net: dsa: realtek: fix LED support for rtl8366rb
Subsystems (5)
Luiz Angelo Daros de Luca
maintainercover net: dsa: realtek: fix LED support for rtl8366rb
The rtl8366rb switch family has 4 LED groups, with one LED from each group for each of its 6 ports. LEDs in this family can be controlled manually using a bitmap or triggered by hardware. It's important to note that hardware triggers are configured at the LED group level, meaning all LEDs in the same group share the same hardware triggers settings.
The first part of this series involves dropping most of the existing code, as, except for disabling the LEDs, it was not working as expected. If not disabled, the LEDs will retain their default settings after a switch reset, which may be sufficient for many devices.
The second part introduces the LED driver to control the switch LEDs from sysfs or device-tree. This driver still allows the LEDs to retain their default settings, but it will shift to the software-based OS LED triggers if any configuration is changed. Subsequently, the LEDs will operate as normal LEDs until the switch undergoes another reset.
Netdev LED trigger supports offloading to hardware triggers. Unfortunately, this isn't possible with the current LED API for this switch family. When the hardware trigger is enabled, it applies to all LEDs in the LED group while the LED API decides to offload based on only the state of a single LED. To avoid inconsistency between LEDs, offloading would need to check if all LEDs in the group share the same compatible settings and atomically enable offload for all LEDs.
This patch series has a minor conflict with the other realtek refacatoring series at the priv->ds access.
- dsa_switch_for_each_port(dp, priv->ds) {
+ dsa_switch_for_each_port(dp, &priv->ds) {
Luiz Angelo Daros de Luca
maintainerRFC 1/2 net: dsa: realtek: keep default LED state in rtl8366rb
This switch family supports four LEDs for each of its six ports. Each LED group is composed of one of these four LEDs from all six ports. LED groups can be configured to display hardware information, such as link activity, or manually controlled through a bitmap in registers RTL8366RB_LED_0_1_CTRL_REG and RTL8366RB_LED_2_3_CTRL_REG.
After a reset, the default LED group configuration for groups 0 to 3 indicates link activity at 1000M, 100M, and 10M, or RTL8366RB_LED_CTRL_REG as 0x5432. These configurations are commonly used for LED indications. However, the driver was replacing that configuration to use manually controlled LEDs (RTL8366RB_LED_FORCE) without providing a way for the OS to control them. The default configuration is deemed more useful than fixed, uncontrollable turned-on LEDs.
The driver was enabling/disabling LEDs during port_enable/disable. However, these events occur when the port is administratively controlled (up or down) and are not related to link presence. Additionally, when a port N was disabled, the driver was turning off all LEDs for group N, not only the corresponding LED for port N in any of those 4 groups. In such cases, if port 0 is WAN and brought down, the LEDs for all ports in LED group 0 would be turned off. As another side effect, the driver was wrongly warning that port 5 didn't have an LED ("no LED for port 5"). Since showing the administrative state of ports is not an orthodox way to use LEDs, it was not worth it to fix it and all this code was dropped.
The code to disable LEDs was simplified only changing each LED group to the RTL8366RB_LED_OFF state. Registers RTL8366RB_LED_0_1_CTRL_REG and RTL8366RB_LED_2_3_CTRL_REG are only used when the corresponding LED group is configured with RTL8366RB_LED_FORCE and they don't need to be cleaned. The code still references an LED controlled by RTL8366RB_INTERRUPT_CONTROL_REG, but as of now, no test device has actually used it. Also, some magic numbers were replaced by macros.
