Itanium gets supercomputing software
Quoted 7 lines · Matt Chapman
Quoted 3 lines · Duraid Madina
I put it to you that software is easier to develop on hardware. Nothing unique to IA64, indeed.
We still use simulators despite the availability of hardware. Operating system software is often easier to debug on a simulator.
Exactly. There are a lot of things that you can do with a simulator that you can't do with hardware. Developing software before hardware is available is just one of them. (plug mode on) That's why we sell simulators for most major current CPU architectures. Including IA64.
Signature · 2 lines
David Kågedal, Virtutech http://www.simics.com/
I guess I was being a bit subtle.
I'm well aware there are things you can do with a simulator that you can't do with hardware. Like test your code against what's supposed to happen, not what actually happens. ;)
My point wasn't that software simulators are useless, but that software simulators _should_ be useless **4 years** (!!) after the public availability of hardware.
Quoted 1 line · When I
I put it to you that software is easier to develop on hardware.
I meant that at this late stage, one would expect that people would be writing software, on their hardware. And not a whole lot else, all things considered. Do you see x86 linux people using simulators? Once in a blue moon, perhaps. Does anyone doubt that the x86-64 port will mature a heck of a lot faster than linux-ia64 has? One doesn't need to think for very long to realise why this might be.
Don't get me wrong, I think Linus was being a complete idiot for his comments against IA64 and for x86-64, but insofar as keeping hardware pricing so high that Joe K. Hacker can't even dream of affording it is "good business" on Intel/HP's part, it's an even better way of keeping your kernel untested.
Duraid
Quoted 4 lines · David Kågedal
Exactly. There are a lot of things that you can do with a simulator that you can't do with hardware. Developing software before hardware is available is just one of them. (plug mode on) That's why we sell simulators for most major current CPU architectures. Including IA64.
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line · Duraid Madina
Duraid> My point wasn't that software simulators are useless, but Duraid> that software simulators _should_ be useless **4 years** Duraid> (!!) after the public availability of hardware.
Then how do you explain the popularity of user-mode linux on x86?
The reason I continue to use Ski is because it's one of the very few simulators out there that are (a) architecturally extremely accurate,
(b) fast, and (c) very easy to setup & use. Ski is an asset for ia64 linux, not a weakness.
(And no, just because we have Ski doesn't mean we don't use real
hardware. Nothing could be further from the truth.)
--david
Quoted 7 lines · David Mosberger
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line · Duraid Madina
Duraid> My point wasn't that software simulators are useless, but Duraid> that software simulators _should_ be useless **4 years** Duraid> (!!) after the public availability of hardware.
Then how do you explain the popularity of user-mode linux on x86?
If user-mode linux is "popular", then linux is "f@#%g buggy s#!t". I mean really, when your attitude to software development is:
<Linus> hey somethings wrong my swap is full what gives???? <Rik Riel> stop running 91589 copies of XMMS 8)
<Linus> shut up riel god i hate you
** Riel is banned from linux-kernel
<Andrea> YO CHECK OUT THE NEW VM SYSTEM I WROTE THIS
MORNING^H^H^H^H^H^H^HWEEK!! ITLL FIX YOUR PROBLEMS!!!!
<Linus> k i know 2.4 is supposed to be a "stable" kernel but god i hate
that riel dude!! :| welp.. out with the old, in with the new!!!!!
** Linus integrates new VM
<Andrea> THANKS D00D
<Linus> no probs m8
..then yes, having UML as a sandbox can help.
The UML guys see it differently though. According to them: "It doesn't need to be good for anything. It's fun!" Maybe Ski can embrace this spirit also. ;)
Quoted 7 lines
The reason I continue to use Ski is because it's one of the very few simulators out there that are (a) architecturally extremely accurate,
(b) fast, and (c) very easy to setup & use. Ski is an asset for ia64 linux, not a weakness.(And no, just because we have Ski doesn't mean we don't use real
hardware. Nothing could be further from the truth.)
That's right - _you_ use real hardware because you actually have it. Everyone else (figuratively speaking, though it's not far off the mark) has no choice _but_ to use Ski. That sucks, regardless of whether or not Ski is accurate, fast, or easy to use.
Anyway, I don't think there's much more that can be said. As Matt indicated, we must pray for Deerfield, so I will continue to align my holy carpet of hope to Fort Collins/Portland/Carly's hotel bedroom and pray for reasonably priced IA64 hardware.
Duraid
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line · Duraid Madina
Duraid> That's right - _you_ use real hardware because you actually have it. Duraid> Everyone else (figuratively speaking, though it's not far off the mark) Duraid> has no choice _but_ to use Ski. That sucks, regardless of whether or not Duraid> Ski is accurate, fast, or easy to use.
Duraid> Anyway, I don't think there's much more that can be said. As Matt Duraid> indicated, we must pray for Deerfield, so I will continue to align my Duraid> holy carpet of hope to Fort Collins/Portland/Carly's hotel bedroom and Duraid> pray for reasonably priced IA64 hardware.
Anyone can get access to ia64 hardware at:
They're shared machines, so kernel development is out, but for user-level development, they are very handy.
--david
Quoted 9 lines · Duraid Madina
I guess I was being a bit subtle.
I'm well aware there are things you can do with a simulator that you can't do with hardware. Like test your code against what's supposed to happen, not what actually happens. ;)
My point wasn't that software simulators are useless, but that software simulators _should_ be useless **4 years** (!!) after the public availability of hardware.
Why is that? There are numerous reasons for using simulators to develop software, especially low-level software (OS, drivers, firmware etc.) You get things like full system visibility, non-intrusive debugging, deterministic repeatability, fault injection, and more.
Signature · 1 line
David Kågedal, Virtutech