Skip to contentSkip to conversation

more bridging + qos confusion

LARTC Abraham van der Merwe 2 participants 6 messages Mar 4, 2003

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hi!

If I create the following setup:

66.8.28.52/29 66.8.28.51/29

  +------+                  +------+
  | PC A |------+ +---------| PC B |
  +------+      | |         +------+
                | |
            eth1| | eth0
              +-----+
              | qos | (br0 = 66.8.28.49/29)
              +-----+

PC A is connected to qos via crossover cable and PC B and qos is plugged into same switch. So even though everything is on the same network, traffic has to go through qos when PC A talks to PC B.

Now, if PC A ping PC B, then my packet counters on the PREROUTING, INPUT, FORWARD, OUTPUT, POSTROUTING chains stay the same for both filter and mangle tables - i.e. netfilter don't see any traffic flowing through the machine.

Why is this? How do I match this traffic using netfilter? I can't use ebtables because I have to match traffic in the mangle table if I want to use it in conjunction with tc.

Signature · 11 lines
Regards
 Abraham

By the yard, life is hard.
By the inch, it's a cinch.

___________________________________________________
 Abraham vd Merwe [ZR1BBQ] - Frogfoot Networks
 P.O. Box 3472, Matieland, Stellenbosch, 7602
 Cell: +27 82 565 4451 Http: http://www.frogfoot.net/
 Email: [email protected]
#1 lore raw

It sounds like you are running bridging with the netfilter hooks.

See the section at the bottom of the page on bridging + firewalling (really netfilter hooks):

http://bridge.sourceforge.net/download.html

And of course, the newest patches here:

http://users.pandora.be/bart.de.schuymer/ebtables/sourcecode.html

Are you running a kernel with support for bridge+nf (as it is known)?

-Martin

: If I create the following setup:
:
:
:
: 66.8.28.52/29 66.8.28.51/29

 :   +------+                  +------+
 :   | PC A |------+ +---------| PC B |
 :   +------+      | |         +------+
 :                 | |
 :             eth1| | eth0
 :               +-----+
 :               | qos | (br0 = 66.8.28.49/29)
 :               +-----+

:
: PC A is connected to qos via crossover cable and PC B and qos is plugged : into same switch. So even though everything is on the same network, traffic : has to go through qos when PC A talks to PC B.
:
: Now, if PC A ping PC B, then my packet counters on the PREROUTING, INPUT, : FORWARD, OUTPUT, POSTROUTING chains stay the same for both filter and mangle : tables - i.e. netfilter don't see any traffic flowing through the machine. :
: Why is this? How do I match this traffic using netfilter? I can't use : ebtables because I have to match traffic in the mangle table if I want to : use it in conjunction with tc.
:
:

Signature · 5 lines
Martin A. Brown --- SecurePipe, Inc. --- [email protected]

_______________________________________________
LARTC mailing list / [email protected]
http://mailman.ds9a.nl/mailman/listinfo/lartc HOWTO: http://lartc.org/
#2 lore raw
In reply to Abraham van der Merwe

Hi Martin!

No, I'm not running with ebtables+nf support. From what I understand (and please correct me if I'm wrong), patching the kernel with ebtables+bridge-nf, you get an ebtables table with BROUTING, FORWARD, and NAT chains which you can match traffic on.

However, I need to match traffic in the mangles table, so the ebtables table won't help me.

Some questions:

(a) If I add the bridge-nf + ebtables patches, will I be able to match traffic on OUTPUT/FORWARD/POSTROUTING in the mangle table?

(b) Why does netfilter not currently see the traffic even though a tcpdump on eth0/eth1 shows all the traffic passing through the interfaces?

Quoted 42 lines

It sounds like you are running bridging with the netfilter hooks.

See the section at the bottom of the page on bridging + firewalling (really netfilter hooks):

http://bridge.sourceforge.net/download.html

And of course, the newest patches here:

http://users.pandora.be/bart.de.schuymer/ebtables/sourcecode.html

Are you running a kernel with support for bridge+nf (as it is known)?

-Martin

: If I create the following setup:
:
:
:
: 66.8.28.52/29 66.8.28.51/29

 :   +------+                  +------+
 :   | PC A |------+ +---------| PC B |
 :   +------+      | |         +------+
 :                 | |
 :             eth1| | eth0
 :               +-----+
 :               | qos | (br0 = 66.8.28.49/29)
 :               +-----+

:
: PC A is connected to qos via crossover cable and PC B and qos is plugged : into same switch. So even though everything is on the same network, traffic : has to go through qos when PC A talks to PC B.
:
: Now, if PC A ping PC B, then my packet counters on the PREROUTING, INPUT, : FORWARD, OUTPUT, POSTROUTING chains stay the same for both filter and mangle : tables - i.e. netfilter don't see any traffic flowing through the machine. :
: Why is this? How do I match this traffic using netfilter? I can't use : ebtables because I have to match traffic in the mangle table if I want to : use it in conjunction with tc.
:
:

Signature · 12 lines
Regards
 Abraham

I'm telling you that the kernel is stable not because it's a kernel,
but because I refuse to listen to arguments like this.
	-- Linus Torvalds

___________________________________________________
 Abraham vd Merwe [ZR1BBQ] - Frogfoot Networks
 P.O. Box 3472, Matieland, Stellenbosch, 7602
 Cell: +27 82 565 4451 Http: http://www.frogfoot.net/
 Email: [email protected]
#3 lore raw
In reply to Abraham van der Merwe

<bill-the-cat-sound> Ack! I meant to say:

"It sounds like you are running bridging without the netfilter hooks."

