Skip to contentSkip to conversation

indistinguishable column names ( BA Start Start Start Start )

linux-lvm Roland 3 participants 6 messages Aug 19, 2023 – Aug 23, 2023

lore
Share & tools
lore

Roland

author
#0 lore raw

hello,

does somebody know how we can have native (i.e. non translated) column field names in first line of output of pvs ?

in its current implementation, output is hard to read , difficult to distinguish and also not scriptable/parseable, as whitespace is used for field separator and there are fields which also contain whitespace themselves,and there also seems no way to add separators in between (like with printf) for separation/formatting

# pvs --units s -o+pv_ba_start,seg_start,seg_start_pe,pvseg_start
  PV         VG        Fmt  Attr PSize        PFree BA Start Start    Start Start
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S       0S 2097152S     1     0
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S       0S 2097152S     1     1
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S       0S     0  5309
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S       0S     0  5587
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S       0S     0  5588

i mean like this:

# pvs --units s -o+pv_ba_start,seg_start,seg_start_pe,pvseg_start
  PV         VG        Fmt  Attr PSize        PFree pv_ba_start seg_start seg_start_pe pvseg_start
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S          0S 2097152S            1           0
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S          0S 2097152S            1           1
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S        0S            0        5309
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S        0S            0        5587
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S        0S            0        5588

furthermore, it's a little bit weird that some columns being printed by default when using -o, is there an easier way to remove those besides explictly removing them one by one with several -o options ? "-o-opt1,-opt2,..." doesn't work

# pvs --units s -o+pv_ba_start,seg_start,pvseg_start,seg_start_pe -o-vg_name -o-pv_name -o-pv_fmt -o-attr -o -pv_size -o -pv_free
  BA Start Start    Start Start
        0S 2097152S     0     1
        0S 2097152S     1     1
        0S       0S  5309     0
        0S       0S  5587     0
        0S       0S  5588     0

roland

_______________________________________________
linux-lvm mailing list
[email protected]
https://listman.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/linux-lvm
read the LVM HOW-TO at http://tldp.org/HOWTO/LVM-HOWTO/

author
#1 lore raw
Quoted 2 lines

furthermore, it's a little bit weird that some columns being printed by default when using -o, is
there an easier way to remove those besides explictly removing them one by one with several -o options ? "-o-opt1,-opt2,..." doesn't work

sorry for this noise, i was too dumb for that , "-o+opt1,opt2 -o-opt3,opt4" works as desired (as documented in manpage)

Quoted 1 line

themselves,and there also seems no way to add separators in between (like with printf) for separation/formatting

also sorry for this, as we can use --separator=","   (apparently did have too much coffee and had overseen that in the manpage)

the question regarding native column headers/description remains

roland

Am 19.08.23 um 17:20 schrieb Roland:

Quoted 35 lines

hello,

does somebody know how we can have native (i.e. non translated) column field names in first line of output of pvs ?

in its current implementation, output is hard to read , difficult to distinguish and also not scriptable/parseable, as whitespace is used for field separator and there are fields which also contain whitespace themselves,and there also seems no way to add separators in between (like with printf) for separation/formatting

# pvs --units s -o+pv_ba_start,seg_start,seg_start_pe,pvseg_start
  PV         VG        Fmt  Attr PSize        PFree BA Start Start    Start Start
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S       0S 2097152S     1     0
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S       0S 2097152S     1     1
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S 0S     0  5309
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S 0S     0  5587
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S 0S     0  5588

i mean like this:

# pvs --units s -o+pv_ba_start,seg_start,seg_start_pe,pvseg_start
  PV         VG        Fmt  Attr PSize        PFree pv_ba_start seg_start seg_start_pe pvseg_start
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S          0S 2097152S            1           0
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S          0S 2097152S            1           1
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S 0S            0        5309
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S 0S            0        5587
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S 0S            0        5588

furthermore, it's a little bit weird that some columns being printed by default when using -o, is there an easier way to remove those besides explictly removing them one by one with several -o options ? "-o-opt1,-opt2,..." doesn't work

# pvs --units s -o+pv_ba_start,seg_start,pvseg_start,seg_start_pe 
-o-vg_name -o-pv_name -o-pv_fmt -o-attr -o -pv_size -o -pv_free
  BA Start Start    Start Start
        0S 2097152S     0     1
        0S 2097152S     1     1
        0S       0S  5309     0
        0S       0S  5587     0
        0S       0S  5588     0
Quoted 2 lines

roland

_______________________________________________
linux-lvm mailing list
[email protected]
https://listman.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/linux-lvm
read the LVM HOW-TO at http://tldp.org/HOWTO/LVM-HOWTO/

#2 lore raw
Quoted 7 lines · Roland

furthermore, it's a little bit weird that some columns being printed by default when using -o, is there an easier way to remove those besides explictly removing them one by one with several -o options ? "-o-opt1,-opt2,..." doesn't work

sorry for this noise, i was too dumb for that , "-o+opt1,opt2 -o-opt3,opt4" works as desired (as documented in manpage)

Usually if you're interested in exact fields, you'd avoid the default options and just use "-o opt1,opt2,..." without +/-.

