kbuild: modules.builtin is empty on architectures without CONFIG_ARCH_VMLINUX_NEEDS_RELOCS
Hi,
While build todays net-next tree on a Lantiq-based board I use for testing I run into a weird problem which gave me some headaches. It turns there is a regression introduced in commit 39cfd5b12160 ("kbuild:
extract modules.builtin.modinfo from vmlinux.unstripped") which causes both modules.builtin and modules.builtin.modinfo to be empty files on certain architectures.
AFFECTED SCOPE:
===============
This bug affects all architectures where:
1. CONFIG_ARCH_VMLINUX_NEEDS_RELOCS is NOT set, AND
2. The architecture uses the standard ELF_DETAILS macro in its linker script (which places .modinfo at address 0 as a non-allocatable section)
This includes at least MIPS (32-bit and 64-bit) and likely several other architectures. The issue does NOT affect architectures with CONFIG_ARCH_VMLINUX_NEEDS_RELOCS=y (e.g., x86 with certain configurations, parisc, s390).
OBSERVED BEHAVIOR:
==================
After a successful kernel build with the affected configuration:
- modules.builtin: 0 bytes (empty)
- modules.builtin.modinfo: 0 bytes (empty)
- vmlinux.o: contains .modinfo section (verified with readelf)
- vmlinux.unstripped: .modinfo section is MISSING (verified with readelf)
This breaks any build tooling that depends on modules.builtin to determine which drivers are built into the kernel image, such as OpenWrt's build system.
ROOT CAUSE ANALYSIS:
====================
Commit 39cfd5b12160 moved the extraction of modules.builtin.modinfo from vmlinux.o to vmlinux.unstripped. The commit message states:
"Currently, we assume all the data for modules.builtin.modinfo are
available in vmlinux.o."
However, this change makes a NEW assumption that was not explicitly documented or validated: it assumes that the .modinfo section will be present in vmlinux.unstripped.
The problem occurs during the linking phase
(vmlinux.o -> vmlinux.unstripped):
1. The .modinfo section is defined in include/asm-generic/vmlinux.lds.h as part of ELF_DETAILS:
.modinfo : { *(.modinfo) }This places it at address 0 (non-allocatable, similar to .comment, .symtab, etc.)
2. When CONFIG_ARCH_VMLINUX_NEEDS_RELOCS is NOT set, the Makefile does NOT add "--discard-none" to LDFLAGS_vmlinux (see Makefile line 1133-1135):
ifneq ($(CONFIG_ARCH_VMLINUX_NEEDS_RELOCS),) LDFLAGS_vmlinux += --emit-relocs --discard-none endif
3. Without "--discard-none", the GNU linker (ld) applies its default
behavior: it discards unreferenced sections with address 0 that are not marked as allocatable.
4. The .modinfo section is unreferenced from the linker's perspective (no code/data references it directly), so it gets discarded.
5. In scripts/Makefile.vmlinux line 107, objcopy attempts to extract .modinfo from vmlinux.unstripped:
modules.builtin.modinfo: vmlinux.unstripped FORCE $(call if_changed,objcopy)
But since .modinfo was discarded, objcopy produces an empty file.
6. Subsequently, modules.builtin (which depends on modules.builtin.modinfo) is also empty.
WHY THE PREVIOUS CODE WORKED:
==============================
Before commit 39cfd5b12160, modules.builtin.modinfo was extracted from vmlinux.o (in scripts/Makefile.vmlinux_o). The .modinfo section was reliably present in vmlinux.o because:
- vmlinux.o is the direct output of object file linking
- No section stripping occurs at this stage
- The section contains actual data (module metadata from __MODULE_INFO)
REPRODUCTION:
=============
1. Configure a kernel for MIPS (or any other architecture without CONFIG_ARCH_VMLINUX_NEEDS_RELOCS)
2. Ensure CONFIG_MODULES=y is set
3. Build the kernel: make
4. Observe: ls -lh modules.builtin modules.builtin.modinfo Both files will be 0 bytes
VERIFICATION:
=============
You can verify the .modinfo section presence:
$ readelf -S vmlinux.o | grep modinfo [51265] .modinfo PROGBITS 00000000 919448 00803e 00 A 0 0 1
$ readelf -S vmlinux.unstripped | grep modinfo (no output - section is missing)
IMPACT:
=======
This is a build system regression that breaks kernel builds for downstream projects (like OpenWrt) that rely on modules.builtin. Since the file is silently empty rather than causing a build failure, it can lead to incorrect packaging and deployment decisions.