--- drivers/net/dsa/realtek/rtl8366rb.c | 87 +++++++---------------------- 1 file changed, 20 insertions(+), 67 deletions(-)
drivers/net/dsa/realtek/rtl8366rb.c +20 -67
@@ -182,7 +182,12 @@#define RTL8366RB_LED_BLINKRATE_222MS 0x0004#define RTL8366RB_LED_BLINKRATE_446MS 0x0005 +/* LED trigger event for each group */ #define RTL8366RB_LED_CTRL_REG 0x0431 +#define RTL8366RB_LED_CTRL_OFFSET (led_group) \ + (4 * (led_group)) +#define RTL8366RB_LED_CTRL_MASK (led_group) \ + (0xf << RTL8366RB_LED_CTRL_OFFSET(led_group))#define RTL8366RB_LED_OFF 0x0#define RTL8366RB_LED_DUP_COL 0x1#define RTL8366RB_LED_LINK_ACT 0x2
@@ -199,6 +204,11 @@#define RTL8366RB_LED_LINK_TX 0xd#define RTL8366RB_LED_MASTER 0xe#define RTL8366RB_LED_FORCE 0xf + +/* The RTL8366RB_LED_X_X registers are used to manually set the LED state only +* when the corresponding LED group in RTL8366RB_LED_CTRL_REG is +* RTL8366RB_LED_FORCE. Otherwise, it is ignored. +*/ #define RTL8366RB_LED_0_1_CTRL_REG 0x0432#define RTL8366RB_LED_1_OFFSET 6#define RTL8366RB_LED_2_3_CTRL_REG 0x0433
@@ -998,28 +1008,20 @@ static int rtl8366rb_setup(struct dsa_switch *ds)*/ if (priv->leds_disabled) {/* Turn everything off */ -regmap_update_bits (priv->map, -RTL8366RB_LED_0_1_CTRL_REG , -0x0FFF ,0 ); -regmap_update_bits (priv->map, -RTL8366RB_LED_2_3_CTRL_REG , -0x0FFF ,0 );regmap_update_bits (priv->map,RTL8366RB_INTERRUPT_CONTROL_REG ,RTL8366RB_P4_RGMII_LED ,0 ); - val =RTL8366RB_LED_OFF ; - }else { -/* TODO: make this configurable per LED */ - val =RTL8366RB_LED_FORCE ; - } -for (i =0 ; i <4 ; i++) { - ret =regmap_update_bits (priv->map, -RTL8366RB_LED_CTRL_REG , -0xf << (i *4 ), - val << (i *4 )); -if (ret) -return ret; + +for (i =0 ; i <RTL8366RB_NUM_LEDGROUPS ; i++) { + val =RTL8366RB_LED_OFF <<RTL8366RB_LED_CTRL_OFFSET (i); + ret =regmap_update_bits (priv->map, +RTL8366RB_LED_CTRL_REG , +RTL8366RB_LED_CTRL_MASK (i), + val); +if (ret) +return ret; + } } ret =rtl8366_reset_vlan (priv);
@@ -1166,52 +1168,6 @@ rtl8366rb_mac_link_down(struct dsa_switch *ds, int port, unsigned int mode, } } -static void rb8366rb_set_port_led (struct realtek_priv *priv, -int port,bool enable) -{ -u16 val = enable ?0x3f :0 ; -int ret; - -if (priv->leds_disabled) -return ; - -switch (port) { -case 0 : - ret =regmap_update_bits (priv->map, -RTL8366RB_LED_0_1_CTRL_REG , -0x3F , val); -break ; -case 1 : - ret =regmap_update_bits (priv->map, -RTL8366RB_LED_0_1_CTRL_REG , -0x3F <<RTL8366RB_LED_1_OFFSET , - val <<RTL8366RB_LED_1_OFFSET ); -break ; -case 2 : - ret =regmap_update_bits (priv->map, -RTL8366RB_LED_2_3_CTRL_REG , -0x3F , val); -break ; -case 3 : - ret =regmap_update_bits (priv->map, -RTL8366RB_LED_2_3_CTRL_REG , -0x3F <<RTL8366RB_LED_3_OFFSET , - val <<RTL8366RB_LED_3_OFFSET ); -break ; -case 4 : - ret =regmap_update_bits (priv->map, -RTL8366RB_INTERRUPT_CONTROL_REG , -RTL8366RB_P4_RGMII_LED , - enable ?RTL8366RB_P4_RGMII_LED :0 ); -break ; -default : -dev_err (priv->dev,"no LED for port %d\n" , port); -return ; - } -if (ret) -dev_err (priv->dev,"error updating LED on port %d\n" , port); -} -static int rtl8366rb_port_enable (struct dsa_switch *ds,int port,struct phy_device *phy)
@@ -1225,7 +1181,6 @@ rtl8366rb_port_enable(struct dsa_switch *ds, int port,if (ret)return ret; -rb8366rb_set_port_led (priv, port, true);return 0 ; }
@@ -1240,8 +1195,6 @@ rtl8366rb_port_disable(struct dsa_switch *ds, int port) BIT(port));if (ret)return ; - -rb8366rb_set_port_led (priv, port, false); } static int
Signature · 1 line
2.43.0
Luiz Angelo Daros de Luca
maintainerRFC 2/2 net: dsa: realtek: add LED drivers for rtl8366rb
In reply to Luiz Angelo Daros de LucaThis commit introduces LED drivers for rtl8366rb, allowing LEDs to be described in the device tree using the same format as qca8k. Each port can configure up to 4 LEDs.
If LEDs use the default state "keep", they will keep the default behavior after a reset. Changing the brightness of one LED will cause the entire LED group to switch to manually controlled LEDs. Once in this mode, there is no way to revert to hardware-controlled LEDs (except by resetting the switch).
Software triggers function as expected with manually controlled LEDs.