Quoted 3 lines
# pvs --units s -o+pv_ba_start,seg_start,seg_start_pe,pvseg_start
  PV         VG        Fmt  Attr PSize        PFree pv_ba_start
 seg_start seg_start_pe pvseg_start

It does sound better than some of the strange header abbreviations. It could also use the key words that appear with --nameprefixes.

Dave
_______________________________________________
linux-lvm mailing list
[email protected]
https://listman.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/linux-lvm
read the LVM HOW-TO at http://tldp.org/HOWTO/LVM-HOWTO/

author
#3 lore raw

Am 21.08.23 um 18:17 schrieb David Teigland:

Quoted 10 lines · Roland
Quoted 7 lines

furthermore, it's a little bit weird that some columns being printed by default when using -o, is there an easier way to remove those besides explictly removing them one by one with several -o options ? "-o-opt1,-opt2,..." doesn't work

sorry for this noise, i was too dumb for that , "-o+opt1,opt2 -o-opt3,opt4" works as desired (as documented in manpage)

Usually if you're interested in exact fields, you'd avoid the default options and just use "-o opt1,opt2,..." without +/-.

yes, that makes totally sense  - there are default options, "+" adds some options,
"- removes some , and -o without "+/-" just makes it print exactly what we want.

totally straightforward if understood, i was just too lazy, sorry.

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 3 lines
# pvs --units s -o+pv_ba_start,seg_start,seg_start_pe,pvseg_start
   PV         VG        Fmt  Attr PSize        PFree pv_ba_start
  seg_start seg_start_pe pvseg_start

It does sound better than some of the strange header abbreviations. It could also use the key words that appear with --nameprefixes.

i have found the place where to add an RFE and did that :

https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=2233336

thank you

roland

_______________________________________________
linux-lvm mailing list
[email protected]
https://listman.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/linux-lvm
read the LVM HOW-TO at http://tldp.org/HOWTO/LVM-HOWTO/

#4 lore raw
In reply to Roland

Hi Roland, is lvs --reportformat json or lvs --nameprefixes good enough?

Quoted 71 lines · Roland
Quoted 1 line

furthermore, it's a little bit weird that some columns being printed

by default when using -o, is

Quoted 1 line

there an easier way to remove those besides explictly removing them

one by one with several -o options ? "-o-opt1,-opt2,..." doesn't work

sorry for this noise, i was too dumb for that , "-o+opt1,opt2 -o-opt3,opt4" works as desired (as documented in manpage)

Quoted 1 line

themselves,and there also seems no way to add separators in between

(like with printf) for separation/formatting

also sorry for this, as we can use --separator="," (apparently did
have too much coffee and had overseen that in the manpage)

the question regarding native column headers/description remains

roland

Am 19.08.23 um 17:20 schrieb Roland:

Quoted 52 lines

hello,

does somebody know how we can have native (i.e. non translated) column field names in first line of output of pvs ?

in its current implementation, output is hard to read , difficult to distinguish and also not scriptable/parseable, as whitespace is used for field separator and there are fields which also contain whitespace themselves,and there also seems no way to add separators in between (like with printf) for separation/formatting

# pvs --units s -o+pv_ba_start,seg_start,seg_start_pe,pvseg_start
  PV         VG        Fmt  Attr PSize        PFree BA Start Start
Start Start
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S       0S
2097152S     1     0
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S       0S
2097152S     1     1
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S 0S     0  5309
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S 0S     0  5587
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S 0S     0  5588

i mean like this:

# pvs --units s -o+pv_ba_start,seg_start,seg_start_pe,pvseg_start
  PV         VG        Fmt  Attr PSize        PFree pv_ba_start
seg_start seg_start_pe pvseg_start
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S          0S
2097152S            1           0
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S          0S
2097152S            1           1
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S 0S            0
       5309
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S 0S
0        5587
  /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S 0S
0        5588

furthermore, it's a little bit weird that some columns being printed by default when using -o, is there an easier way to remove those besides explictly removing them one by one with several -o options ? "-o-opt1,-opt2,..." doesn't work

