Skip to contentSkip to conversation

bpf development stats for 6.5

ANN Stanislav Fomichev 4 participants 5 messages Jun 28, 2023 – Jul 19, 2023 BPF

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Same as last time, running Jakub's scripts against bpf tree, see netdev posting for more info on the methodology:
https://lore.kernel.org/netdev/[email protected]/T/#u

He also shared with me bpf stats for the previous cycle (a lot of work went into the scripts in these past two months, so my data was completely irrelevant), so we can have some comparisons!

As last time, I'm presenting raw stats without any evaluation. I'm also trying to present the same data as we have in netdev email so you can follow Jakub's comments about script changes/etc. One thing to note maybe is that we have a lot of cross-pollination with netdev list, so our stats change quite a bit depending on netdev activity :-)

Previous cycle:
21 Feb to 26 Apr: 5362 mailing list messages, 64 days, 86 messages per day 438 repo commits (7 commits/day)

Current cycle:
27 Apr to 28 Jun: 4234 mailing list messages, 62 days, 68 messages per day 664 repo commits (11 commits/day)

6.4 stats: https://lore.kernel.org/bpf/[email protected]/

Rankings
--------

Top reviewers (thr): Top reviewers (msg):

   1 (+13) [7] Yonghong Song            1 ( +1) [16] Andrii Nakryiko     
   2 ( -1) [7] Alexei Starovoitov       2 ( -1) [15] Alexei Starovoitov  
   3 ( -1) [6] Andrii Nakryiko          3 (+17) [13] Yonghong Song       
   4 ( +1) [4] Daniel Borkmann          4 (***) [ 5] David Hildenbrand   
   5 ( +3) [3] Jiri Olsa                5 (+11) [ 5] Jiri Olsa           
   6 (+14) [3] Simon Horman             6 ( +3) [ 5] Daniel Borkmann     
   7 ( -4) [2] Stanislav Fomichev       7 ( -4) [ 5] Stanislav Fomichev  
   8 ( -4) [2] Martin KaFai Lau         8 (***) [ 5] Song Liu            
   9 ( -3) [2] Jakub Kicinski           9 (+21) [ 4] Steven Rostedt      

10 (+32) [2] Steven Rostedt 10 ( -6) [ 4] Martin KaFai Lau
11 ( +5) [2] Toke Høiland-Jørgensen 11 (+15) [ 4] Simon Horman
12 ( -3) [2] Quentin Monnet 12 ( -2) [ 4] Toke Høiland-Jørgensen

Top authors (thr): Top authors (msg):

   1 (   ) [2] Andrii Nakryiko          1 (   ) [14] Andrii Nakryiko     
   2 (+11) [2] Yafang Shao              2 ( +4) [11] Yafang Shao         
   3 (+36) [1] Aditi Ghag               3 (***) [10] Maciej Fijalkowski  
   4 (+14) [1] Jiri Olsa                4 (+27) [ 9] Masami Hiramatsu (Google)
   5 (+40) [1] Stanislav Fomichev       5 ( +2) [ 6] John Fastabend      
   6 ( +3) [1] Eduard Zingerman         6 ( +5) [ 6] Jiri Olsa           

7 (***) [1] Masami Hiramatsu (Google) 7 (+40) [ 6] Stanislav Fomichev
8 (***) [1] Menglong Dong 8 (***) [ 5] Ian Rogers
9 ( +1) [1] Daniel Borkmann 9 ( -1) [ 5] Alexei Starovoitov
10 ( +6) [1] Yonghong Song 10 ( -5) [ 4] Eduard Zingerman

Company rankings
----------------

Top reviewers (thr): Top reviewers (msg):

   1 (   ) [17] Meta                    1 (   ) [50] Meta                
   2 (   ) [ 7] Isovalent               2 ( +3) [19] RedHat              
   3 ( +1) [ 5] Google                  3 (   ) [13] Isovalent           
   4 ( +1) [ 5] RedHat                  4 ( -2) [11] Google              
   5 ( -2) [ 3] Intel                   5 ( -1) [ 6] Intel               
   6 ( +5) [ 3] Corigine                6 ( +8) [ 4] Corigine            
   7 ( +6) [ 1] Microsoft               7 ( +2) [ 4] nVidia              