--- drivers/net/dsa/realtek/rtl8366rb.c | 269 +++++++++++++++++++++++++--- 1 file changed, 245 insertions(+), 24 deletions(-)
drivers/net/dsa/realtek/rtl8366rb.c +245 -24
@@ -188,31 +188,21 @@ (4 * (led_group))#define RTL8366RB_LED_CTRL_MASK (led_group) \ (0xf << RTL8366RB_LED_CTRL_OFFSET(led_group)) -#define RTL8366RB_LED_OFF 0x0 -#define RTL8366RB_LED_DUP_COL 0x1 -#define RTL8366RB_LED_LINK_ACT 0x2 -#define RTL8366RB_LED_SPD1000 0x3 -#define RTL8366RB_LED_SPD100 0x4 -#define RTL8366RB_LED_SPD10 0x5 -#define RTL8366RB_LED_SPD1000_ACT 0x6 -#define RTL8366RB_LED_SPD100_ACT 0x7 -#define RTL8366RB_LED_SPD10_ACT 0x8 -#define RTL8366RB_LED_SPD100_10_ACT 0x9 -#define RTL8366RB_LED_FIBER 0xa -#define RTL8366RB_LED_AN_FAULT 0xb -#define RTL8366RB_LED_LINK_RX 0xc -#define RTL8366RB_LED_LINK_TX 0xd -#define RTL8366RB_LED_MASTER 0xe -#define RTL8366RB_LED_FORCE 0xf/* The RTL8366RB_LED_X_X registers are used to manually set the LED state only * when the corresponding LED group in RTL8366RB_LED_CTRL_REG is * RTL8366RB_LED_FORCE. Otherwise, it is ignored. */ #define RTL8366RB_LED_0_1_CTRL_REG 0x0432 -#define RTL8366RB_LED_1_OFFSET 6#define RTL8366RB_LED_2_3_CTRL_REG 0x0433 -#define RTL8366RB_LED_3_OFFSET 6 +#define RTL8366RB_LED_X_X_CTRL_REG (led_group) \ + ((led_group) <= 1 ? \ + RTL8366RB_LED_0_1_CTRL_REG : \ + RTL8366RB_LED_2_3_CTRL_REG) +#define RTL8366RB_LED_0_X_CTRL_MASK GENMASK(5, 0) +#define RTL8366RB_LED_X_1_CTRL_MASK GENMASK(11, 6) +#define RTL8366RB_LED_2_X_CTRL_MASK GENMASK(5, 0) +#define RTL8366RB_LED_X_3_CTRL_MASK GENMASK(11, 6)#define RTL8366RB_MIB_COUNT 33#define RTL8366RB_GLOBAL_MIB_COUNT 1
@@ -356,14 +346,44 @@#define RTL8366RB_GREEN_FEATURE_TX BIT(0)#define RTL8366RB_GREEN_FEATURE_RX BIT(2) +enum rtl8366_led_mode { +RTL8366RB_LED_OFF =0x0 , +RTL8366RB_LED_DUP_COL =0x1 , +RTL8366RB_LED_LINK_ACT =0x2 , +RTL8366RB_LED_SPD1000 =0x3 , +RTL8366RB_LED_SPD100 =0x4 , +RTL8366RB_LED_SPD10 =0x5 , +RTL8366RB_LED_SPD1000_ACT =0x6 , +RTL8366RB_LED_SPD100_ACT =0x7 , +RTL8366RB_LED_SPD10_ACT =0x8 , +RTL8366RB_LED_SPD100_10_ACT =0x9 , +RTL8366RB_LED_FIBER =0xa , +RTL8366RB_LED_AN_FAULT =0xb , +RTL8366RB_LED_LINK_RX =0xc , +RTL8366RB_LED_LINK_TX =0xd , +RTL8366RB_LED_MASTER =0xe , +RTL8366RB_LED_FORCE =0xf , + + __RTL8366RB_LED_MAX +}; + +struct rtl8366rb_led { +u8 port_num; +u8 led_group; +struct realtek_priv *priv; +struct led_classdev cdev; +}; +/** * struct rtl8366rb - RTL8366RB-specific data * @max_mtu: per-port max MTU setting * @pvid_enabled: if PVID is set for respective port +* @leds: per-port and per-ledgroup led info */ struct rtl8366rb {unsigned int max_mtu[RTL8366RB_NUM_PORTS ];bool pvid_enabled[RTL8366RB_NUM_PORTS ]; +struct rtl8366rb_led leds[RTL8366RB_NUM_PORTS ][RTL8366RB_NUM_LEDGROUPS ]; };static struct rtl8366_mib_counter rtl8366rb_mib_counters[] = {
@@ -806,6 +826,207 @@ static int rtl8366rb_jam_table(const struct rtl8366rb_jam_tbl_entry *jam_table,return 0 ; } +static int rb8366rb_set_ledgroup_mode (struct realtek_priv *priv, +u8 led_group, +enum rtl8366_led_mode mode) +{ +int ret; +u32 val; + + val = mode <<RTL8366RB_LED_CTRL_OFFSET (led_group); + + ret =regmap_update_bits (priv->map, +RTL8366RB_LED_CTRL_REG , +RTL8366RB_LED_CTRL_MASK (led_group), + val); +if (ret) +return ret; + +return 0 ; +} + +static inline u32 rtl8366rb_led_group_port_mask (u8 led_group,u8 port) +{ +switch (led_group) { +case 0 : +return FIELD_PREP (RTL8366RB_LED_0_X_CTRL_MASK ,BIT (port)); +case 1 : +return FIELD_PREP (RTL8366RB_LED_0_X_CTRL_MASK ,BIT (port)); +case 2 : +return FIELD_PREP (RTL8366RB_LED_0_X_CTRL_MASK ,BIT (port)); +case 3 : +return FIELD_PREP (RTL8366RB_LED_0_X_CTRL_MASK ,BIT (port)); +default : +return 0 ; + } +} + +static int rb8366rb_get_port_led (struct rtl8366rb_led *led,bool enable) +{ +struct realtek_priv *priv = led->priv; +u8 led_group = led->led_group; +u8 port_num = led->port_num; +int ret; +u32 val; + +if (led_group >=RTL8366RB_NUM_LEDGROUPS ) { +dev_err (priv->dev,"Invalid LED group %d for port %d" , + led_group, port_num); +return -EINVAL ; + } + + ret =regmap_read (priv->map,RTL8366RB_LED_X_X_CTRL_REG (led_group), + &val); +if (ret) { +dev_err (priv->dev,"error reading LED on port %d group %d\n" , + led_group, port_num); +return ret; + } + +return !!