GPL version 4
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
Quoted 9 lines · Morton Harrow
I see with pain in my heart that the GPLv3 doesn't actually give the users of GPLv3 software the liberty and freedom the FSF has been fighting for. Instead they are forced to play by the strict set of terms the GPLv3 provides.
For example, as a liberated computer user, I might like to incorporate a high quality piece of GPLv3 software in a commercial product, which for bussiness strategic reasons happens to be closed source software. But the GPLv3 denies my claim for this freedom to do this.
Would you grant me the freedom to give away your commercial product for free or to incorporate it in my commercial product? Probably not. You'd instead grant me less freedom. The GPL protects me from this.
Quoted 5 lines
Would you grant me the freedom to give away your commercial product for free
or to incorporate it in my commercial product? Probably not. You'd instead grant me less freedom. The GPL protects me from this.
Except it doesn't. With or without the GPL, if he still makes his commercial product, you will still be unable to give it away or incorporate it in your commercial product. If he doesn't make it, that's just less choice for everyone.
It may be a poorer product. It may cost him more to develop it. It may wind up not existing. But in no case will will you wind up with the freedom to give away his commercial product. So the GPL actually won't protect you from this at all.
It will just result in him producing a poorer, more expensive, less compatible product -- or none at all. Either way, everyone else will have fewer (and/or poorer) choices. Everyone loses. Nobody wins.
Note that had he been able to incorporate the GPL code in his commercial product, he may have passed bug fixes and improvements back to the GPL project. He would not have had to, of course, but if his product just uses a GPL component or library (that doesn't compete with the larger product), there's no reason for him not to. Everybody could have won.
It's always possible he may instead elect to make a GPL'd project. This may allow him to produce a higher-quality product in less time. It may allow others to build on his work, and result in more freedom for everyone. He may make less money, but maybe not. The question of whether the "everybody loses" or the "lots of people, maybe everybody, wins" case is more common is an empiric one.
I have seen an awful lot of "everybody loses" cases. I've seen very few "everybody wins" cases.
DS
Could you guys please remove [email protected] from the cc of this mail? Nobody here cares.
Quoted 45 lines · David Schwartz
Quoted 4 lines
Would you grant me the freedom to give away your commercial product for free
or to incorporate it in my commercial product? Probably not. You'd instead grant me less freedom. The GPL protects me from this.Except it doesn't. With or without the GPL, if he still makes his commercial
product, you will still be unable to give it away or incorporate it in your
commercial product. If he doesn't make it, that's just less choice for everyone.It may be a poorer product. It may cost him more to develop it. It may wind
up not existing. But in no case will will you wind up with the freedom to give away his commercial product. So the GPL actually won't protect you from
this at all.It will just result in him producing a poorer, more expensive, less compatible product -- or none at all. Either way, everyone else will have fewer (and/or poorer) choices. Everyone loses. Nobody wins.
Note that had he been able to incorporate the GPL code in his commercial product, he may have passed bug fixes and improvements back to the GPL project. He would not have had to, of course, but if his product just uses a
GPL component or library (that doesn't compete with the larger product), there's no reason for him not to. Everybody could have won.It's always possible he may instead elect to make a GPL'd project. This may
allow him to produce a higher-quality product in less time. It may allow others to build on his work, and result in more freedom for everyone. He may
make less money, but maybe not. The question of whether the "everybody loses" or the "lots of people, maybe everybody, wins" case is more common is
an empiric one.I have seen an awful lot of "everybody loses" cases. I've seen very few "everybody wins" cases.
DS
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
Quoted 4 lines · Richard M Stallman
Freedom means having control of your own life. Using a proprietary program means giving the developer power over you. "More choice" in surrendering your freedom is not more freedom, and it does not make a better world.
"Breathing the air means giving anyone else power over you."
Even with proprietary programs you still have the control of your life: noone forces you to use this or that program.