Top authors (thr): Top authors (msg):

   1 (   ) [7] Meta                     1 (   ) [28] Meta                
   2 (   ) [6] Isovalent                2 ( +3) [24] Google              
   3 ( +2) [5] Google                   3 ( -1) [23] Isovalent           
   4 ( -1) [2] RedHat                   4 ( +3) [18] Intel               
   5 ( +1) [2] Huawei                   5 ( +3) [11] Yafang Shao         
   6 ( -2) [2] Intel                    6 ( +3) [ 6] Huawei              
   7 ( +6) [2] Yafang Shao              7 ( -3) [ 6] Alibaba             
   8 (***) [1] nVidia                   8 ( -5) [ 4] RedHat              
   9 ( +2) [1] Eduard Zingerman         9 ( -3) [ 4] Eduard Zingerman    

Yafang/Eduard, if you'd like to share you company with me, feel free to drop a private email.

New formula rankings
--------------------

Top scores (positive): Top scores (negative):

   1 (   ) [156] Meta                   1 ( +2) [38] Yafang Shao         
   2 ( +3) [ 68] RedHat                 2 (***) [25] Intel               
   3 ( +5) [ 35] Corigine               3 (***) [25] Google              
   4 (+11) [ 15] IBM                    4 ( -3) [20] Alibaba             
   5 (+34) [ 13] Microsoft              5 (***) [14] Menglong Dong       
   6 ( +1) [ 10] nVidia                 6 (***) [11] Oracle              
   7 (***) [  9] Linux Foundation       7 (***) [10] Mike Rapoport       
   8 (***) [  8] Kent Overstreet        8 ( -4) [10] Bytedance           
   9 ( +8) [  8] Amazon                 9 ( +5) [ 8] Lorenzo Stoakes     
  10 (+11) [  7] Christoph Hellwig     10 ( +3) [ 7] Gilad Sever         
  11 ( +2) [  7] SUSE                  11 (***) [ 7] Tessares            
  12 (+10) [  7] CloudFlare            12 (***) [ 7] Eduard Zingerman    

How top authors rank in scores:

  1   p0 [155]  Meta
  2  p97 [-25]  Google
  3   p8 [  6]  Isovalent
  4  p98 [-26]  Intel
  5  p99 [-39]  Yafang Shao <[email protected]>
  6  p89 [ -7]  Huawei
  7  p96 [-21]  Alibaba
  8   p0 [ 68]  RedHat
  9  p90 [ -7]  Eduard Zingerman <[email protected]>
 10  p96 [-15]  Menglong Dong <[email protected]>
 11  p95 [-11]  Oracle
 12  p94 [-11]  Mike Rapoport <[email protected]>
 13  p93 [-10]  Bytedance
 14   p3 [ 10]  nVidia
 15  p91 [ -7]  Tessares

How to reproduce
----------------

This is mostly for myself so I don't forget how to do it next time.

$ SINCE=04/26/2023
$ UNTIL=06/27/2023
$ cd bpf-0.git
$ git log --oneline --until $UNTIL | head -n1
a73e0498abf2 Re: [PATCH RFC net-next v4 6/8] virtio/vsock: support dgrams
$ git log --oneline --since $SINCE | tail -n 1
83eb87892df6 Re: [PATCH bpf-next 3/6] bpf: Don't EFAULT for {g,s}setsockopt with wrong optlen
$ git rev-list --count 83eb87892df6..a73e0498abf2
4234
$ git checkout a73e0498abf2
$ cd ..
$ ./ml-stat.py --linux ~/bpf-next --repo bpf --db db.json --email-count 4234 --json-out bpf-6.5.json
$ cd bpf-next
$ git log --oneline --until $UNTIL | head -n1
771ca3de2502 Merge branch 'sfc-next'
$ git log --oneline --since $SINCE | tail -n 1
3ee23096add5 doc:it_IT: fix some typos
$ ./git-stat.py --linux ~/bpf-next/ \
	--db db.json \
	--json-out bpf-6.5.json \
        --start-commit 3ee23096add5 --end-commit 771ca3de2502 \
	--maintainers [email protected] \
		[email protected] \
		[email protected] \
		[email protected]
$ ./stat-print.py --ml-stats bpf-6.4.json bpf-6.5.json