(val &rtl8366rb_led_group_port_mask (led_group, port_num)); +} + +static int rb8366rb_set_port_led (struct rtl8366rb_led *led,bool enable) +{ +struct realtek_priv *priv = led->priv; +u8 led_group = led->led_group; +u8 port_num = led->port_num; +int ret; + +if (led_group >=RTL8366RB_NUM_LEDGROUPS ) { +dev_err (priv->dev,"Invalid LED group %d for port %d" , + led_group, port_num); +return -EINVAL ; + } + + ret =regmap_update_bits (priv->map, +RTL8366RB_LED_X_X_CTRL_REG (led_group), +rtl8366rb_led_group_port_mask (led_group, + port_num), + enable ?0xffff :0 ); +if (ret) { +dev_err (priv->dev,"error updating LED on port %d group %d\n" , + led_group, port_num); +return ret; + } + +/* Change the LED group to manual controlled LEDs if required */ + ret =rb8366rb_set_ledgroup_mode (priv, led_group,RTL8366RB_LED_FORCE ); + +if (ret) { +dev_err (priv->dev,"error updating LED GROUP group %d\n" , + led_group); +return ret; + } + +return 0 ; +} + +static int +rtl8366rb_cled_brightness_set_blocking (struct led_classdev *ldev, +enum led_brightness brightness) +{ + struct rtl8366rb_led *led = container_of(ldev, struct rtl8366rb_led, + cdev); + +return rb8366rb_set_port_led (led, brightness ==LED_ON ); +} + +static int rtl8366rb_setup_led (struct realtek_priv *priv,struct dsa_port *dp, +struct fwnode_handle *led_fwnode) +{ +struct rtl8366rb *rb = priv->chip_data; +struct led_init_data init_data = { }; +struct rtl8366rb_led *led; +enum led_default_state state; +u32 led_group; +int ret; + + ret =fwnode_property_read_u32 (led_fwnode,"reg" , &led_group); +if (ret) +return ret; + +if (led_group >=RTL8366RB_NUM_LEDGROUPS ) { +dev_warn (priv->dev,"Invalid LED reg %d defined for port %d" , + led_group, dp->index); +return -EINVAL ; + } + + led = &rb->leds[dp->index][led_group]; + led->port_num = dp->index; + led->led_group = led_group; + led->priv = priv; + + state =led_init_default_state_get (led_fwnode); +switch (state) { +case LEDS_DEFSTATE_ON : + led->cdev.brightness =1 ; +rb8366rb_set_port_led (led,1 ); +break ; +case LEDS_DEFSTATE_KEEP : + led->cdev.brightness = +rb8366rb_get_port_led (led,1 ); +break ; +case LEDS_DEFSTATE_OFF : +default : + led->cdev.brightness =0 ; +rb8366rb_set_port_led (led,0 ); + } + + led->cdev.max_brightness =1 ; + led->cdev.brightness_set_blocking = + rtl8366rb_cled_brightness_set_blocking; + init_data.fwnode = led_fwnode; + init_data.devname_mandatory = true; + + init_data.devicename =kasprintf (GFP_KERNEL ,"Realtek-%d:0%d:%d" , + dp->ds->index, dp->index, led_group); +if (!init_data.devicename) +return -ENOMEM ; + + ret =devm_led_classdev_register_ext (priv->dev, &led->cdev, &init_data); +if (ret) { +dev_warn (priv->dev,"Failed to init LED %d for port %d" , + led_group, dp->index); +return ret; + } + +return 0 ; +} + +static int rtl8366rb_setup_leds (struct realtek_priv *priv) +{ +struct device_node *leds_np, *led_np; +struct dsa_port *dp; +int ret; + +dsa_switch_for_each_port (dp, priv->ds) { +if (!dp->dn) +continue ; + + leds_np =of_get_child_by_name (dp->dn,"leds" ); +if (!leds_np) { +dev_dbg (priv->dev,"No leds defined for port %d" , + dp->index); +continue ; + } + +for_each_child_of_node (leds_np, led_np) { + ret =rtl8366rb_setup_led (priv, dp, +of_fwnode_handle (led_np)); +if (ret) { +of_node_put (led_np); +break ; + } + } + +of_node_put (leds_np); +if (ret) +return ret; + } +return 0 ; +} +static int rtl8366rb_setup (struct dsa_switch *ds) {struct realtek_priv *priv = ds->priv;
@@ -814,7 +1035,6 @@ static int rtl8366rb_setup(struct dsa_switch *ds)u32 chip_ver =0 ;u32 chip_id =0 ;int jam_size; -u32 val;int ret;int i;
