BUG: race-cond with partition-check and ll_rw_blk (all platforms, 2.4.*!)
From: [email protected]
We just had a problem when running some formatting-utils on
a large amount of disks synchronously: We got a NULL-pointer violation when accessig blk_size[major] for our major number. Further research showed, that grok_partitions was running at that time, which has been called by register_disk, which our device driver issues after a disk has been formatted. Grok_partitions first initializes blk_size[major] with a NULL pointer, detects the partitions and then assigns the original value to blk_size[major] again.
Here's the interresting code from these functions, I cut some irrelevant things out:
From grok_paritions:
blk_size[dev->major] = NULL;
check_partition(dev, MKDEV(dev->major, first_minor), 1 + first_minor); if (dev->sizes != NULL) {
blk_size[dev->major] = dev->sizes;
};
From generic_make_request:
if (blk_size[major]) {
if (blk_size[major][MINOR(bh->b_rdev)]) {
Can anyone explain to me, why grok_partitions has to clear this pointer?
Well, among the irrelevant details you left out is the fact that it is not
blk_size[dev->major] = NULL; but if(!dev->sizes) blk_size[dev->major] = NULL; ... if (dev->sizes) blk_size[dev->major] = dev->sizes;
So, the idea is that either this major has an array with sizes, and then one can find it in blk_size[dev->major], or it hasn't. You seem to have a situation where dev->sizes is NULL but blk_size[dev->major] is not? What device is this?
Andries