# pvs --units s -o+pv_ba_start,seg_start,pvseg_start,seg_start_pe
-o-vg_name -o-pv_name -o-pv_fmt -o-attr -o -pv_size -o -pv_free
  BA Start Start    Start Start
        0S 2097152S     0     1
        0S 2097152S     1     1
        0S       0S  5309     0
        0S       0S  5587     0
        0S       0S  5588     0
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 2 lines

roland

_______________________________________________
linux-lvm mailing list
[email protected]
https://listman.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/linux-lvm
read the LVM HOW-TO at http://tldp.org/HOWTO/LVM-HOWTO/

_______________________________________________
linux-lvm mailing list
[email protected]
https://listman.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/linux-lvm
read the LVM HOW-TO at http://tldp.org/HOWTO/LVM-HOWTO/

author
#5 lore raw

Hi,

Quoted 1 line

Hi Roland, is lvs --reportformat json or lvs --nameprefixes good

enough?

good when using scripting / automated processing - but not good, when we need it human readable.

i'd even would call it a bug, when using same strings for "translated" names.

would anybody accept something like this (just for saving column space) ?  ok, that's a little bit over the top - but i wand to underline what i mean

getpersondetails -o forename, surname, streetname, cityname

name        name    name            name
john          doe      highstreet     washington

roland

Am 21.08.23 um 18:00 schrieb Marian Csontos:

Quoted 98 lines

Hi Roland, is lvs --reportformat json or lvs --nameprefixes good enough?

On Sat, Aug 19, 2023 at 6:06 PM Roland <[email protected]> wrote:

 > furthermore, it's a little bit weird that some columns being printed
by default when using -o, is
 > there an easier way to remove those besides explictly removing them
one by one with several -o options ? "-o-opt1,-opt2,..." doesn't work

sorry for this noise, i was too dumb for that , "-o+opt1,opt2 -o-opt3,opt4" works as desired (as documented in manpage)

 > themselves,and there also seems no way to add separators in between
(like with printf) for separation/formatting

also sorry for this, as we can use --separator="," (apparently did have too much coffee and had overseen that in the manpage)

the question regarding native column headers/description remains

roland

Am 19.08.23 um 17:20 schrieb Roland:
> hello,
>
> does somebody know how we can have native (i.e. non translated) column
> field names in first line of output of pvs ?
>
> in its current implementation, output is hard to read , difficult to
> distinguish and also not scriptable/parseable, as whitespace is used
> for field separator and there are fields which also contain whitespace
> themselves,and there also seems no way to add separators in between > (like with printf) for separation/formatting
>
> # pvs --units s -o+pv_ba_start,seg_start,seg_start_pe,pvseg_start >   PV         VG        Fmt  Attr PSize        PFree BA Start Start > Start Start
>   /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S > 2097152S     1     0
>   /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S > 2097152S     1     1
>   /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S 0S     0 5309
>   /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S 0S     0 5587
>   /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S 0S     0 5588
>
> i mean like this:
>
> # pvs --units s -o+pv_ba_start,seg_start,seg_start_pe,pvseg_start >   PV         VG        Fmt  Attr PSize        PFree pv_ba_start > seg_start seg_start_pe pvseg_start
>   /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S    0S > 2097152S            1           0
>   /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S 0S          0S > 2097152S            1           1
>   /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S 0S 0
>        5309
>   /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S 0S > 0        5587
>   /dev/sdb   VGrecycle lvm2 a--  11720982528S    0S 0S 0S > 0        5588
>
> furthermore, it's a little bit weird that some columns being printed
> by default when using -o, is there an easier way to remove those > besides explictly removing them one by one with several -o options ?
> "-o-opt1,-opt2,..." doesn't work
>
> # pvs --units s -o+pv_ba_start,seg_start,pvseg_start,seg_start_pe > -o-vg_name -o-pv_name -o-pv_fmt -o-attr -o -pv_size -o -pv_free >   BA Start Start    Start Start
>         0S 2097152S     0     1
>         0S 2097152S     1     1
>         0S       0S  5309     0
>         0S       0S  5587     0
>         0S       0S  5588     0
>
> roland
>
_______________________________________________
linux-lvm mailing list
[email protected]
https://listman.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/linux-lvm
read the LVM HOW-TO at http://tldp.org/HOWTO/LVM-HOWTO/

Quoted 5 lines

_______________________________________________
linux-lvm mailing list
[email protected]
https://listman.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/linux-lvm
read the LVM HOW-TO athttp://tldp.org/HOWTO/LVM-HOWTO/

_______________________________________________
linux-lvm mailing list
[email protected]
https://listman.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/linux-lvm
read the LVM HOW-TO at http://tldp.org/HOWTO/LVM-HOWTO/