Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Is Sony violating Linux GPL?

DISCUSSION Salvador Fandino 4 participants 4 messages Jan 9, 2006

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hi,

A couple of months ago I bought a Sony Vaio VGN-TX50B. It comes with an embedded version of Linux used to run a multimedia player (InterVideo InstantON) without booting the main OS.

A booklet containing a copy of the GPL and other free licenses was included on the laptop package. A note on the same booklet pointed to
http://www.sony.net/Products/Linux/Download/search.html as the place were the GPL'ed software could be downloaded.

My laptop has a couple of ports for SD and a MagicGate memories not supported by Linux, but that are usable from the multimedia player and so that have to be supported by the custom kernel included on the laptop. I downloaded the kernel package available from the Sony website expecting to found the source code for the drivers there, but after closer examination, I found it was an unmodified copy of the Linux sources.

Then I started mailing Vaio technical support ([email protected]), asking for the drivers source code, and after several mails they just refused to give me the drivers source code because "These drivers are directly delivered to us by the manufacturers of the hardware and modified by us and therefore we are not obliged to supply any source code for these drivers".

I am not an expert on Linux internals but I doubt a driver for this kind of device could be developed independently enough of the kernel to not be considered a derived work, so is Sony violating the Linux license?

lspci -v

0000:06:05.3 Mass storage controller: Texas Instruments PCIxx21 Integrated FlashMedia Controller
Subsystem: Sony Corporation: Unknown device 81e2
Flags: bus master, medium devsel, latency 57, IRQ 10 Memory at b0104000 (32-bit, non-prefetchable) [size=8K]
Capabilities: [44] Power Management version 2

Cheers,

- Salvador

#1 lore raw
Quoted 10 lines · Salvador Fandino

Then I started mailing Vaio technical support ([email protected]), asking for the drivers source code, and after several mails they just refused to give me the drivers source code because "These drivers are directly delivered to us by the manufacturers of the hardware and modified by us and therefore we are not obliged to supply any source code for these drivers".

I am not an expert on Linux internals but I doubt a driver for this kind of device could be developed independently enough of the kernel to not be considered a derived work, so is Sony violating the Linux license?

They are correct. The deal with modules is they don't have to GPL them.

It's also not entirely impossible for them to use stock kernel source to build a simple boot system for just a media player.

What would be nice is if Sony or someone would push this hardware manufacturer to open up their drivers.

Signature · 3 lines
   Ben Collins <[email protected]>
   Developer
   Ubuntu Linux
#2 lore raw
Quoted 4 lines · Ben Collins
Quoted 2 lines

of device could be developed independently enough of the kernel to not be considered a derived work, so is Sony violating the Linux license?

They are correct. The deal with modules is they don't have to GPL them.

There is no such "deal". Whether Sony is violating the license is a matter of interpretation of the boundary lines that in law define a "derived work". Nothing else.

Many of the Linux kernel copyright holders (including the FSF) are of opinions that some or indeed all kernel modules are derivative works. There is currently no directly relevant legal test case to assertain this reliably.

At the moment the bigger concern however is not legal corner cases but the huge number of vendors directly violating the GPL.

Alan

#3 lore raw
In reply to Ben Collins
Quoted 8 lines · Ben Collins
Quoted 7 lines · Salvador Fandino

Then I started mailing Vaio technical support ([email protected]), asking for the drivers source code, and after several mails they just refused to give me the drivers source code because "These drivers are directly delivered to us by the manufacturers of the hardware and modified by us and therefore we are not obliged to supply any source code for these drivers".

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 3 lines

I am not an expert on Linux internals but I doubt a driver for this kind of device could be developed independently enough of the kernel to not be considered a derived work, so is Sony violating the Linux license?

They are correct. The deal with modules is they don't have to GPL them.

there is no such agreement or deal. There is no exception to the GPL in this regard at all (but yes that's a semi common misconception/excuse used by binary driver people)