More raw stats
--------------

Prev: start: Tue, 21 Feb 2023 17:10:17 +0000

	end: Wed, 26 Apr 2023 16:39:19 -0700

Prev: messages: 5362 days: 64 (84 msg/day)
Prev: direct commits: 438 (7 commits/day)
Prev: people/aliases: 255 {'author': 95, 'commenter': 105, 'both': 55}
Prev: review pct: 10.73% x-corp pct: 9.82%

Curr: start: Thu, 27 Apr 2023 08:55:55 +0200

	end: Wed, 28 Jun 2023 17:27:38 +0200

Curr: messages: 4234 days: 62 (68 msg/day)
Curr: direct commits: 664 (11 commits/day)
Curr: people/aliases: 241 {'author': 89, 'commenter': 103, 'both': 49}
Curr: review pct: 12.95% x-corp pct: 12.05%

Diff: -18.5% msg/day
Diff: +56.5% commits/day
Diff: -2.4% people/day
Diff: review pct: +2.2%

      x-corp pct: +2.2%
#1 lore raw
Quoted 98 lines · Stanislav Fomichev

Same as last time, running Jakub's scripts against bpf tree, see netdev posting for more info on the methodology:
https://lore.kernel.org/netdev/[email protected]/T/#u

He also shared with me bpf stats for the previous cycle (a lot of work went into the scripts in these past two months, so my data was completely irrelevant), so we can have some comparisons!

As last time, I'm presenting raw stats without any evaluation. I'm also trying to present the same data as we have in netdev email so you can follow Jakub's comments about script changes/etc. One thing to note maybe is that we have a lot of cross-pollination with netdev list, so our stats change quite a bit depending on netdev activity :-)

Previous cycle:
21 Feb to 26 Apr: 5362 mailing list messages, 64 days, 86 messages per day 438 repo commits (7 commits/day)

Current cycle:
27 Apr to 28 Jun: 4234 mailing list messages, 62 days, 68 messages per day 664 repo commits (11 commits/day)

6.4 stats: https://lore.kernel.org/bpf/[email protected]/

Rankings
--------

Top reviewers (thr): Top reviewers (msg):

   1 (+13) [7] Yonghong Song            1 ( +1) [16] Andrii Nakryiko
   2 ( -1) [7] Alexei Starovoitov       2 ( -1) [15] Alexei Starovoitov
   3 ( -1) [6] Andrii Nakryiko          3 (+17) [13] Yonghong Song
   4 ( +1) [4] Daniel Borkmann          4 (***) [ 5] David Hildenbrand
   5 ( +3) [3] Jiri Olsa                5 (+11) [ 5] Jiri Olsa
   6 (+14) [3] Simon Horman             6 ( +3) [ 5] Daniel Borkmann
   7 ( -4) [2] Stanislav Fomichev       7 ( -4) [ 5] Stanislav Fomichev
   8 ( -4) [2] Martin KaFai Lau         8 (***) [ 5] Song Liu
   9 ( -3) [2] Jakub Kicinski           9 (+21) [ 4] Steven Rostedt

10 (+32) [2] Steven Rostedt 10 ( -6) [ 4] Martin KaFai Lau
11 ( +5) [2] Toke Høiland-Jørgensen 11 (+15) [ 4] Simon Horman
12 ( -3) [2] Quentin Monnet 12 ( -2) [ 4] Toke Høiland-Jørgensen

Top authors (thr): Top authors (msg):

