Skip to contentSkip to conversation

SNATed connections show as original ip in /proc/net/tcp

DISCUSSION Noah McNallie 2 participants 4 messages Jul 11, 2010

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

just as the topic describes.

I'm currently doing SNAT to force some destination tcp ports to be routed through a specific route rather than the default route. To accomplish this I mark thoes packets with iptables, use 'ip' to specify marked packets via the specified route, and then use iptables to change their source address.

one problem i've noticed is that in netstat (and hence /proc/net/tcp) the connections are shown as their original source. this causes problems with some things such as identd, because identd won't see the SNATed to ip with that port open. hence it will reply that it has no connection.

anyway i can get around this?

noah

#1 lore raw
Quoted 3 lines · Noah McNallie

just as the topic describes.

Probably better to post this to netdev?

Quoted 5 lines

I'm currently doing SNAT to force some destination tcp ports to be routed through a specific route rather than the default route. To accomplish this I mark thoes packets with iptables, use 'ip' to specify marked packets via the specified route, and then use iptables to change their source address.

SNAT'ing locally sourced traffic? That's pretty nasty.

Look into using 'ip rule' and a second routing table.

http://lartc.org/howto/lartc.rpdb.html

You will still need use iptables/MARK to do L4 (tcp/udp/etc) policy routing though, however now you can dump the ugly SNATing.

Cheers

Signature · 2 lines
Alexander Clouter
.sigmonster says: Where do your SOCKS go when you lose them in th' WASHER?
#2 lore raw
Quoted 13 lines · Alexander Clouter
Quoted 3 lines · Noah McNallie

just as the topic describes.

Probably better to post this to netdev?

Quoted 5 lines

I'm currently doing SNAT to force some destination tcp ports to be routed through a specific route rather than the default route. To accomplish this I mark thoes packets with iptables, use 'ip' to specify marked packets via the specified route, and then use iptables to change their source address.

SNAT'ing locally sourced traffic? That's pretty nasty.

Quoted 9 lines

Look into using 'ip rule' and a second routing table.

http://lartc.org/howto/lartc.rpdb.html

You will still need use iptables/MARK to do L4 (tcp/udp/etc) policy routing though, however now you can dump the ugly SNATing.

Cheers

ok i'll stick it there i must have missed that browsing mailing lists last night... uhh as far as ip rule i am using that, that's how i match the packets with the firewall mark that need to go out a specific interface and to a specific route... i don't believe ip rule has any option to match packets based on destination port and change their source address and route them out any specific interface, or i'd be doing that all along as that would be much better.

noah

#3 lore raw
Quoted 8 lines · Noah McNallie
Quoted 7 lines

Look into using 'ip rule' and a second routing table.

http://lartc.org/howto/lartc.rpdb.html

You will still need use iptables/MARK to do L4 (tcp/udp/etc) policy routing though, however now you can dump the ugly SNATing.

Quoted 8 lines

ok i'll stick it there i must have missed that browsing mailing lists last night... uhh as far as ip rule i am using that, that's how i match the packets with the firewall mark that need to go out a specific interface and to a specific route... i don't believe ip rule has any option to match packets based on destination port and change their source address and route them out any specific interface, or i'd be doing that all along as that would be much better.

I read your original post as saying were using iptables and the SNAT action, I am suggesting you use 'ip rule' to say "if x/tcp or y/udp using routing table 'alternative'". Might be easier if you actually put here the ip/iptables rules you are actually using?

In the alternative routing table you can say to use a different source IP and/or alternative default gateway address (using something like 'ip route ... src ... via ... dev'). As I mentioned before, as 'ip rule' only knows about IP addresses (and not tcp/udp/etc port numbers and what not) you will need to use iptables MARK action and the fwmark in 'ip rule' to get the L4 policy based routing you want.

By using a second routing table (as described in the LARTC link), you can stop using the 'iptables -j SNAT' I think you are using. Then, hopefully all your netstat output for locally sourced traffic will be correct.

Cheers

Signature · 2 lines
Alexander Clouter
.sigmonster says: You will be married within a year, and divorced within two.