Using DCACHE instead of internal SRAM as the initial stack on PPC440GP?
Hi,
I'm experimenting to set up the initial stack in DCACHE instead of internal SRAM on Ebony. Our SoC only has a ppc440 core and no internal SRAM available.
I made more changes than what I reported yesterday
(http://sourceforge.net/mailarchive/message.php?msg_id=11062649). My understanding on the initial stack is:
1. CFG_INIT_RAM_ADDR is set to an address which nobody uses it. No backup RAM is required.
2. Config only this area cacheable. All others are caching inhibited.
So I made the following changes on Ebony's uboot code.
1. set CFG_INIT_RAM_ADDR to 0x40000000, no memory or peripherals use this address space, and CFG_INIT_DCACHE_CS to 4.
2. This address space is mapped to 0x1_4F00_0000, one of spared peripheral areas. My TLB is set as follows.
(gdb) mon tlb 0 8
0 : 00 f0000000 256MB V0 -> 1_f0000000 U:0000 -I-G- XWRXWR 1 : 00 e0000000 256MB V0 -> 1_40000000 U:0000 -I-G- -WR-WR
2 : 00 40000000 4KB V0 -> 1_4f000000 U:0000 ----- XWRXWR
3 : 00 00000000 256MB V0 -> 0_00000000 U:0000 -I-G- XWRXWR 4 : 00 d0000000 256MB V0 -> 2_00000000 U:0000 -I-G- -WR-WR 5 : 00 80000000 256MB V0 -> 3_00000000 U:0000 -I-G- -WR-WR
6 : 00 00000000 1KB -0 -> 0_00000000 U:0000 ----- ------ 7 : 00 00000000 1KB -0 -> 0_00000000 U:0000 ----- ------ 8 : 00 00000000 1KB -0 -> 0_00000000 U:0000 ----- ------
3. Commented out internal SRAM initialization and TLB entries.
4. set up EBC bank 4 for this area.
/*----------------------------------------------------------------------- */ /* Memory Bank x (nothingness) initialization */ /* used as temporary stack pointer for stage0 */ /*----------------------------------------------------------------------- */ li r4, xbcfg mtdcr ebccfga, r4 lis r1, 0x0400 ori r1, r1, 0x0000 mfdcr r4, ebccfgd or r4, r4, r1 mtdcr ebccfgd, r4 /* set ATC */ li r4, PBxAP mtdcr ebccfga, r4 lis r4, 0x0380 ori r4, r4, 0x0480 mtdcr ebccfgd, r4 addi r4, 0, PBxCR mtdcr ebccfga, r4 lis r4, 0x4F01 /* BAS=0x4F0, BS=000 (1MB) */ ori r4, r4, 0xE000 /* BU=11 (r/w), BW=11 (32 bits) */ mtdcr ebccfgd, r4
However initializing the stack still causes machine check exception. I really don't know what else I'm missing here. Any suggestions or hints are greatly appreciated!
Thanks,
-Shawn.
Hi Shawn,
Quoted 17 lines · Shawn Jin
I'm experimenting to set up the initial stack in DCACHE instead of internal SRAM on Ebony. Our SoC only has a ppc440 core and no internal SRAM available.
I made more changes than what I reported yesterday
(http://sourceforge.net/mailarchive/message.php?msg_id=11062649). My understanding on the initial stack is:
1.CFG_INIT_RAM_ADDRis set to an address which nobody uses it. No backup RAM is required.
2. Config only this area cacheable. All others are caching inhibited.So I made the following changes on Ebony's uboot code.
1. setCFG_INIT_RAM_ADDRto0x40000000, no memory or peripherals use this address space, andCFG_INIT_DCACHE_CSto 4.
2. This address space is mapped to 0x1_4F00_0000, one of spared peripheral areas. My TLB is set as follows.
Quoted 4 lines
(gdb) mon tlb 0 8
0 : 00f0000000256MB V0 -> 1_f0000000 U:0000 -I-G- XWRXWR 1 : 00e0000000256MB V0 -> 1_40000000 U:0000 -I-G- -WR-WR
2 : 00 40000000 4KB V0 -> 1_4f000000 U:0000 ----- XWRXWR
Tlb 1 and 2 seem to overlap in the physical addresses!