   1 (   ) [2] Andrii Nakryiko          1 (   ) [14] Andrii Nakryiko
   2 (+11) [2] Yafang Shao              2 ( +4) [11] Yafang Shao
   3 (+36) [1] Aditi Ghag               3 (***) [10] Maciej Fijalkowski
   4 (+14) [1] Jiri Olsa                4 (+27) [ 9] Masami Hiramatsu (Google)
   5 (+40) [1] Stanislav Fomichev       5 ( +2) [ 6] John Fastabend
   6 ( +3) [1] Eduard Zingerman         6 ( +5) [ 6] Jiri Olsa

7 (***) [1] Masami Hiramatsu (Google) 7 (+40) [ 6] Stanislav Fomichev
8 (***) [1] Menglong Dong 8 (***) [ 5] Ian Rogers
9 ( +1) [1] Daniel Borkmann 9 ( -1) [ 5] Alexei Starovoitov
10 ( +6) [1] Yonghong Song 10 ( -5) [ 4] Eduard Zingerman

Company rankings
----------------

Top reviewers (thr): Top reviewers (msg):

   1 (   ) [17] Meta                    1 (   ) [50] Meta
   2 (   ) [ 7] Isovalent               2 ( +3) [19] RedHat
   3 ( +1) [ 5] Google                  3 (   ) [13] Isovalent
   4 ( +1) [ 5] RedHat                  4 ( -2) [11] Google
   5 ( -2) [ 3] Intel                   5 ( -1) [ 6] Intel
   6 ( +5) [ 3] Corigine                6 ( +8) [ 4] Corigine
   7 ( +6) [ 1] Microsoft               7 ( +2) [ 4] nVidia

Top authors (thr): Top authors (msg):

   1 (   ) [7] Meta                     1 (   ) [28] Meta
   2 (   ) [6] Isovalent                2 ( +3) [24] Google
   3 ( +2) [5] Google                   3 ( -1) [23] Isovalent
   4 ( -1) [2] RedHat                   4 ( +3) [18] Intel
   5 ( +1) [2] Huawei                   5 ( +3) [11] Yafang Shao
   6 ( -2) [2] Intel                    6 ( +3) [ 6] Huawei
   7 ( +6) [2] Yafang Shao              7 ( -3) [ 6] Alibaba
   8 (***) [1] nVidia                   8 ( -5) [ 4] RedHat
   9 ( +2) [1] Eduard Zingerman         9 ( -3) [ 4] Eduard Zingerman

Yafang/Eduard, if you'd like to share you company with me, feel free to drop a private email.

New formula rankings
--------------------

Top scores (positive): Top scores (negative):

   1 (   ) [156] Meta                   1 ( +2) [38] Yafang Shao
   2 ( +3) [ 68] RedHat                 2 (***) [25] Intel
   3 ( +5) [ 35] Corigine               3 (***) [25] Google
   4 (+11) [ 15] IBM                    4 ( -3) [20] Alibaba
   5 (+34) [ 13] Microsoft              5 (***) [14] Menglong Dong
   6 ( +1) [ 10] nVidia                 6 (***) [11] Oracle
   7 (***) [  9] Linux Foundation       7 (***) [10] Mike Rapoport
   8 (***) [  8] Kent Overstreet        8 ( -4) [10] Bytedance
   9 ( +8) [  8] Amazon                 9 ( +5) [ 8] Lorenzo Stoakes
  10 (+11) [  7] Christoph Hellwig     10 ( +3) [ 7] Gilad Sever
  11 ( +2) [  7] SUSE                  11 (***) [ 7] Tessares
  12 (+10) [  7] CloudFlare            12 (***) [ 7] Eduard Zingerman

How top authors rank in scores:

Quoted 15 lines
  1   p0 [155]  Meta
  2  p97 [-25]  Google
  3   p8 [  6]  Isovalent
  4  p98 [-26]  Intel
  5  p99 [-39]  Yafang Shao <[email protected]>
  6  p89 [ -7]  Huawei
  7  p96 [-21]  Alibaba
  8   p0 [ 68]  RedHat
  9  p90 [ -7]  Eduard Zingerman <[email protected]>
 10  p96 [-15]  Menglong Dong <[email protected]>
 11  p95 [-11]  Oracle
 12  p94 [-11]  Mike Rapoport <[email protected]>
 13  p93 [-10]  Bytedance
 14   p3 [ 10]  nVidia
 15  p91 [ -7]  Tessares

Thank you Stanislav for running the stats. Much appreciate it.

