Skip to contentSkip to conversation

4D-NXs (was Re: Sync Issues)

linux-audio-dev Joe Miklojcik 2 participants 2 messages Oct 28, 1999 Sound

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw
Quoted 5 lines · Dan Hollis
Quoted 1 line · Paul Barton-Davis

* "we don't have enough programmers to do that"

If the drivers are being written for them by volunteers, I dont see how this is relevant.

They just can't imagine anybody who isn't in their shop writing a driver. It's a really crappy job.

Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 3 lines

* "we don't have any written documentation to give you guys - we wrote the driver by having the software group sit in with the hardware group"

This should be a warning sign to anyone thinking of purchasing their hardware. If a company cant be bothered to internally document the hardware, what happens if key engineers leave the company? Oh dear, their project is *permanently screwed*, which means zero support for end users. This is no way to run a company.

I agree. A couple of years ago, I badgered Opcode into giving me specs for their 8Port/SE under NDA so I could write a Linux driver for myself. It took three passes just to convince them that I could do it if I had the specs, even if I didn't work in their shop. It took two more passes to convince them that I would honor the NDA as I would any other legal obligation, and that I would furnish any results I gained working with NDA protected material back to them. Never mind Open Source, these guys didn't want me to know their deep dark "how to use a parallel port" secrets. Turns out the real reason it was pulling teeth to get their spec is that the spec revealed how shoddy of an engineering job the 8Port/SE was. I wound up destroying the spec and giving the unit to a Windows sufferer.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines

* "we think our hardware's proprietary secrets will be revealed if there is a source code driver"

Uh, isnt this what patents are for? If someone reverse engineers their card, they are *completely screwed* unless they have patent protection.

Shhh :) They haven't figured that out yet. It's the only thing saving us on a lot of the hardware Linux supports. I'm not a lawyer, but I think that they can deny the right to reverse engineer in a user license, which would make some drivers illegal. This leads to the silly phrase

"If drivers are outlawed, only outlaws will have drivers."

--
Joe Miklojcik - NBCS System Programmer - http://oss.rutgers.edu
The purpose of computing is insight, not numbers. --Richard W. Hamming, 1962

#1 lore raw
Quoted 8 lines · Joe Miklojcik
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 2 lines

* "we think our hardware's proprietary secrets will be revealed if there is a source code driver"

Uh, isnt this what patents are for? If someone reverse engineers their card, they are *completely screwed* unless they have patent protection.

Shhh :) They haven't figured that out yet. It's the only thing saving us on a lot of the hardware Linux supports. I'm not a lawyer, but I think that they can deny the right to reverse engineer in a user license, which would make some drivers illegal.

So you reverse engineer them in a country where such shrinkwrap licenses themselves are illegal. Isnt this most of europe? :)

Isnt there some precedent law in the US which basically says such licenses are unenforceable?

-Dan