Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Autofs LDAP mount question

DISCUSSION Techie 2 participants 6 messages Mar 11, 2010 – Mar 12, 2010 Kernel automounter

lore
Share & tools
lore

Techie

author
#0 lore raw

Hello,

I have a simple question regarding LDAP direct map mounts.

If I use a local direct map "/etc/direct_map" with the below contents to map NFS directories on two different file systems.

/data red:/usr/local/app \
/libs/apps red:/var/libs/apps

Both mount points to map properly. The /data directory shows the correct contents of red:/usr/local/app. And the /data/lib/apps directory also shows the correct contents of red:/var/libs/apps. This is what I believe are nested mount points. However when I try the same thing with an LDAP direct map it fails. he contents of the same map in LDAP is below.

dn: automountKey=/data,automountMapName=direct_map,ou=Autofs,dc=example,dc=com
automountInformation: -fstype=nfs,rw red:/usr/local/app
automountKey: /data
objectClass: automount
objectClass: top

dn: automountKey=/data/libs/apps,automountMapName=direct_map,ou=Autofs,dc=example,dc=com
automountKey: /data/libs/apps
objectClass: automount
objectClass: top
automountInformation: -fstype=nfs,rw red://var/libs/apps

When I do this in my LDAP map as shown above, the mount points do not show up correctly. The /data directory covers up one of the 2 mount points. So it looks like nested mount points don't work in LDAP or I am not using correct syntax. All my other LDAP mounts work but two mount points in the same dir does not work like it does with local direct maps.

Can you please confirm or deny if I can achieve nested mount points using LDAP direct maps like I can with local direct maps as shown above?

Thank you

maintainer
#1 lore raw
Quoted 37 lines · Techie

Hello,

I have a simple question regarding LDAP direct map mounts.

If I use a local direct map "/etc/direct_map" with the below contents to map NFS directories on two different file systems.

/data red:/usr/local/app \
/libs/apps red:/var/libs/apps

Both mount points to map properly. The /data directory shows the correct contents of red:/usr/local/app. And the /data/lib/apps directory also shows the correct contents of red:/var/libs/apps. This is what I believe are nested mount points. However when I try the same thing with an LDAP direct map it fails. he contents of the same map in LDAP is below.

dn: automountKey=/data,automountMapName=direct_map,ou=Autofs,dc=example,dc=com
automountInformation: -fstype=nfs,rw red:/usr/local/app
automountKey: /data
objectClass: automount
objectClass: top

dn: automountKey=/data/libs/apps,automountMapName=direct_map,ou=Autofs,dc=example,dc=com
automountKey: /data/libs/apps
objectClass: automount
objectClass: top
automountInformation: -fstype=nfs,rw red://var/libs/apps

When I do this in my LDAP map as shown above, the mount points do not show up correctly. The /data directory covers up one of the 2 mount points. So it looks like nested mount points don't work in LDAP or I am not using correct syntax. All my other LDAP mounts work but two mount points in the same dir does not work like it does with local direct maps.

Quoted 3 lines

Can you please confirm or deny if I can achieve nested mount points using LDAP direct maps like I can with local direct maps as shown above?

LDAP map isn't quite right.

The LDAP map entry must be the same as your file map.

In your file map the direct mount is
key = "/data"
location = "/ red:/usr/local/app /libs/apps red:/var/libs/apps"

In your original file map the "/" offset has been implied because the syntax allows it to be optional.

and in LDAP
key = "/data"
location = "red:/usr/local/app"

key = "/data/libs/apps"
Invalid, you can't nest distinct direct mounts.

You need to use the same value for location as you did for the file map in LDAP.

Quoted 8 lines

Thank you

_______________________________________________
autofs mailing list
[email protected]
http://linux.kernel.org/mailman/listinfo/autofs

author
#2 lore raw
Quoted 57 lines · Ian Kent
Quoted 37 lines · Techie

Hello,

I have a simple question regarding LDAP direct map mounts.