The folks with negative scores please work on improving them. Negative score == takers, not givers.
The community is healthy when people give and take.
For every patch sent please take time to review somebody else's patch.

https://nesslabs.com/taker-giver-matcher

#2 lore raw
Quoted 117 lines · Alexei Starovoitov
Quoted 98 lines · Stanislav Fomichev

Same as last time, running Jakub's scripts against bpf tree, see netdev posting for more info on the methodology:
https://lore.kernel.org/netdev/[email protected]/T/#u

He also shared with me bpf stats for the previous cycle (a lot of work went into the scripts in these past two months, so my data was completely irrelevant), so we can have some comparisons!

As last time, I'm presenting raw stats without any evaluation. I'm also trying to present the same data as we have in netdev email so you can follow Jakub's comments about script changes/etc. One thing to note maybe is that we have a lot of cross-pollination with netdev list, so our stats change quite a bit depending on netdev activity :-)

Previous cycle:
21 Feb to 26 Apr: 5362 mailing list messages, 64 days, 86 messages per day 438 repo commits (7 commits/day)

Current cycle:
27 Apr to 28 Jun: 4234 mailing list messages, 62 days, 68 messages per day 664 repo commits (11 commits/day)

6.4 stats: https://lore.kernel.org/bpf/[email protected]/

Rankings
--------

Top reviewers (thr): Top reviewers (msg):

   1 (+13) [7] Yonghong Song            1 ( +1) [16] Andrii Nakryiko
   2 ( -1) [7] Alexei Starovoitov       2 ( -1) [15] Alexei Starovoitov
   3 ( -1) [6] Andrii Nakryiko          3 (+17) [13] Yonghong Song
   4 ( +1) [4] Daniel Borkmann          4 (***) [ 5] David Hildenbrand
   5 ( +3) [3] Jiri Olsa                5 (+11) [ 5] Jiri Olsa
   6 (+14) [3] Simon Horman             6 ( +3) [ 5] Daniel Borkmann
   7 ( -4) [2] Stanislav Fomichev       7 ( -4) [ 5] Stanislav Fomichev
   8 ( -4) [2] Martin KaFai Lau         8 (***) [ 5] Song Liu
   9 ( -3) [2] Jakub Kicinski           9 (+21) [ 4] Steven Rostedt

10 (+32) [2] Steven Rostedt 10 ( -6) [ 4] Martin KaFai Lau
11 ( +5) [2] Toke Høiland-Jørgensen 11 (+15) [ 4] Simon Horman
12 ( -3) [2] Quentin Monnet 12 ( -2) [ 4] Toke Høiland-Jørgensen

Top authors (thr): Top authors (msg):

   1 (   ) [2] Andrii Nakryiko          1 (   ) [14] Andrii Nakryiko
   2 (+11) [2] Yafang Shao              2 ( +4) [11] Yafang Shao
   3 (+36) [1] Aditi Ghag               3 (***) [10] Maciej Fijalkowski
   4 (+14) [1] Jiri Olsa                4 (+27) [ 9] Masami Hiramatsu (Google)
   5 (+40) [1] Stanislav Fomichev       5 ( +2) [ 6] John Fastabend
   6 ( +3) [1] Eduard Zingerman         6 ( +5) [ 6] Jiri Olsa

7 (***) [1] Masami Hiramatsu (Google) 7 (+40) [ 6] Stanislav Fomichev
8 (***) [1] Menglong Dong 8 (***) [ 5] Ian Rogers
9 ( +1) [1] Daniel Borkmann 9 ( -1) [ 5] Alexei Starovoitov
10 ( +6) [1] Yonghong Song 10 ( -5) [ 4] Eduard Zingerman

Company rankings
----------------

Top reviewers (thr): Top reviewers (msg):