Quoted 5 lines
It will just result in him producing a poorer, more expensive, less compatible product -- or none at all.
Ideally, it will be none at all. A proprietary program is a negative contribution to society.
Oh, really. Programs are dearer to your heart than people.
What you say sounds luddist: it is better to force everyone to perform routine tasks manually instead of saving time by minor investment in development of tools.
Quoted 3 lines
One less proprietary program means one less
job of replacement on our list, and it could leave the field open for a free program to succeed.
You speculate on what it could or could not, yet many people prefer to look at what is and what is not.
Quoted 2 lines
Just think how much better off we would be
if Microsoft Windows had never been developed.
How? How exactly? I don't believe you, show me facts.
Quoted 3 lines
But suppose he does it anyway, without using our code. That could be just the handicap that enables a competing free program to be superior in convenience, just as it always is in ethics.
Put ethics aside, it is subjective and differs from place to place.
In which way your "free" "replacement" is more convenient than Adobe Photoshop? How do you explain simple fact, that photographers prefer the latter, even when they tried your so-called "free" so-called "replacement".
Haven't these arguments been made before? Yet the FSF, Open Source and proprietary developers still exist. There are obvious advantages in each approach.
As a developer involved in many types of software I can appreciate what each solution has to offer.
Isn't it fruitless to debate this ideology, again and again and again... We will choose the approach that best suits our particular situation and interests.
Let's not instigate another war over ground that has already been "carpet bombed".
------------
Quoted 60 lines
-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]]On Behalf Of Aleksej Saushev
Sent: Sunday, July 20, 2008 1:34 AM
To: [email protected]
Cc: [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]
Subject: Re: GPL version 4Quoted 4 lines · Richard M Stallman
Freedom means having control of your own life. Using a proprietary program means giving the developer power over you. "More choice" in surrendering your freedom is not more freedom, and it does not make a better world.
"Breathing the air means giving anyone else power over you."
Even with proprietary programs you still have the control of your life: noone forces you to use this or that program.
Quoted 5 lines
It will just result in him producing a poorer, more expensive, less compatible product -- or none at all.
Ideally, it will be none at all. A proprietary program is a negative contribution to society.
Oh, really. Programs are dearer to your heart than people.
What you say sounds luddist: it is better to force everyone to perform routine tasks manually instead of saving time by minor investment in development of tools.
Quoted 3 lines
One less proprietary program means one less
job of replacement on our list, and it could leave the field open for a free program to succeed.You speculate on what it could or could not, yet many people prefer to look at what is and what is not.
Quoted 2 lines
Just think how much better off we would be
if Microsoft Windows had never been developed.How? How exactly? I don't believe you, show me facts.
Quoted 3 lines
But suppose he does it anyway, without using our code. That could be just the handicap that enables a competing free program to be superior in convenience, just as it always is in ethics.
Put ethics aside, it is subjective and differs from place to place.
In which way your "free" "replacement" is more convenient than Adobe Photoshop?
How do you explain simple fact, that photographers prefer the latter, even when they tried your so-called "free" so-called "replacement".
On Sun, 2008-07-20 at 12:34 +0400, Aleksej Saushev wrote:
<snip>
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 2 lines
Just think how much better off we would be
if Microsoft Windows had never been developed.How? How exactly? I don't believe you, show me facts.
You have got to be kidding..
Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 4 lines
But suppose he does it anyway, without using our code. That could be just the handicap that enables a competing free program to be superior in convenience, just as it always is in ethics.
Put ethics aside, it is subjective and differs from place to place.
In which way your "free" "replacement" is more convenient than Adobe Photoshop? How do you explain simple fact, that photographers prefer the latter, even when they tried your so-called "free" so-called "replacement".
I find it horrifying that you believe that simply because lots of people(maybe even the majority) does/use something, and even prefer it, means its the right thing. I suggest you look around the world, reflect on it, and then read your own post.
Quoted 6 lines
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/