Quoted 23 lines
3 : 00 00000000 256MB V0 -> 0_00000000 U:0000 -I-G- XWRXWR 4 : 00
d0000000256MB V0 -> 2_00000000 U:0000 -I-G- -WR-WR 5 : 00 80000000 256MB V0 -> 3_00000000 U:0000 -I-G- -WR-WR6 : 00 00000000 1KB -0 -> 0_00000000 U:0000 ----- ------ 7 : 00 00000000 1KB -0 -> 0_00000000 U:0000 ----- ------ 8 : 00 00000000 1KB -0 -> 0_00000000 U:0000 ----- ------3. Commented out internal SRAM initialization and TLB entries.
4. set up EBC bank 4 for this area./*----------------------------------------------------------------------- */ /* Memory Bank x (nothingness) initialization */ /* used as temporary stack pointer for stage0 */ /*----------------------------------------------------------------------- */ li r4, xbcfg mtdcr ebccfga, r4 lis r1, 0x0400 ori r1, r1, 0x0000 mfdcr r4, ebccfgd or r4, r4, r1 mtdcr ebccfgd, r4 /* set ATC */ li r4, PBxAP mtdcr ebccfga, r4
Quoted 8 lines
lis r4, 0x0380 ori r4, r4, 0x0480 mtdcr ebccfgd, r4 addi r4, 0, PBxCR mtdcr ebccfga, r4 lis r4, 0x4F01 /* BAS=0x4F0, BS=000 (1MB) */ ori r4, r4, 0xE000 /* BU=11 (r/w), BW=11 (32 bits) */
You don't set BW to 11 but to 10. Please use 0x4f01f000 for the PBxCR value. I don't think this is the cause for the problem, but it can't hurt to correct this.
Quoted 5 lines
mtdcr ebccfgd, r4
However initializing the stack still causes machine check exception. I really don't know what else I'm missing here. Any suggestions or hints are greatly appreciated!
Did you take a look at the error reporting registers (for example EBC0_BEAR / EBC0_BESR)?
Best regards,
Stefan
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 4 lines
(gdb) mon tlb 0 8
0 : 00f0000000256MB V0 -> 1_f0000000 U:0000 -I-G- XWRXWR 1 : 00e0000000256MB V0 -> 1_40000000 U:0000 -I-G- -WR-WR
2 : 00 40000000 4KB V0 -> 1_4f000000 U:0000 ----- XWRXWRTlb 1 and 2 seem to overlap in the physical addresses!
Now I changed the page size to 4K in tlb 1. Here is the new tlb.
Core#0>tlb 0 8
0 : 00 f0000000 256MB V0 -> 1_f0000000 U:0000 -I-G- XWRXWR
1 : 00 e0000000 4KB V0 -> 1_40000000 U:0000 -I-G- -WR-WR
2 : 00 40000000 4KB V0 -> 1_4f000000 U:0000 ----- XWRXWR
3 : 00 00000000 256MB V0 -> 0_00000000 U:0000 -I-G- XWRXWR 4 : 00 d0000000 256MB V0 -> 2_00000000 U:0000 -I-G- -WR-WR 5 : 00 80000000 256MB V0 -> 3_00000000 U:0000 -I-G- -WR-WR
6 : 00 00000000 1KB -0 -> 0_00000000 U:0000 ----- ------
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 4 lines
addi r4, 0, PBxCR mtdcr ebccfga, r4 lis r4, 0x4F01 /* BAS=0x4F0, BS=000 (1MB) */ ori r4, r4, 0xE000 /* BU=11 (r/w), BW=11 (32 bits) */You don't set BW to 11 but to 10. Please use
0x4f01f000for the PBxCR value. I
^^^^^^^^^^^
You really meant 0x4f01a000, didn't you? (set BW to 10).
Quoted 2 lines
don't think this is the cause for the problem, but it can't hurt to correct this.
This doesn't seem to be the cause of the problem. :(
Quoted 2 lines
Did you take a look at the error reporting registers (for example
EBC0_BEAR/EBC0_BESR)?
I checked both registers. They are all 0s. Here is the debugging screen dump. PC 0xfff80180 is the first instruction of stwu.
li r0,0 stwu r0,-4(r1) stwu r0,-4(r1) /* Terminate call chain */
Core#0>ti
Core number : 0
Core state : debug mode
Debug entry cause : single step
Current PC : 0xfff80180
Current CR : 0x22ffdff7
Current MSR : 0x00021000
Current LR : 0xfffff174
Core#0>rd ebc0_besr
ebc0_besr: 0x00000000 0
Core#0>ti
Core number : 0
Core state : debug mode
Debug entry cause : single step
Current PC : 0x00001400
Current CR : 0x22ffdff7
Current MSR : 0x00021000
Current LR : 0xfffff174Core#0>rd ebc0_besrebc0_besr: 0x00000000 0
Thanks,
-Shawn.