   1 (   ) [17] Meta                    1 (   ) [50] Meta
   2 (   ) [ 7] Isovalent               2 ( +3) [19] RedHat
   3 ( +1) [ 5] Google                  3 (   ) [13] Isovalent
   4 ( +1) [ 5] RedHat                  4 ( -2) [11] Google
   5 ( -2) [ 3] Intel                   5 ( -1) [ 6] Intel
   6 ( +5) [ 3] Corigine                6 ( +8) [ 4] Corigine
   7 ( +6) [ 1] Microsoft               7 ( +2) [ 4] nVidia

Top authors (thr): Top authors (msg):

   1 (   ) [7] Meta                     1 (   ) [28] Meta
   2 (   ) [6] Isovalent                2 ( +3) [24] Google
   3 ( +2) [5] Google                   3 ( -1) [23] Isovalent
   4 ( -1) [2] RedHat                   4 ( +3) [18] Intel
   5 ( +1) [2] Huawei                   5 ( +3) [11] Yafang Shao
   6 ( -2) [2] Intel                    6 ( +3) [ 6] Huawei
   7 ( +6) [2] Yafang Shao              7 ( -3) [ 6] Alibaba
   8 (***) [1] nVidia                   8 ( -5) [ 4] RedHat
   9 ( +2) [1] Eduard Zingerman         9 ( -3) [ 4] Eduard Zingerman

Yafang/Eduard, if you'd like to share you company with me, feel free to drop a private email.

New formula rankings
--------------------

Top scores (positive): Top scores (negative):

   1 (   ) [156] Meta                   1 ( +2) [38] Yafang Shao
   2 ( +3) [ 68] RedHat                 2 (***) [25] Intel
   3 ( +5) [ 35] Corigine               3 (***) [25] Google
   4 (+11) [ 15] IBM                    4 ( -3) [20] Alibaba
   5 (+34) [ 13] Microsoft              5 (***) [14] Menglong Dong
   6 ( +1) [ 10] nVidia                 6 (***) [11] Oracle
   7 (***) [  9] Linux Foundation       7 (***) [10] Mike Rapoport
   8 (***) [  8] Kent Overstreet        8 ( -4) [10] Bytedance
   9 ( +8) [  8] Amazon                 9 ( +5) [ 8] Lorenzo Stoakes
  10 (+11) [  7] Christoph Hellwig     10 ( +3) [ 7] Gilad Sever
  11 ( +2) [  7] SUSE                  11 (***) [ 7] Tessares
  12 (+10) [  7] CloudFlare            12 (***) [ 7] Eduard Zingerman

How top authors rank in scores:

Quoted 15 lines
  1   p0 [155]  Meta
  2  p97 [-25]  Google
  3   p8 [  6]  Isovalent
  4  p98 [-26]  Intel
  5  p99 [-39]  Yafang Shao <[email protected]>
  6  p89 [ -7]  Huawei
  7  p96 [-21]  Alibaba
  8   p0 [ 68]  RedHat
  9  p90 [ -7]  Eduard Zingerman <[email protected]>
 10  p96 [-15]  Menglong Dong <[email protected]>
 11  p95 [-11]  Oracle
 12  p94 [-11]  Mike Rapoport <[email protected]>
 13  p93 [-10]  Bytedance
 14   p3 [ 10]  nVidia
 15  p91 [ -7]  Tessares
Quoted 8 lines

Thank you Stanislav for running the stats. Much appreciate it.

The folks with negative scores please work on improving them. Negative score == takers, not givers.
The community is healthy when people give and take.
For every patch sent please take time to review somebody else's patch.

https://nesslabs.com/taker-giver-matcher

I thought it is the reviewer's responsibility to review :) Now I understand it, I will take time to help review. Thanks for your reminder.

Signature · 2 lines
Regards
Yafang
#3 lore raw
Quoted 127 lines · Yafang Shao
Quoted 124 lines · Alexei Starovoitov
Quoted 98 lines · Stanislav Fomichev

Same as last time, running Jakub's scripts against bpf tree, see netdev posting for more info on the methodology:
https://lore.kernel.org/netdev/[email protected]/T/#u

He also shared with me bpf stats for the previous cycle (a lot of work went into the scripts in these past two months, so my data was completely irrelevant), so we can have some comparisons!

