
This also means we'll have to add this pattern to any platform's
u-boot.dtsithat wasn't already supporting capsules. It'll result in an immediate line count increase across multiple files and a rather messy diff.---
Curious what opinions people have before I start shuffling files on my end.
Option 1 seems much better to me. The real problem is that CONFIG_ARM64 is being used as a proxy for 'which images does this build produce', and this proxy is breaking down. So the fix is to make the condition say what it means.
A few suggestions:
- Name the options after the artefacts rather than the boot stage, e.g. TI_K3_BINMAN_TIBOOT3 / _TISPL / _UBOOT, since 'tiboot3.bin' etc. are the things being gated. Whatever the spelling, the option should read as "this build produces this image".
- Make them hidden options (no prompt), selected by the SoC/target Kconfig entries. Boards should not be able to choose an inconsistent set, and it keeps the cost per target to a single select.
- The two capsule files can then merge into one, with each gated on the same option as the image it wraps.
Obviously the genuinely architecture-specific parts (the FIT arch properties, load addresses) should stay keyed off CONFIG_ARM64
Regards,
Simon