If I use a local direct map "/etc/direct_map"  with the below contents to map NFS directories on two different file systems.

/data                                    red:/usr/local/app   \
         /libs/apps                    red:/var/libs/apps

Both mount points to map properly. The /data directory shows the correct contents of red:/usr/local/app. And the /data/lib/apps directory also shows the correct contents of  red:/var/libs/apps. This is what I believe are nested mount points. However when I try the same thing with an LDAP direct map it fails. he contents of the same map in LDAP is below.

dn: automountKey=/data,automountMapName=direct_map,ou=Autofs,dc=example,dc=com
automountInformation: -fstype=nfs,rw red:/usr/local/app
automountKey: /data
objectClass: automount
objectClass: top

dn: automountKey=/data/libs/apps,automountMapName=direct_map,ou=Autofs,dc=example,dc=com
automountKey: /data/libs/apps
objectClass: automount
objectClass: top
automountInformation: -fstype=nfs,rw red://var/libs/apps

When I do this in my LDAP map as shown above, the mount points do not show up correctly. The /data directory covers up one of the 2 mount points. So it looks like nested mount points don't work in LDAP or I am not using correct syntax. All my other LDAP mounts work but two mount points in the same dir does not work like it does with local direct maps.

Quoted 3 lines

Can you please confirm or deny if I can achieve nested mount points using LDAP direct maps like I can with local direct maps as shown above?

LDAP map isn't quite right.

The LDAP map entry must be the same as your file map.

In your file map the direct mount is
key = "/data"
location = "/ red:/usr/local/app /libs/apps red:/var/libs/apps"

In your original file map the "/" offset has been implied because the syntax allows it to be optional.

and in LDAP
key = "/data"
location = "red:/usr/local/app"

Quoted 11 lines

key = "/data/libs/apps"
Invalid, you can't nest distinct direct mounts.

You need to use the same value for location as you did for the file map in LDAP.

Quoted 5 lines

Thank you

_______________________________________________

Ian,
Thanks a bunch for pointing out that the "/" offset is syntactically optional for file based maps but is necessary in LDAP. That really helped my understanding of both formats..

Regards
J

_______________________________________________
autofs mailing list
[email protected]
http://linux.kernel.org/mailman/listinfo/autofs

maintainer
#3 lore raw
Quoted 66 lines · Techie
Quoted 65 lines · Ian Kent
Quoted 37 lines · Techie

Hello,

I have a simple question regarding LDAP direct map mounts.

If I use a local direct map "/etc/direct_map" with the below contents to map NFS directories on two different file systems.

/data red:/usr/local/app \
/libs/apps red:/var/libs/apps

Both mount points to map properly. The /data directory shows the correct contents of red:/usr/local/app. And the /data/lib/apps directory also shows the correct contents of red:/var/libs/apps. This is what I believe are nested mount points. However when I try the same thing with an LDAP direct map it fails. he contents of the same map in LDAP is below.

dn: automountKey=/data,automountMapName=direct_map,ou=Autofs,dc=example,dc=com
automountInformation: -fstype=nfs,rw red:/usr/local/app
automountKey: /data
objectClass: automount
objectClass: top

dn: automountKey=/data/libs/apps,automountMapName=direct_map,ou=Autofs,dc=example,dc=com
automountKey: /data/libs/apps
objectClass: automount
objectClass: top
automountInformation: -fstype=nfs,rw red://var/libs/apps

When I do this in my LDAP map as shown above, the mount points do not show up correctly. The /data directory covers up one of the 2 mount points. So it looks like nested mount points don't work in LDAP or I am not using correct syntax. All my other LDAP mounts work but two mount points in the same dir does not work like it does with local direct maps.

Quoted 3 lines

Can you please confirm or deny if I can achieve nested mount points using LDAP direct maps like I can with local direct maps as shown above?

LDAP map isn't quite right.

The LDAP map entry must be the same as your file map.