@@ -1014,14 +1234,15 @@ static int rtl8366rb_setup(struct dsa_switch *ds) 0);for (i =0 ; i <RTL8366RB_NUM_LEDGROUPS ; i++) { - val =RTL8366RB_LED_OFF <<RTL8366RB_LED_CTRL_OFFSET (i); - ret =regmap_update_bits (priv->map, -RTL8366RB_LED_CTRL_REG , -RTL8366RB_LED_CTRL_MASK (i), - val); + ret =rb8366rb_set_ledgroup_mode (priv, i, +RTL8366RB_LED_OFF );if (ret)return ret; } + }else { + ret =rtl8366rb_setup_leds (priv); +if (ret) +return ret; } ret =rtl8366_reset_vlan (priv);
Signature · 1 line
2.43.0
Luiz Angelo Daros de Luca
maintainerQuoted 17 lines
The rtl8366rb switch family has 4 LED groups, with one LED from each group for each of its 6 ports. LEDs in this family can be controlled manually using a bitmap or triggered by hardware. It's important to note that hardware triggers are configured at the LED group level, meaning all LEDs in the same group share the same hardware triggers settings.
The first part of this series involves dropping most of the existing code, as, except for disabling the LEDs, it was not working as expected. If not disabled, the LEDs will retain their default settings after a switch reset, which may be sufficient for many devices.
The second part introduces the LED driver to control the switch LEDs from sysfs or device-tree. This driver still allows the LEDs to retain their default settings, but it will shift to the software-based OS LED triggers if any configuration is changed. Subsequently, the LEDs will operate as normal LEDs until the switch undergoes another reset.
Quoted 7 lines
Netdev LED trigger supports offloading to hardware triggers. Unfortunately, this isn't possible with the current LED API for this switch family. When the hardware trigger is enabled, it applies to all LEDs in the LED group while the LED API decides to offload based on only the state of a single LED. To avoid inconsistency between LEDs, offloading would need to check if all LEDs in the group share the same compatible settings and atomically enable offload for all LEDs.
Hi Christian,
I tried to implement something close to your work with qca8k and LED hw control. However, I couldn't find a solution that would work with the existing API. The HW led configuration in realtek switches is shared with all LEDs in a group. Before activating the hw control, all LEDs in the same group must share the same netdev trigger config, use the correct device and also use a compatible netdev trigger settings. In order to check that, I would need to expose some internal netdev trigger info that is only available through sysfs (and I believe sysfs is not suitable to be used from the kernel). Even if I got all LEDs with the correct settings, I would need to atomicly switch all LEDs to use the hw control or, at least, I would need to stop all update jobs because if the OS changes a LED brightness, it might be interpreted as the OS disabling the hw control:
/*
...
* Deactivate hardware blink control by setting brightness to LED_OFF via
* the brightness_set() callback.
*
...
*/
int (*hw_control_set)(struct led_classdev *led_cdev,
unsigned long flags);
Do you have any idea how to implement it?
BTW, during my tests with a single LED, ignoring the LED group situation, I noticed that the OS was sending a brightness_set(LED_OFF) after I changed the trigger to netdev, a moment after hw_control_set was called. It doesn't make sense to enable hw control just to disable it afterwards. The call came from set_brightness_delayed(). Maybe it is because my test device is pretty slow and the previous trigger event always gets queued. Touching any settings after that worked as expected without the spurious brightness_set(LED_OFF). Did you see something like this?
Regards,
Luiz
Quoted 27 lines · Luiz Angelo Daros de Luca
Quoted 17 lines
The rtl8366rb switch family has 4 LED groups, with one LED from each group for each of its 6 ports. LEDs in this family can be controlled manually using a bitmap or triggered by hardware. It's important to note that hardware triggers are configured at the LED group level, meaning all LEDs in the same group share the same hardware triggers settings.
