Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Journaling pointless with today's hard disks?

DISCUSSION Pete Zaitcev 2 participants 2 messages Nov 25, 2001 1 message not in the archive

lore
Share & tools
lore

A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]

#1 lore raw
Quoted 10 lines

[...]
It is the responsibility of the power monitor to detect a power-fail event and tell the drive(s) that a power-fail event is occurring.

Most power supplies are not designed to hold up for more than 30-60 ms at full load upon removal of mains power. Power-fail detect typically requires 12 ms (three-quarters cycle average at 60 Hz) or 15 ms (three-quarters cycle average at 50 Hz) to detect that mains power has failed, leaving your system a very short time to abort that long queue of disk write commands.

This is a total crap argument, because you invent an impossible request, pretend that your opponent made that request, then show that it's impossible to fulfill the impossible requesti. No shit, sherlock! Of course it's "a very short time to abort that long queue of disk write commands".

However, what is asked here is entirely different: disks must complete writes of sectors that they started writing, this is all. They do not need to report _anything_ to the host, in fact they may ignore the host interface completely the moment the power failure sequence is triggered. Neither they need to do anything about queued commands: abort them, discard in any way, or whatever. Just complete the sector, and start head landing sequence.

IBM Deskstar is completely broken, and that's a fact.

BTW, hpa went on how he was buying IBM drives, how good they were, and what a surprise it was that IBM fucked Deskstar. Hardly a surprise. The first time I heard of IBM drive was a horror story. Our company was making RAID arrays, and we sourced new IBM SCSI disks. They were qualified through a rigorous testing as it was the procedure in the company. So, after a while they started to fail. It turned out that bearings leaked grease to platters. Of course, we shipped tens of thousands of those when IBM explained to us that every one of them will die in a year. We shipped Seagates ever after.

-- Pete

#2 lore raw

With those Seagates you probably just got yourself something else to
worry about, maybe even more sneaky than disks failing completely after one year. I've had a $40.000+ external raid system (brand withhold), promising reliability and data security at all levels, and with enough bells and whistles to bore a "geek". It came with Hitachi disks and that surprised me, because that box was replacing a same brand one that was sold with IBM disks - the best and the only thing they used, i was told. I thought maybe they knew something we don't, or maybe they were really special. Anyway, some time later we started having complete disk lockups in the device. Honest, the hardware would find a bad block in one of the disks with parity that weren't remaped. And for some reason the hardware would just freeze after some time. After checking with support we were sent a new batch of disks to replace the current ones, with a different firmware level. It did the trick. After backing up and restoring 360GB of data, of course. But this begs for some questions. And it really makes me worry about where the industry is going. Is it the increasing complexity of the technology? Are they cutting too many corners on trying to reach the market sooner? Or just cost cutting with old fashioned second source suppliers? I am more and more worried about what passes as "enterprise level storage" these days.

/Pedro

Quoted 20 lines · Pete Zaitcev

IBM Deskstar is completely broken, and that's a fact.

BTW, hpa went on how he was buying IBM drives, how good they were, and what a surprise it was that IBM fucked Deskstar. Hardly a surprise. The first time I heard of IBM drive was a horror story. Our company was making RAID arrays, and we sourced new IBM SCSI disks. They were qualified through a rigorous testing as it was the procedure in the company. So, after a while they started to fail. It turned out that bearings leaked grease to platters. Of course, we shipped tens of thousands of those when IBM explained to us that every one of them will die in a year. We shipped Seagates ever after.

-- Pete
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in the body of a message to [email protected] More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/