In your file map the direct mount is
key = "/data"
location = "/ red:/usr/local/app /libs/apps red:/var/libs/apps"

In your original file map the "/" offset has been implied because the syntax allows it to be optional.

and in LDAP
key = "/data"
location = "red:/usr/local/app"

key = "/data/libs/apps"
Invalid, you can't nest distinct direct mounts.

You need to use the same value for location as you did for the file map in LDAP.

Quoted 2 lines
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Thank you

_______________________________________________

Ian,
Thanks a bunch for pointing out that the "/" offset is syntactically optional for file based maps but is necessary in LDAP. That really helped my understanding of both formats..

No, actually it's always optional but can cause confusion when omitted.

The issue was that you can't break up the mount location into two separate entries (either in a file map or LDAP, LDAP convention just happens to make you want to do it that way). You just need to feed the same string to the daemon whether the map is in a file or stored in LDAP.

Ian

author
#4 lore raw
Quoted 77 lines · Ian Kent
Quoted 66 lines · Techie
Quoted 65 lines · Ian Kent
Quoted 37 lines · Techie

Hello,

I have a simple question regarding LDAP direct map mounts.

If I use a local direct map "/etc/direct_map"  with the below contents to map NFS directories on two different file systems.

/data                                    red:/usr/local/app   \
         /libs/apps                    red:/var/libs/apps

Both mount points to map properly. The /data directory shows the correct contents of red:/usr/local/app. And the /data/lib/apps directory also shows the correct contents of  red:/var/libs/apps. This is what I believe are nested mount points. However when I try the same thing with an LDAP direct map it fails. he contents of the same map in LDAP is below.

dn: automountKey=/data,automountMapName=direct_map,ou=Autofs,dc=example,dc=com
automountInformation: -fstype=nfs,rw red:/usr/local/app
automountKey: /data
objectClass: automount
objectClass: top

dn: automountKey=/data/libs/apps,automountMapName=direct_map,ou=Autofs,dc=example,dc=com
automountKey: /data/libs/apps
objectClass: automount
objectClass: top
automountInformation: -fstype=nfs,rw red://var/libs/apps

When I do this in my LDAP map as shown above, the mount points do not show up correctly. The /data directory covers up one of the 2 mount points. So it looks like nested mount points don't work in LDAP or I am not using correct syntax. All my other LDAP mounts work but two mount points in the same dir does not work like it does with local direct maps.

Quoted 3 lines

Can you please confirm or deny if I can achieve nested mount points using LDAP direct maps like I can with local direct maps as shown above?

LDAP map isn't quite right.

The LDAP map entry must be the same as your file map.

In your file map the direct mount is
key = "/data"
location = "/ red:/usr/local/app /libs/apps red:/var/libs/apps"

In your original file map the "/" offset has been implied because the syntax allows it to be optional.

and in LDAP
key = "/data"
location = "red:/usr/local/app"

key = "/data/libs/apps"
Invalid, you can't nest distinct direct mounts.

You need to use the same value for location as you did for the file map in LDAP.

Quoted 2 lines
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Thank you

_______________________________________________

Ian,
Thanks a bunch for pointing out that the "/" offset is syntactically optional for file based maps but is necessary in LDAP. That really helped my understanding of both formats..

No, actually it's always optional but can cause confusion when omitted.

Quoted 8 lines

The issue was that you can't break up the mount location into two separate entries (either in a file map or LDAP, LDAP convention just happens to make you want to do it that way). You just need to feed the same string to the daemon whether the map is in a file or stored in LDAP.

Ian

I see that makes sense, thank you.
I was also trying to specify multiple direct maps in LDAP. I tried creating another direct map with a "/-" key but ldap complained saying that the "/-" key already exists. Which makes sense as the two DNs would be the same.

In a /etc/auto.master local file I can have multiple direct map entries with ...
/- /etc/map1
/- /etc/map2

I was able to accomplish this in ldap by appending multiple map names to the automountinformation attribute of the dn: automountKey=/- entry. I am not sure if this is the proper way to do however it seems to work well so I imagine it may be. I am able to use the different maps by specifying them by name in the client auto.master files. AutoFS5 seems to be able to do everything I need it to, it's greatly improved over Autofs4 from what I can tell.