The regression is present in v6.18-rc1 and later kernels.
I'm happy to test any proposed patches. Please let me know if you need additional information or testing.
Best regards,
Daniel Golle
Quoted 92 lines · Daniel Golle
Hi,
While build todays net-next tree on a Lantiq-based board I use for testing I run into a weird problem which gave me some headaches. It turns there is a regression introduced in commit
39cfd5b12160("kbuild:
extract modules.builtin.modinfo from vmlinux.unstripped") which causes both modules.builtin and modules.builtin.modinfo to be empty files on certain architectures.AFFECTED SCOPE:
===============
This bug affects all architectures where:
1.CONFIG_ARCH_VMLINUX_NEEDS_RELOCSis NOT set, AND
2. The architecture uses the standardELF_DETAILSmacro in its linker script (which places .modinfo at address 0 as a non-allocatable section)This includes at least MIPS (32-bit and 64-bit) and likely several other architectures. The issue does NOT affect architectures with
CONFIG_ARCH_VMLINUX_NEEDS_RELOCS=y(e.g., x86 with certain configurations, parisc, s390).OBSERVED BEHAVIOR:
==================
After a successful kernel build with the affected configuration:
- modules.builtin: 0 bytes (empty)
- modules.builtin.modinfo: 0 bytes (empty)
- vmlinux.o: contains .modinfo section (verified with readelf)
- vmlinux.unstripped: .modinfo section is MISSING (verified with readelf)This breaks any build tooling that depends on modules.builtin to determine which drivers are built into the kernel image, such as OpenWrt's build system.
ROOT CAUSE ANALYSIS:
====================
Commit39cfd5b12160moved the extraction of modules.builtin.modinfo from vmlinux.o to vmlinux.unstripped. The commit message states:"Currently, we assume all the data for modules.builtin.modinfo are
available in vmlinux.o."However, this change makes a NEW assumption that was not explicitly documented or validated: it assumes that the .modinfo section will be present in vmlinux.unstripped.
The problem occurs during the linking phase
(vmlinux.o -> vmlinux.unstripped):1. The .modinfo section is defined in
include/asm-generic/vmlinux.lds.has part ofELF_DETAILS:.modinfo : { *(.modinfo) }This places it at address 0 (non-allocatable, similar to .comment, .symtab, etc.)
2. When
CONFIG_ARCH_VMLINUX_NEEDS_RELOCSis NOT set, theMakefiledoes NOT add "--discard-none" toLDFLAGS_vmlinux(seeMakefileline 1133-1135):ifneq ($(CONFIG_ARCH_VMLINUX_NEEDS_RELOCS),) LDFLAGS_vmlinux += --emit-relocs --discard-none endif3. Without "--discard-none", the GNU linker (ld) applies its default
behavior: it discards unreferenced sections with address 0 that are not marked as allocatable.4. The .modinfo section is unreferenced from the linker's perspective (no code/data references it directly), so it gets discarded.
5. In
scripts/Makefile.vmlinuxline 107, objcopy attempts to extract .modinfo from vmlinux.unstripped:modules.builtin.modinfo: vmlinux.unstripped FORCE $(call if_changed,objcopy)But since .modinfo was discarded, objcopy produces an empty file.
6. Subsequently, modules.builtin (which depends on modules.builtin.modinfo) is also empty.
WHY THE PREVIOUS CODE WORKED:
==============================
Before commit39cfd5b12160, modules.builtin.modinfo was extracted from vmlinux.o (inscripts/Makefile.vmlinux_o). The .modinfo section was reliably present in vmlinux.o because:
- vmlinux.o is the direct output of object file linking
- No section stripping occurs at this stage
- The section contains actual data (module metadata from__MODULE_INFO)
Quoted 8 lines
REPRODUCTION:
=============
1. Configure a kernel for MIPS (or any other architecture withoutCONFIG_ARCH_VMLINUX_NEEDS_RELOCS)
2. EnsureCONFIG_MODULES=yis set
3. Build the kernel: make
4. Observe: ls -lh modules.builtin modules.builtin.modinfo Both files will be 0 bytes
Hm. At least on arm64, it doesn't reproduce with these parameters.
