Do I need kswapd if I don't have swap?
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
Can you try 2.6?
AFAIK 2.4 has no callpath to return ENOMEM to user space. (probably
in couple of months I will reach this issue on my systems and test it completely).
kswapd is universal process to write-out information to disk - and in
Linux pages has no any difference as kswapd concerned. It just dumbly write them out. If you will disable kswapd - files modified by mean of mmap() most likely will never be written back to disk. (Here I am (most likely) wrong - probably some of the vm gurus can correct me). That's actually why Linux has problems with disk cache and disk cache can easily swap the task doing i/o.
If you want to work-around this situation - enable OOM. it will just
kill your process instead.
Quoted 42 lines · David Wuertele
Using 2.4.18 on my 32MB RAM embedded MIPS system,
malloc()goes bye-bye:/* Malloc as much as possible, then return */ #include <stdio.h> #define UNIT 1024 /* one kilobyte */ int main () { unsigned int j, totalmalloc=0, totalwrote=0, totalread=0; while (1) { unsigned char *buf = (unsigned char *) malloc (UNIT); if (!buf) return 0; totalmalloc += UNIT; fprintf (stderr, "%u ", totalmalloc); for (j=0; j<UNIT; j++) buf[j] = j % 256; totalwrote += UNIT; fprintf (stderr, "%u ", totalwrote); for (j=0; j<UNIT; j++) if (buf[j] != (j % 256)) return -1; totalread += UNIT; fprintf (stderr, "%u\n", totalread); } }I expected this program to malloc most of my embedded MIPS's 32MB of system RAM, then eventually return with a -1 or a -2. Unfortunately, it hangs having finally printed:
M26916864
W26916864
R26916864The malloc call isn't even returning. What could explain that?
I don't have swap space configured, and I notice several kernel threads that I figure might be assuming I have swap. For example:
3 root S [ksoftirqd_CPU0] 4 root S [kswapd] 5 root S [bdflush] 6 root S [kupdated] 7 root S [mtdblockd]Do I need any of these if I don't have swap? Are there any special kernel configs I should be doing if I don't have swap?