The first part of this series involves dropping most of the existing code, as, except for disabling the LEDs, it was not working as expected. If not disabled, the LEDs will retain their default settings after a switch reset, which may be sufficient for many devices.
The second part introduces the LED driver to control the switch LEDs from sysfs or device-tree. This driver still allows the LEDs to retain their default settings, but it will shift to the software-based OS LED triggers if any configuration is changed. Subsequently, the LEDs will operate as normal LEDs until the switch undergoes another reset.
Quoted 7 lines
Netdev LED trigger supports offloading to hardware triggers. Unfortunately, this isn't possible with the current LED API for this switch family. When the hardware trigger is enabled, it applies to all LEDs in the LED group while the LED API decides to offload based on only the state of a single LED. To avoid inconsistency between LEDs, offloading would need to check if all LEDs in the group share the same compatible settings and atomically enable offload for all LEDs.
Hi Christian,
Quoted 14 lines
I tried to implement something close to your work with qca8k and LED hw control. However, I couldn't find a solution that would work with the existing API. The HW led configuration in realtek switches is shared with all LEDs in a group. Before activating the hw control, all LEDs in the same group must share the same netdev trigger config, use the correct device and also use a compatible netdev trigger settings. In order to check that, I would need to expose some internal netdev trigger info that is only available through sysfs (and I believe sysfs is not suitable to be used from the kernel). Even if I got all LEDs with the correct settings, I would need to atomicly switch all LEDs to use the hw control or, at least, I would need to stop all update jobs because if the OS changes a LED brightness, it might be interpreted as the OS disabling the hw control:
Saddly we still don't have the concept of LED groups, but from what I notice 99% of the time switch have limitation of HW control but single LED can still be controlled separately.
With this limitation you can use the is_supported function and some priv struct to enforce and reject unsupported configuration. netdev trigger will then fallback to software in this case. (I assume on real world scenario to have all the LED in the group to be set to the common rule set resulting in is_supported never rejecting it)
Also consider this situation, it's the first LED touched that enables HW control that drive everything. LED configuration are not enabled all at once. You can totally introduce a priv struct that cache the current modes and on the other LEDs make sure the requested mode match the cache one.
And I guess this limitation should be printed and documented in DT.
Quoted 12 lines
/*
...
* Deactivate hardware blink control by setting brightness toLED_OFFvia
* thebrightness_set()callback.
*
...
*/
int (*hw_control_set)(structled_classdev*led_cdev,
unsigned long flags);Do you have any idea how to implement it?
Quoted 10 lines
BTW, during my tests with a single LED, ignoring the LED group situation, I noticed that the OS was sending a
brightness_set(LED_OFF)after I changed the trigger to netdev, a moment afterhw_control_setwas called. It doesn't make sense to enable hw control just to disable it afterwards. The call came fromset_brightness_delayed(). Maybe it is because my test device is pretty slow and the previous trigger event always gets queued. Touching any settings after that worked as expected without the spuriousbrightness_set(LED_OFF). Did you see something like this?
Consider that brightness_set is called whatever a trigger is changed, the logic is in the generic LED handling. Setting OFF and then enabling hw control should not change a thing. In other driver tho I notice an extra measure is needed to reset any HW control rule already applied by default.
Signature · 1 line
Ansuel
Luiz Angelo Daros de Luca
maintainerQuoted 17 lines
Quoted 16 lines
Hi Christian,
I tried to implement something close to your work with qca8k and LED hw control. However, I couldn't find a solution that would work with the existing API. The HW led configuration in realtek switches is shared with all LEDs in a group. Before activating the hw control, all LEDs in the same group must share the same netdev trigger config, use the correct device and also use a compatible netdev trigger settings. In order to check that, I would need to expose some internal netdev trigger info that is only available through sysfs (and I believe sysfs is not suitable to be used from the kernel). Even if I got all LEDs with the correct settings, I would need to atomicly switch all LEDs to use the hw control or, at least, I would need to stop all update jobs because if the OS changes a LED brightness, it might be interpreted as the OS disabling the hw control:
Quoted 3 lines
Saddly we still don't have the concept of LED groups, but from what I notice 99% of the time switch have limitation of HW control but single LED can still be controlled separately.
Individually, I can only turn them on/off. That is enough for software control but not for hardware control. When you set a LED group to blink on link activity, all LEDs will be affected.
Quoted 5 lines
With this limitation you can use the
is_supportedfunction and some priv struct to enforce and reject unsupported configuration. netdev trigger will then fallback to software in this case. (I assume on real world scenario to have all the LED in the group to be set to the common rule set resulting inis_supportednever rejecting it)
Maybe I wasn't clear enough about what the HW provides me. I have 4 16-bit registers:
REG1: a single blink rate used by all LEDs in all groups
REG2: configures the trigger for each group, 4-bit each, with one special 4-bit value being "fixed", equivalent to "none" in Linux LED trigger
REG3: bitmap to manually control LEDs in group 0 and 1 only when their group trigger is configured as fixed.
