Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Suspected problem w/ autofs and xauth

DISCUSSION Steven Hirsch 2 participants 3 messages Nov 16, 2008 – Nov 17, 2008

Subsystems (2)
lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

I've been battling with an extremely annoying issue that I believe is related to autofs. My home directory is mounted over NFS using autofs 4.1.4 (as supplied with Kubuntu Hardy). I've used this setup for years over perhaps a dozen different distributions without any particular problems.

Since moving to the Hardy distro, the problem is this: If I leave the system idle at the KDE desktop for more than a few minutes, any and all attempts at opening new windows fail with an error that they cannot obtain X authorization. If I simply do an 'ls' in my home directory and try again, it works fine. I believe this is being caused by the automounter timing out, but I do not find any log messages from the automounter under any circumstances, so it's difficult to prove. If I do an strace on the X application, it appears to be unable to read ~/.Xauthority (which is there and can be read after triggering a remount).

Is it possible that autofs behavior changed in a manner such that a stat of ~/.Xauthority is no longer sufficient to trigger the mounter?

Any suggestions (or even WAGs) appreciated. I'd love to swat this annoyance.

Steve

#1 lore raw
Quoted 17 lines · Steven Hirsch

I've been battling with an extremely annoying issue that I believe is related to autofs. My home directory is mounted over NFS using autofs 4.1.4 (as supplied with Kubuntu Hardy). I've used this setup for years over perhaps a dozen different distributions without any particular problems.

Since moving to the Hardy distro, the problem is this: If I leave the system idle at the KDE desktop for more than a few minutes, any and all attempts at opening new windows fail with an error that they cannot obtain X authorization. If I simply do an 'ls' in my home directory and try again, it works fine. I believe this is being caused by the automounter timing out, but I do not find any log messages from the automounter under any circumstances, so it's difficult to prove. If I do an strace on the X application, it appears to be unable to read ~/.Xauthority (which is there and can be read after triggering a remount).

Quoted 5 lines

Is it possible that autofs behavior changed in a manner such that a stat of ~/.Xauthority is no longer sufficient to trigger the mounter?

Any suggestions (or even WAGs) appreciated. I'd love to swat this annoyance.

In theory, the directory shouldn't be unmounted. Try typing just 'mount' to see what's mounted when the problem occurs. What's the kernel version?

Cheers,

Jeff

#2 lore raw
Quoted 22 lines · Jeff Moyer
Quoted 20 lines · Steven Hirsch

I've been battling with an extremely annoying issue that I believe is related to autofs. My home directory is mounted over NFS using autofs 4.1.4 (as supplied with Kubuntu Hardy). I've used this setup for years over perhaps a dozen different distributions without any particular problems.

Since moving to the Hardy distro, the problem is this: If I leave the system idle at the KDE desktop for more than a few minutes, any and all attempts at opening new windows fail with an error that they cannot obtain X authorization. If I simply do an 'ls' in my home directory and try again, it works fine. I believe this is being caused by the automounter timing out, but I do not find any log messages from the automounter under any circumstances, so it's difficult to prove. If I do an strace on the X application, it appears to be unable to read ~/.Xauthority (which is there and can be read after triggering a remount).

Is it possible that autofs behavior changed in a manner such that a stat of ~/.Xauthority is no longer sufficient to trigger the mounter?

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines

Any suggestions (or even WAGs) appreciated. I'd love to swat this annoyance.

In theory, the directory shouldn't be unmounted. Try typing just 'mount' to see what's mounted when the problem occurs. What's the kernel version?

I have accidently discovered a workaround, which may provide a hint as to the failure mode: For performance, I had been mounting my home directory with 'noatime' specified as an option. On a whim, I deleted that and let it take the default (seems to be relatime). Lo and behold, the problem is gone!

I will revert this as soon as I get an opportunity and see what is mounted (or not, as the case may be) when the symptoms appear.

Steve