Skip to contentSkip to conversation

ibook1 hangs during boot, atyfb broken

DISCUSSION Olaf Hering 3 participants 6 messages Feb 23, 2006 – Feb 24, 2006

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

My iBook1 did not work with recent kernels (2.6.15+), 2.6.13 was always ok. Today I did some more testing, with 2.6.16-rc4-git3.
If I boot with 'quiet panic=1 root=/dev/blah', it will hang in 75% of the boots before displaying the penguin.
Adding video=atyfb:off did fix it, tried it a few times. Then I removed the quiet and video= option, and it did boot again. Then I reverted the atyfb to 2.6.15 status and did a reboot loop.
Unfortunately, after 13 reboots with just 'panic=1 root=/x' it was stuck, after
time_init: processor frequency = 300MHz.

"panic=1 root=/dev/blah video=atyfb:off" works better, 27 reboots and still going.

#1 lore raw
Quoted 9 lines · Olaf Hering

My iBook1 did not work with recent kernels (2.6.15+), 2.6.13 was always ok. Today I did some more testing, with 2.6.16-rc4-git3.
If I boot with 'quiet panic=1 root=/dev/blah', it will hang in 75% of the boots before displaying the penguin.
Adding video=atyfb:off did fix it, tried it a few times. Then I removed the quiet and video= option, and it did boot again. Then I reverted the atyfb to 2.6.15 status and did a reboot loop.
Unfortunately, after 13 reboots with just 'panic=1 root=/x' it was stuck, after
time_init: processor frequency = 300MHz.

It boots with video=atyfb:noaccel ?

I suggest you report that to the linux-fbdev mailing list. That problem seems to happen with some wallstreet powerbooks too, there is definitely something broken there...

Ben.

#2 lore raw

Benjamin Herrenschmidt kirjoitti:

Quoted 11 lines · Olaf Hering
Quoted 8 lines

My iBook1 did not work with recent kernels (2.6.15+), 2.6.13 was always ok.
Today I did some more testing, with 2.6.16-rc4-git3.
If I boot with 'quiet panic=1 root=/dev/blah', it will hang in 75% of the boots before displaying the penguin. Adding video=atyfb:off did fix it, tried it a few times. Then I removed
the quiet and video= option, and it did boot again. Then I reverted the
atyfb to 2.6.15 status and did a reboot loop.
Unfortunately, after 13 reboots with just 'panic=1 root=/x' it was stuck, after time_init: processor frequency = 300MHz.

Quoted 5 lines

It boots with video=atyfb:noaccel ?

I suggest you report that to the linux-fbdev mailing list. That problem seems to happen with some wallstreet powerbooks too, there is definitely something broken there...

Using an older DVI TiBook, atyfb has been broken at least since 2.6.8 or so, and still is with 2.6.15, in that it can't seem to synchronize with the LCD and maybe 50% of the (re-)boots produce just more-or-less shimmering/flashing garbage on screen. Doesn't completely hang though...

-- Heikki Lindholm

#3 lore raw
Quoted 1 line · Heikki Lindholm

Using an older DVI TiBook, atyfb has been broken at least since 2.6.8 or

atyfb vs. aty128fb.

#4 lore raw
In reply to Heikki Lindholm
Quoted 5 lines

Using an older DVI TiBook, atyfb has been broken at least since 2.6.8 or so, and still is with 2.6.15, in that it can't seem to synchronize with the LCD and maybe 50% of the (re-)boots produce just more-or-less shimmering/flashing garbage on screen. Doesn't completely hang though...

Except that no tibook ever used atyfb...

Ben.

#5 lore raw

Benjamin Herrenschmidt kirjoitti:

Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 1 line

Using an older DVI TiBook, atyfb has been broken at least since 2.6.8 or so, and still is with 2.6.15, in that it can't seem to synchronize with the LCD and maybe 50% of the (re-)boots produce just more-or-less shimmering/flashing garbage on screen. Doesn't completely hang though...

Except that no tibook ever used atyfb...

Damn straight! I stand corrected (confused with one PC laptop), it's the radeon thing then..

-- Heikki Lindholm