But, of course, you understood what I meant.

: No, I'm not running with ebtables+nf support. From what I understand : (and please correct me if I'm wrong), patching the kernel with : ebtables+bridge-nf, you get an ebtables table with BROUTING, FORWARD, : and NAT chains which you can match traffic on.
:
: However, I need to match traffic in the mangles table, so the ebtables : table won't help me.

In order for you to be able to use iptables *at all* with the bridging code, you need the bridge+nf patch(es).

: (a) If I add the bridge-nf + ebtables patches, will I be able to match
: traffic on OUTPUT/FORWARD/POSTROUTING in the mangle table?

Good question. I haven't used the OUTPUT and POSTROUTING chains, but I have used the FORWARD chain on a bridge+nf installation. I think the link you forwarded to this list earlier today [1] shows the sequence of netfilter hook traversal, but assumes that you are running bridge+nf.

: (b) Why does netfilter not currently see the traffic even though a tcpdump
: on eth0/eth1 shows all the traffic passing through the interfaces?

See above....

-Martin

[1] http://www.sparkle-cc.co.uk/firewall/firewall.html

Signature · 5 lines
Martin A. Brown --- SecurePipe, Inc. --- [email protected]

_______________________________________________
LARTC mailing list / [email protected]
http://mailman.ds9a.nl/mailman/listinfo/lartc HOWTO: http://lartc.org/
#4 lore raw
In reply to Abraham van der Merwe

Hi Martin!

Quoted 10 lines

: No, I'm not running with ebtables+nf support. From what I understand : (and please correct me if I'm wrong), patching the kernel with : ebtables+bridge-nf, you get an ebtables table with BROUTING, FORWARD, : and NAT chains which you can match traffic on.
:
: However, I need to match traffic in the mangles table, so the ebtables : table won't help me.

In order for you to be able to use iptables *at all* with the bridging code, you need the bridge+nf patch(es).

Ah ok. Which patch should I use
(http://bridge.sourceforge.net/devel/bridge-nf/bridge-nf-0.0.7-against-2.4.19.diff
or
http://users.pandora.be/bart.de.schuymer/ebtables/br-nf/bridge-nf-0.0.10-against-2.4.20.diff)

I've used the latter with 2.4.21pre5, but it seems as if the first one was created for iptables and the latter for ebtables - is that correct or can I use both?

I'll test it now with the new one anyway and see if I can match packets in the mangle table.

Signature · 15 lines
Regards
 Abraham

Heller's Law:
	The first myth of management is that it exists.

Johnson's Corollary:
	Nobody really knows what is going on anywhere within the
	organization.

___________________________________________________
 Abraham vd Merwe [ZR1BBQ] - Frogfoot Networks
 P.O. Box 3472, Matieland, Stellenbosch, 7602
 Cell: +27 82 565 4451 Http: http://www.frogfoot.net/
 Email: [email protected]
#5 lore raw
In reply to Abraham van der Merwe

Hi Martin!

I just applied the bridge-nf and ebtables patches and tried it and I can match packets in the mangle table as usual (also have to use FORWARD for packets passing through the machine).

Quoted 33 lines

<bill-the-cat-sound> Ack! I meant to say:

"It sounds like you are running bridging without the netfilter hooks."

But, of course, you understood what I meant.

: No, I'm not running with ebtables+nf support. From what I understand : (and please correct me if I'm wrong), patching the kernel with : ebtables+bridge-nf, you get an ebtables table with BROUTING, FORWARD, : and NAT chains which you can match traffic on.
:
: However, I need to match traffic in the mangles table, so the ebtables : table won't help me.

In order for you to be able to use iptables *at all* with the bridging code, you need the bridge+nf patch(es).

: (a) If I add the bridge-nf + ebtables patches, will I be able to match
: traffic on OUTPUT/FORWARD/POSTROUTING in the mangle table?

Good question. I haven't used the OUTPUT and POSTROUTING chains, but I have used the FORWARD chain on a bridge+nf installation. I think the link you forwarded to this list earlier today [1] shows the sequence of netfilter hook traversal, but assumes that you are running bridge+nf.

: (b) Why does netfilter not currently see the traffic even though a tcpdump
: on eth0/eth1 shows all the traffic passing through the interfaces?

See above....

-Martin

[1] http://www.sparkle-cc.co.uk/firewall/firewall.html

Signature · 11 lines
Regards
 Abraham

It is more rational to sacrifice one life than six.
		-- Spock, "The Galileo Seven", stardate 2822.3

___________________________________________________
 Abraham vd Merwe [ZR1BBQ] - Frogfoot Networks
 P.O. Box 3472, Matieland, Stellenbosch, 7602
 Cell: +27 82 565 4451 Http: http://www.frogfoot.net/
 Email: [email protected]