Thanks again
J

_______________________________________________
autofs mailing list
[email protected]
http://linux.kernel.org/mailman/listinfo/autofs

maintainer
#5 lore raw
Quoted 97 lines · Techie
Quoted 77 lines · Ian Kent
Quoted 66 lines · Techie
Quoted 65 lines · Ian Kent
Quoted 37 lines · Techie

Hello,

I have a simple question regarding LDAP direct map mounts.

If I use a local direct map "/etc/direct_map" with the below contents to map NFS directories on two different file systems.

/data red:/usr/local/app \
/libs/apps red:/var/libs/apps

Both mount points to map properly. The /data directory shows the correct contents of red:/usr/local/app. And the /data/lib/apps directory also shows the correct contents of red:/var/libs/apps. This is what I believe are nested mount points. However when I try the same thing with an LDAP direct map it fails. he contents of the same map in LDAP is below.

dn: automountKey=/data,automountMapName=direct_map,ou=Autofs,dc=example,dc=com
automountInformation: -fstype=nfs,rw red:/usr/local/app
automountKey: /data
objectClass: automount
objectClass: top

dn: automountKey=/data/libs/apps,automountMapName=direct_map,ou=Autofs,dc=example,dc=com
automountKey: /data/libs/apps
objectClass: automount
objectClass: top
automountInformation: -fstype=nfs,rw red://var/libs/apps

When I do this in my LDAP map as shown above, the mount points do not show up correctly. The /data directory covers up one of the 2 mount points. So it looks like nested mount points don't work in LDAP or I am not using correct syntax. All my other LDAP mounts work but two mount points in the same dir does not work like it does with local direct maps.

Quoted 3 lines

Can you please confirm or deny if I can achieve nested mount points using LDAP direct maps like I can with local direct maps as shown above?

LDAP map isn't quite right.

The LDAP map entry must be the same as your file map.

In your file map the direct mount is
key = "/data"
location = "/ red:/usr/local/app /libs/apps red:/var/libs/apps"

In your original file map the "/" offset has been implied because the syntax allows it to be optional.

and in LDAP
key = "/data"
location = "red:/usr/local/app"

key = "/data/libs/apps"
Invalid, you can't nest distinct direct mounts.

You need to use the same value for location as you did for the file map in LDAP.

Quoted 2 lines
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Thank you

_______________________________________________

Ian,
Thanks a bunch for pointing out that the "/" offset is syntactically optional for file based maps but is necessary in LDAP. That really helped my understanding of both formats..

No, actually it's always optional but can cause confusion when omitted.

Quoted 8 lines

The issue was that you can't break up the mount location into two separate entries (either in a file map or LDAP, LDAP convention just happens to make you want to do it that way). You just need to feed the same string to the daemon whether the map is in a file or stored in LDAP.

Ian

I see that makes sense, thank you.
I was also trying to specify multiple direct maps in LDAP. I tried creating another direct map with a "/-" key but ldap complained saying that the "/-" key already exists. Which makes sense as the two DNs would be the same.

In a /etc/auto.master local file I can have multiple direct map entries with ...
/- /etc/map1
/- /etc/map2

Quoted 7 lines

I was able to accomplish this in ldap by appending multiple map names to the automountinformation attribute of the dn: automountKey=/- entry. I am not sure if this is the proper way to do however it seems to work well so I imagine it may be. I am able to use the different maps by specifying them by name in the client auto.master files. AutoFS5 seems to be able to do everything I need it to, it's greatly improved over Autofs4 from what I can tell.

Yes, that is a limitation of ldap, bummer.

It is interesting to hear placing multiple map names in the automountinformation attribute works for you, I didn't expect that would work. I thought we would need to use a file or NIS based master map to specify multiple direct map entries or use a schema that doesn't enforce uniqueness and somehow name the dn a little differently.

Ian