Skip to contentSkip to conversation

GPL Violation of 'sveasoft' with GPL Linux Kernel/Busybox + code

gnu.org #214016 [email protected] via RT 2 participants 6 messages Nov 9, 2004 – Nov 11, 2004 1 message not in the archive

lore
Share & tools
lore
#1 lore raw
In reply to a message not in the archive
Quoted 3 lines · Shawn Starr via RT

I dont know if this has been brought up but, a company called sveasoft is blatently violating the GPL by not releasing any code

Under the GPL, nobody has to give any particular person copies of the binaries. They are free to sell binaries for whatever price they like.

But if you distribute binaries, you must either include or offer source code. Do they do this? What software do they include that FSF holds
copyright on? Where can I check this?

Do they include a copy of the GPL with the software?

Signature · 3 lines
-Dave Turner
GPL Compliance Engineer
Support my work: http://svcs.affero.net/rm.php?r=novalis&p=FSF
#2 lore raw
In reply to a message not in the archive
Quoted 5 lines · On Maw, 2004-11-09 at 00:11, [email protected] via RT wrote:

But if you distribute binaries, you must either include or offer source code. Do they do this? What software do they include that FSF holds
copyright on? Where can I check this?

Do they include a copy of the GPL with the software?

They include the GPL, they include the source nothing I can find they do violates the GPL. They do appear to annoy a few people because their policy is that while you may join their early access process and get source if you redistribute that source then you get kicked off their program, but you are still allowed to distribute that source.

#3 lore raw

They won't be distributing the source because of their new anti-distribution methods, they aren't providing the source because they don't want people to distribute the binaries any more either or know now the anti-distribution mechanism will work (which requires the user to enter a value to unlock the binary firmware and send a request to their servers).

It is this action that they are violating the GPL and that needs to be enforced.

If they want to relicense their changes they need to not use GPL existing code which they are not doing. They have not added written any of this code from scratch and thus must distribute the source on request to those who get the binaries which they are not doing anymore.

What was true before of redistribution and being kicked out of the program is now not happening anymore as there is no code to distribute of the resulting binaries.

Shawn.

Quoted 12 lines · Alan Cox via RT
Quoted 5 lines · On Maw, 2004-11-09 at 00:11, [email protected] via RT wrote:

But if you distribute binaries, you must either include or offer source code. Do they do this? What software do they include that FSF holds
copyright on? Where can I check this?

Do they include a copy of the GPL with the software?

They include the GPL, they include the source nothing I can find they do violates the GPL. They do appear to annoy a few people because their policy is that while you may join their early access process and get source if you redistribute that source then you get kicked off their program, but you are still allowed to distribute that source.

#4 lore raw
In reply to a message not in the archive

They won't be distributing the source because of their new anti-distribution methods, they aren't providing the source because they don't want people to distribute the binaries any more either or know now the anti-distribution mechanism will work (which requires the user to enter a value to unlock the binary firmware and send a request to their servers).

It is this action that they are violating the GPL and that needs to be enforced.

If they want to relicense their changes they need to not use GPL existing code which they are not doing. They have not added written any of this code from scratch and thus must distribute the source on request to those who get the binaries which they are not doing anymore.

What was true before of redistribution and being kicked out of the program is now not happening anymore as there is no code to distribute of the resulting binaries.

Shawn.

Quoted 12 lines · Alan Cox via RT
Quoted 5 lines · On Maw, 2004-11-09 at 00:11, [email protected] via RT wrote:

But if you distribute binaries, you must either include or offer source code. Do they do this? What software do they include that FSF holds
copyright on? Where can I check this?

Do they include a copy of the GPL with the software?

They include the GPL, they include the source nothing I can find they do violates the GPL. They do appear to annoy a few people because their policy is that while you may join their early access process and get source if you redistribute that source then you get kicked off their program, but you are still allowed to distribute that source.

#5 lore raw
In reply to a message not in the archive

They won't be distributing the source because of their new anti-distribution methods, they aren't providing the source because they don't want people to distribute the binaries any more either or know now the anti-distribution mechanism will work (which requires the user to enter a value to unlock the binary firmware and send a request to their servers).

It is this action that they are violating the GPL and that needs to be enforced.

If they want to relicense their changes they need to not use GPL existing code which they are not doing. They have not added written any of this code from scratch and thus must distribute the source on request to those who get the binaries which they are not doing anymore.

What was true before of redistribution and being kicked out of the program is now not happening anymore as there is no code to distribute of the resulting binaries.

Shawn.

Quoted 12 lines · Alan Cox via RT
Quoted 5 lines · On Maw, 2004-11-09 at 00:11, [email protected] via RT wrote:

But if you distribute binaries, you must either include or offer source code. Do they do this? What software do they include that FSF holds
copyright on? Where can I check this?

Do they include a copy of the GPL with the software?

They include the GPL, they include the source nothing I can find they do violates the GPL. They do appear to annoy a few people because their policy is that while you may join their early access process and get source if you redistribute that source then you get kicked off their program, but you are still allowed to distribute that source.

#6 lore raw
In reply to a message not in the archive

I didn't realize linux-kernel was CC'd here. I'm going to take this off-list with Shawn, because I don't want to waste everyone's time. If anyone else has any information about this, please feel free to email me at <[email protected]> . Thanks.

Quoted 38 lines · Shawn Starr via RT

REPLIES GO TO REQUESTORS BY DEFAULT.

<URL: http://rt.gnu.org/Ticket/Display.html?id=214016 >

They won't be distributing the source because of their new anti-distribution methods, they aren't providing the source because they don't want people to distribute the binaries any more either or know now the anti-distribution mechanism will work (which requires the user to enter a value to unlock the binary firmware and send a request to their servers).

It is this action that they are violating the GPL and that needs to be enforced.

If they want to relicense their changes they need to not use GPL existing code which they are not doing. They have not added written any of this code from scratch and thus must distribute the source on request to those who get the binaries which they are not doing anymore.

What was true before of redistribution and being kicked out of the program is now not happening anymore as there is no code to distribute of the resulting binaries.

Shawn.

Quoted 12 lines · Alan Cox via RT
Quoted 5 lines · On Maw, 2004-11-09 at 00:11, [email protected] via RT wrote:

But if you distribute binaries, you must either include or offer source code. Do they do this? What software do they include that FSF holds
copyright on? Where can I check this?

Do they include a copy of the GPL with the software?

They include the GPL, they include the source nothing I can find they do violates the GPL. They do appear to annoy a few people because their policy is that while you may join their early access process and get source if you redistribute that source then you get kicked off their program, but you are still allowed to distribute that source.

Signature · 3 lines
-Dave Turner
GPL Compliance Engineer
Support my work: http://svcs.affero.net/rm.php?r=novalis&p=FSF