REG3: bitmap to manually control LEDs in group 2 and 3 only when their group trigger is configured as fixed.
And that's it.
I can keep track of the netdev trigger form calls to "is_supported function". I can also check if all LEDs are still using the netdev trigger. However, I cannot detect if the user changed the device to something else not related to the corresponding port as the netdev trigger will not check the compatibility if the device does not match. I would still need to expose at least some of the netdev trigger internal data.
Quoted 5 lines
Also consider this situation, it's the first LED touched that enables HW control that drive everything. LED configuration are not enabled all at once. You can totally introduce a priv struct that cache the current modes and on the other LEDs make sure the requested mode match the cache one.
Considering that I can externally check that all LEDs have a netdev trigger settings compatible with the HW control, once the last LED is configured, I could return true for the hw_control_is_supported. When hw_control_set is called, I could configure the hardware accordingly, which would affect all LEDs in that group. However, the OS will still use the software control for the other LEDs in that same group. That way, once a netdev event turns off one LED, that message is the same clue the LED driver receives to disable the hardware control. It will undo the hardware change I just made. I could use led_brightness_set(OFF) on those other LEDs during hw_control_set to disable their software controlled triggers (actually changing the trigger to "none"), but it might be a race condition of who stops the other. And even then, the other LEDs will keep an inconsistent configuration state, with "none" as their trigger.
I need:
1) expose the required info or allow an external caller to test a LED configuration for compatibility (avoiding recursion).
2) something from hw_control_set() that stops the software triggers in other LEDs without destroying their configuration.
3) something that could enable hw_control on those other LEDs
Quoted 25 lines
And I guess this limitation should be printed and documented in DT.
Quoted 12 lines
/*
...
* Deactivate hardware blink control by setting brightness toLED_OFFvia
* thebrightness_set()callback.
*
...
*/
int (*hw_control_set)(structled_classdev*led_cdev,
unsigned long flags);Do you have any idea how to implement it?
Quoted 10 lines
BTW, during my tests with a single LED, ignoring the LED group situation, I noticed that the OS was sending a
brightness_set(LED_OFF)after I changed the trigger to netdev, a moment afterhw_control_setwas called. It doesn't make sense to enable hw control just to disable it afterwards. The call came fromset_brightness_delayed(). Maybe it is because my test device is pretty slow and the previous trigger event always gets queued. Touching any settings after that worked as expected without the spuriousbrightness_set(LED_OFF). Did you see something like this?
Quoted 5 lines
Consider that
brightness_setis called whatever a trigger is changed, the logic is in the generic LED handling. Setting OFF and then enabling hw control should not change a thing. In other driver tho I notice an extra measure is needed to reset any HW control rule already applied by default.
It would be OK to call brightness_set(LED_OFF) if that is guaranteed to happen before hw_control_set(). The problem is that the brightness_set(LED_OFF) happens *after* hw_control_set() was called. It looks like a race condition.
Regards,
Luiz
Quoted 17 lines · Luiz Angelo Daros de Luca
Quoted 17 lines
Quoted 16 lines
Hi Christian,
I tried to implement something close to your work with qca8k and LED hw control. However, I couldn't find a solution that would work with the existing API. The HW led configuration in realtek switches is shared with all LEDs in a group. Before activating the hw control, all LEDs in the same group must share the same netdev trigger config, use the correct device and also use a compatible netdev trigger settings. In order to check that, I would need to expose some internal netdev trigger info that is only available through sysfs (and I believe sysfs is not suitable to be used from the kernel). Even if I got all LEDs with the correct settings, I would need to atomicly switch all LEDs to use the hw control or, at least, I would need to stop all update jobs because if the OS changes a LED brightness, it might be interpreted as the OS disabling the hw control:
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 3 lines
Saddly we still don't have the concept of LED groups, but from what I notice 99% of the time switch have limitation of HW control but single LED can still be controlled separately.
Individually, I can only turn them on/off. That is enough for software control but not for hardware control. When you set a LED group to blink on link activity, all LEDs will be affected.
Assuming we have the same 2005 datasheet, yes the LED situation is complex for this switch. (If you have something better please link)
Quoted 20 lines
Quoted 5 lines
With this limitation you can use the
is_supportedfunction and some priv struct to enforce and reject unsupported configuration. netdev trigger will then fallback to software in this case. (I assume on real world scenario to have all the LED in the group to be set to the common rule set resulting inis_supportednever rejecting it)Maybe I wasn't clear enough about what the HW provides me. I have 4 16-bit registers:
REG1: a single blink rate used by all LEDs in all groups
REG2: configures the trigger for each group, 4-bit each, with one special 4-bit value being "fixed", equivalent to "none" in Linux LED trigger
REG3: bitmap to manually control LEDs in group 0 and 1 only when their group trigger is configured as fixed.
REG3: bitmap to manually control LEDs in group 2 and 3 only when their group trigger is configured as fixed.And that's it.