As last time, I'm presenting raw stats without any evaluation. I'm also trying to present the same data as we have in netdev email so you can follow Jakub's comments about script changes/etc. One thing to note maybe is that we have a lot of cross-pollination with netdev list, so our stats change quite a bit depending on netdev activity :-)

Previous cycle:
21 Feb to 26 Apr: 5362 mailing list messages, 64 days, 86 messages per day 438 repo commits (7 commits/day)

Current cycle:
27 Apr to 28 Jun: 4234 mailing list messages, 62 days, 68 messages per day 664 repo commits (11 commits/day)

6.4 stats: https://lore.kernel.org/bpf/[email protected]/

Rankings
--------

Top reviewers (thr): Top reviewers (msg):

   1 (+13) [7] Yonghong Song            1 ( +1) [16] Andrii Nakryiko
   2 ( -1) [7] Alexei Starovoitov       2 ( -1) [15] Alexei Starovoitov
   3 ( -1) [6] Andrii Nakryiko          3 (+17) [13] Yonghong Song
   4 ( +1) [4] Daniel Borkmann          4 (***) [ 5] David Hildenbrand
   5 ( +3) [3] Jiri Olsa                5 (+11) [ 5] Jiri Olsa
   6 (+14) [3] Simon Horman             6 ( +3) [ 5] Daniel Borkmann
   7 ( -4) [2] Stanislav Fomichev       7 ( -4) [ 5] Stanislav Fomichev
   8 ( -4) [2] Martin KaFai Lau         8 (***) [ 5] Song Liu
   9 ( -3) [2] Jakub Kicinski           9 (+21) [ 4] Steven Rostedt

10 (+32) [2] Steven Rostedt 10 ( -6) [ 4] Martin KaFai Lau
11 ( +5) [2] Toke Høiland-Jørgensen 11 (+15) [ 4] Simon Horman
12 ( -3) [2] Quentin Monnet 12 ( -2) [ 4] Toke Høiland-Jørgensen

Top authors (thr): Top authors (msg):

   1 (   ) [2] Andrii Nakryiko          1 (   ) [14] Andrii Nakryiko
   2 (+11) [2] Yafang Shao              2 ( +4) [11] Yafang Shao
   3 (+36) [1] Aditi Ghag               3 (***) [10] Maciej Fijalkowski
   4 (+14) [1] Jiri Olsa                4 (+27) [ 9] Masami Hiramatsu (Google)
   5 (+40) [1] Stanislav Fomichev       5 ( +2) [ 6] John Fastabend
   6 ( +3) [1] Eduard Zingerman         6 ( +5) [ 6] Jiri Olsa

7 (***) [1] Masami Hiramatsu (Google) 7 (+40) [ 6] Stanislav Fomichev
8 (***) [1] Menglong Dong 8 (***) [ 5] Ian Rogers
9 ( +1) [1] Daniel Borkmann 9 ( -1) [ 5] Alexei Starovoitov
10 ( +6) [1] Yonghong Song 10 ( -5) [ 4] Eduard Zingerman

Company rankings
----------------

Top reviewers (thr): Top reviewers (msg):

   1 (   ) [17] Meta                    1 (   ) [50] Meta
   2 (   ) [ 7] Isovalent               2 ( +3) [19] RedHat
   3 ( +1) [ 5] Google                  3 (   ) [13] Isovalent
   4 ( +1) [ 5] RedHat                  4 ( -2) [11] Google
   5 ( -2) [ 3] Intel                   5 ( -1) [ 6] Intel
   6 ( +5) [ 3] Corigine                6 ( +8) [ 4] Corigine
   7 ( +6) [ 1] Microsoft               7 ( +2) [ 4] nVidia

Top authors (thr): Top authors (msg):

