Skip to contentSkip to conversation

modutils 2.4.2 and USB

Linux-ia64 Michael Madore 3 participants 6 messages Feb 12, 2001

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hi,

I have just built kernel 2.4.1 with the IA64 patch, and also the latest (2.4.2) modutils. All of the USB options are compiled as modules, with the exception of USB-Core, which is compiled statically. After installing everything, running depmod -a yields:

depmod: Module /lib/modules/2.4.1-010131-1smp/kernel/drivers/usb/acm.o has an unknown version (2) usb_device table
It is likely that the kernel structure has changed, if so then you probably need a new version of modutils to handle this kernel. Check linux/Documentation/Changes.

Is this a known problem?

Signature · 3 lines
Mike Madore
Software Engineer
TurboLinux, Inc.
#1 lore raw
Quoted 5 lines · Michael Madore

I have just built kernel 2.4.1 with the IA64 patch, and also the latest (2.4.2) modutils. All of the USB options are compiled as modules, with the exception of USB-Core, which is compiled statically. After installing everything, running depmod -a yields:

Quoted 7 lines

depmod: Module /lib/modules/2.4.1-010131-1smp/kernel/drivers/usb/acm.o has an unknown version (2) usb_device table
It is likely that the kernel structure has changed, if so then you probably need a new version of modutils to handle this kernel. Check linux/Documentation/Changes.

Is this a known problem?

That is definately weird. Keith Owens wanted to add a version information to help fix a problem we ran into with 2.4.0.

Right before 2.4.0 we had to modify the usb_device_id structure to add some extra information to make it work correctly. However, this didn't change the size of the structure (because of alignment reasons) and as a result it was difficult for modutils to tell the difference between the old style structure and the new style structure.

Both Linus and I didn't want to add the version information in 2.4 and we just told him to drop the support for the old style structure since it was only found in development kernels.

The code stayed in modutils it appears since it wouldn't get in the way of anything and it would be used in 2.5.

But, the patch never went into the kernel and it shouldn't be finding any version information. Is there a __module_usb_device_ver symbol in acm.o?

JE

#2 lore raw
In reply to Michael Madore
Quoted 27 lines · Johannes Erdfelt
Quoted 5 lines · Michael Madore

I have just built kernel 2.4.1 with the IA64 patch, and also the latest (2.4.2) modutils. All of the USB options are compiled as modules, with the exception of USB-Core, which is compiled statically. After installing everything, running depmod -a yields:

Quoted 7 lines

depmod: Module /lib/modules/2.4.1-010131-1smp/kernel/drivers/usb/acm.o has an unknown version (2) usb_device table
It is likely that the kernel structure has changed, if so then you probably need a new version of modutils to handle this kernel. Check linux/Documentation/Changes.

Is this a known problem?

That is definately weird. Keith Owens wanted to add a version information to help fix a problem we ran into with 2.4.0.

Right before 2.4.0 we had to modify the usb_device_id structure to add some extra information to make it work correctly. However, this didn't change the size of the structure (because of alignment reasons) and as a result it was difficult for modutils to tell the difference between the old style structure and the new style structure.

Both Linus and I didn't want to add the version information in 2.4 and we just told him to drop the support for the old style structure since it was only found in development kernels.

Quoted 5 lines

The code stayed in modutils it appears since it wouldn't get in the way of anything and it would be used in 2.5.

But, the patch never went into the kernel and it shouldn't be finding any version information. Is there a __module_usb_device_ver symbol in acm.o?

Yes, acm.o has a symbol called __module_usb_device_ver. If I temporarily remove acm.o, I get the same message for audio.o, so it isn't a problem just with that module.

Signature · 3 lines
Mike Madore
Software Engineer
TurboLinux, Inc.
#3 lore raw
In reply to Michael Madore
Quoted 17 lines · Michael Madore
Quoted 16 lines · Johannes Erdfelt

That is definately weird. Keith Owens wanted to add a version information to help fix a problem we ran into with 2.4.0.

Right before 2.4.0 we had to modify the usb_device_id structure to add some extra information to make it work correctly. However, this didn't change the size of the structure (because of alignment reasons) and as a result it was difficult for modutils to tell the difference between the old style structure and the new style structure.

Both Linus and I didn't want to add the version information in 2.4 and we just told him to drop the support for the old style structure since it was only found in development kernels.

The code stayed in modutils it appears since it wouldn't get in the way of anything and it would be used in 2.5.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines

But, the patch never went into the kernel and it shouldn't be finding any version information. Is there a __module_usb_device_ver symbol in acm.o?

Yes, acm.o has a symbol called __module_usb_device_ver. If I temporarily remove acm.o, I get the same message for audio.o, so it isn't a problem just with that module.

Exactly which patches did you apply? My ia64 development system only has the symbols which should be there.

0000000000000020 ? __module_author
0000000000000068 ? __module_description
0000000000000000 ? __module_kernel_version
0000000000000000 g __module_usb_device_size
0000000000000008 g __module_usb_device_table
U __this_module

JE

#4 lore raw
In reply to Michael Madore
Quoted 5 lines · Michael Madore

depmod: Module /lib/modules/2.4.1-010131-1smp/kernel/drivers/usb/acm.o has an unknown version (2) usb_device table
It is likely that the kernel structure has changed, if so then you probably need a new version of modutils to handle this kernel. Check linux/Documentation/Changes.

Somebody has included patch-2.4.0-hotplug.gz in your source tree. That patch is not to be used.

#5 lore raw
In reply to Michael Madore

Yes, you are correct. I've removed the patch and given myself 20 lashes with a wet noodle.

Quoted 10 lines · Keith Owens
Quoted 5 lines · Michael Madore

depmod: Module /lib/modules/2.4.1-010131-1smp/kernel/drivers/usb/acm.o has an unknown version (2) usb_device table
It is likely that the kernel structure has changed, if so then you probably need a new version of modutils to handle this kernel. Check linux/Documentation/Changes.

Somebody has included patch-2.4.0-hotplug.gz in your source tree. That patch is not to be used.

Signature · 3 lines
Mike Madore
Software Engineer
TurboLinux, Inc.