$ grep -w -e CONFIG_MODULES -e CONFIG_ARCH_VMLINUX_NEEDS_RELOCS .config CONFIG_MODULES=y
$ ARCH=arm64 CROSS_COMPILE=aarch64-unknown-linux-gnu- make /tmp/linux/Makefile:1133: CONFIG_ARCH_VMLINUX_NEEDS_RELOCS="" CALL scripts/checksyscalls.sh OBJCOPY modules.builtin.modinfo GEN modules.builtin
$ ls -lh modules.builtin modules.builtin.modinfo -rw-r--r-- 1 legion legion 1.1K Oct 15 18:59 modules.builtin -rw-r--r-- 1 legion legion 14K Oct 15 18:59 modules.builtin.modinfo
I'll try to reproduce it on mips.
Quoted 25 lines
VERIFICATION:
=============
You can verify the .modinfo section presence:$ readelf -S vmlinux.o | grep modinfo [51265] .modinfo PROGBITS 00000000 919448 00803e 00 A 0 0 1$ readelf -S vmlinux.unstripped | grep modinfo (no output - section is missing)IMPACT:
=======
This is a build system regression that breaks kernel builds for downstream projects (like OpenWrt) that rely on modules.builtin. Since the file is silently empty rather than causing a build failure, it can lead to incorrect packaging and deployment decisions.The regression is present in v6.18-rc1 and later kernels.
I'm happy to test any proposed patches. Please let me know if you need additional information or testing.
Best regards,
Daniel Golle
Signature · 1 line
Rgrds, legion
Nathan Chancellor
maintainerHi Daniel,
Thanks for the report!
Quoted 28 lines · Daniel Golle
While build todays net-next tree on a Lantiq-based board I use for testing I run into a weird problem which gave me some headaches. It turns there is a regression introduced in commit
39cfd5b12160("kbuild:
extract modules.builtin.modinfo from vmlinux.unstripped") which causes both modules.builtin and modules.builtin.modinfo to be empty files on certain architectures.AFFECTED SCOPE:
===============
This bug affects all architectures where:
1.CONFIG_ARCH_VMLINUX_NEEDS_RELOCSis NOT set, AND
2. The architecture uses the standardELF_DETAILSmacro in its linker script (which places .modinfo at address 0 as a non-allocatable section)This includes at least MIPS (32-bit and 64-bit) and likely several other architectures. The issue does NOT affect architectures with
CONFIG_ARCH_VMLINUX_NEEDS_RELOCS=y(e.g., x86 with certain configurations, parisc, s390).OBSERVED BEHAVIOR:
==================
After a successful kernel build with the affected configuration:
- modules.builtin: 0 bytes (empty)
- modules.builtin.modinfo: 0 bytes (empty)
- vmlinux.o: contains .modinfo section (verified with readelf)
- vmlinux.unstripped: .modinfo section is MISSING (verified with readelf)
...
Quoted 8 lines
REPRODUCTION:
=============
1. Configure a kernel for MIPS (or any other architecture withoutCONFIG_ARCH_VMLINUX_NEEDS_RELOCS)
2. EnsureCONFIG_MODULES=yis set
3. Build the kernel: make
4. Observe: ls -lh modules.builtin modules.builtin.modinfo Both files will be 0 bytes
I cannot reproduce this with a simple defconfig build for either mips or arm64 using GCC 15.2.0 / binutils 2.45 from kernel.org [1]:
$ git show -s --pretty=kernel
5a6f65d15025 ("Merge tag 'bitmap-for-v6.18-rc2' of https://github.com/norov/linux")$ make -skj"$(nproc)" ARCH=mips CROSS_COMPILE=mips-linux- clean defconfig all ...
$ scripts/config -s MODULES -s ARCH_VMLINUX_NEEDS_RELOCS y undef
$ ls -hl modules.builtin{,.modinfo}
-rw-r--r-- 1 nathan nathan 8.7K Oct 15 10:19 modules.builtin
-rwxr-xr-x 1 nathan nathan 146K Oct 15 10:19 modules.builtin.modinfo$ make -skj"$(nproc)" ARCH=arm64 CROSS_COMPILE=aarch64-linux- clean virtconfig all
$ scripts/config -s MODULES -s ARCH_VMLINUX_NEEDS_RELOCS y undef
$ ls -hl modules.builtin{,.modinfo}
-rw-r--r-- 1 nathan nathan 18K Oct 15 10:23 modules.builtin
-rw-r--r-- 1 nathan nathan 284K Oct 15 10:23 modules.builtin.modinfoWhat version of GCC and binutils are you using? Your configuration may be helpful for reproducing as well.
[1]: https://kernel.org/pub/tools/crosstool/
Cheers,
Nathan