   1 (   ) [7] Meta                     1 (   ) [28] Meta
   2 (   ) [6] Isovalent                2 ( +3) [24] Google
   3 ( +2) [5] Google                   3 ( -1) [23] Isovalent
   4 ( -1) [2] RedHat                   4 ( +3) [18] Intel
   5 ( +1) [2] Huawei                   5 ( +3) [11] Yafang Shao
   6 ( -2) [2] Intel                    6 ( +3) [ 6] Huawei
   7 ( +6) [2] Yafang Shao              7 ( -3) [ 6] Alibaba
   8 (***) [1] nVidia                   8 ( -5) [ 4] RedHat
   9 ( +2) [1] Eduard Zingerman         9 ( -3) [ 4] Eduard Zingerman

Yafang/Eduard, if you'd like to share you company with me, feel free to drop a private email.

New formula rankings
--------------------

Top scores (positive): Top scores (negative):

   1 (   ) [156] Meta                   1 ( +2) [38] Yafang Shao
   2 ( +3) [ 68] RedHat                 2 (***) [25] Intel
   3 ( +5) [ 35] Corigine               3 (***) [25] Google
   4 (+11) [ 15] IBM                    4 ( -3) [20] Alibaba
   5 (+34) [ 13] Microsoft              5 (***) [14] Menglong Dong
   6 ( +1) [ 10] nVidia                 6 (***) [11] Oracle
   7 (***) [  9] Linux Foundation       7 (***) [10] Mike Rapoport
   8 (***) [  8] Kent Overstreet        8 ( -4) [10] Bytedance
   9 ( +8) [  8] Amazon                 9 ( +5) [ 8] Lorenzo Stoakes
  10 (+11) [  7] Christoph Hellwig     10 ( +3) [ 7] Gilad Sever
  11 ( +2) [  7] SUSE                  11 (***) [ 7] Tessares
  12 (+10) [  7] CloudFlare            12 (***) [ 7] Eduard Zingerman

How top authors rank in scores:

Quoted 15 lines
  1   p0 [155]  Meta
  2  p97 [-25]  Google
  3   p8 [  6]  Isovalent
  4  p98 [-26]  Intel
  5  p99 [-39]  Yafang Shao <[email protected]>
  6  p89 [ -7]  Huawei
  7  p96 [-21]  Alibaba
  8   p0 [ 68]  RedHat
  9  p90 [ -7]  Eduard Zingerman <[email protected]>
 10  p96 [-15]  Menglong Dong <[email protected]>
 11  p95 [-11]  Oracle
 12  p94 [-11]  Mike Rapoport <[email protected]>
 13  p93 [-10]  Bytedance
 14   p3 [ 10]  nVidia
 15  p91 [ -7]  Tessares

Thank you Stanislav for running the stats. Much appreciate it.

The folks with negative scores please work on improving them. Negative score == takers, not givers.
The community is healthy when people give and take.
For every patch sent please take time to review somebody else's patch.

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 1 line

https://nesslabs.com/taker-giver-matcher

I thought it is the reviewer's responsibility to review :) Now I understand it, I will take time to help review. Thanks for your reminder.

For BPF CORE we have 4 maintainers and 7 official reviewers.
bpf mailing list receives ~70 emails a day.
bpf development can scale only when people who actively develop are also actively reviewing code.
M and R entries in MAINTAINERS file is a recognition of the prior efforts. Not much more. We need to trim it and remove people who are no longer active.

#4 lore raw
In reply to Yafang Shao
Quoted 6 lines · Yafang Shao
Quoted 3 lines · Alexei Starovoitov
Quoted 1 line · Stanislav Fomichev

......

Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 9 lines

Thank you Stanislav for running the stats. Much appreciate it.

The folks with negative scores please work on improving them. Negative score == takers, not givers.
The community is healthy when people give and take.
For every patch sent please take time to review somebody else's patch.

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 1 line

https://nesslabs.com/taker-giver-matcher

I thought it is the reviewer's responsibility to review :) Now I understand it, I will take time to help review. Thanks for your reminder.

Me too! I thought that I wasn't qualified to review and only the official reviewers can. I've always been curious if I could review other people's code. I'll try to be a reviewer too.

Thanks!
Menglong Dong