Quoted 8 lines
I can keep track of the netdev trigger form calls to "
is_supportedfunction". I can also check if all LEDs are still using the netdev trigger. However, I cannot detect if the user changed the device to something else not related to the corresponding port as the netdev trigger will not check the compatibility if the device does not match. I would still need to expose at least some of the netdev trigger internal data.
We can make some assumption and use refcount tho. For very exotic configuration it will always fallback to software (and make hw control impossible) but for more generic one we can benefit of it.
- We can only enable HW control on the LED group.
This means that for the group we need to make sure that:
1. We have the correct device set to each LED
2. We have an acceptable mode requesterd.
With these 2 prereq, we can correctly enable HW control for the LED group.
HW control is enable only IF the device netdev currently set match what hw_control_get_device returns. With this, we can assume for HW control request the correct netdev is always set.
We also use refcount to check how many LED are actually ""enabled"". With this count we can understand if we can enable HW control for the LED group or return false from is_supported.
And with HW control enabled, we would reject all kind of invalid settings and print a warning to alert the user of the limitation and maybe how to remove it.
Quoted 21 lines
Quoted 5 lines
Also consider this situation, it's the first LED touched that enables HW control that drive everything. LED configuration are not enabled all at once. You can totally introduce a priv struct that cache the current modes and on the other LEDs make sure the requested mode match the cache one.
Considering that I can externally check that all LEDs have a netdev trigger settings compatible with the HW control, once the last LED is configured, I could return true for the
hw_control_is_supported. Whenhw_control_setis called, I could configure the hardware accordingly, which would affect all LEDs in that group. However, the OS will still use the software control for the other LEDs in that same group. That way, once a netdev event turns off one LED, that message is the same clue the LED driver receives to disable the hardware control. It will undo the hardware change I just made. I could useled_brightness_set(OFF)on those other LEDs duringhw_control_setto disable their software controlled triggers (actually changing the trigger to "none"), but it might be a race condition of who stops the other. And even then, the other LEDs will keep an inconsistent configuration state, with "none" as their trigger.
Quoted 7 lines
I need:
1) expose the required info or allow an external caller to test a LED configuration for compatibility (avoiding recursion).
2) something fromhw_control_set()that stops the software triggers in other LEDs without destroying their configuration.
3) something that could enablehw_controlon those other LEDs
I think it would be problematic for other LED to do changes. I need to check how LED multicolor work... In a sense they are LED group so maybe in LED core we have a way to group LED and share some info with the others.
Quoted 31 lines
Quoted 25 lines
And I guess this limitation should be printed and documented in DT.
Quoted 12 lines
/*
...
* Deactivate hardware blink control by setting brightness toLED_OFFvia
* thebrightness_set()callback.
*
...
*/
int (*hw_control_set)(structled_classdev*led_cdev,
unsigned long flags);Do you have any idea how to implement it?
Quoted 10 lines
BTW, during my tests with a single LED, ignoring the LED group situation, I noticed that the OS was sending a
brightness_set(LED_OFF)after I changed the trigger to netdev, a moment afterhw_control_setwas called. It doesn't make sense to enable hw control just to disable it afterwards. The call came fromset_brightness_delayed(). Maybe it is because my test device is pretty slow and the previous trigger event always gets queued. Touching any settings after that worked as expected without the spuriousbrightness_set(LED_OFF). Did you see something like this?Quoted 5 lines
Consider that
brightness_setis called whatever a trigger is changed, the logic is in the generic LED handling. Setting OFF and then enabling hw control should not change a thing. In other driver tho I notice an extra measure is needed to reset any HW control rule already applied by default.
Quoted 5 lines
It would be OK to call
brightness_set(LED_OFF)if that is guaranteed to happen beforehw_control_set(). The problem is that thebrightness_set(LED_OFF)happens *after*hw_control_set()was called. It looks like a race condition.
Totally require some further investigation, it seems strange tho that the your system is that slow.
Signature · 1 line
Ansuel
Luiz Angelo Daros de Luca
maintainerQuoted 22 lines · Luiz Angelo Daros de Luca
Quoted 21 lines
Quoted 20 lines
Quoted 16 lines
Hi Christian,
I tried to implement something close to your work with qca8k and LED hw control. However, I couldn't find a solution that would work with the existing API. The HW led configuration in realtek switches is shared with all LEDs in a group. Before activating the hw control, all LEDs in the same group must share the same netdev trigger config, use the correct device and also use a compatible netdev trigger settings. In order to check that, I would need to expose some internal netdev trigger info that is only available through sysfs (and I believe sysfs is not suitable to be used from the kernel). Even if I got all LEDs with the correct settings, I would need to atomicly switch all LEDs to use the hw control or, at least, I would need to stop all update jobs because if the OS changes a LED brightness, it might be interpreted as the OS disabling the hw control:
Saddly we still don't have the concept of LED groups, but from what I notice 99% of the time switch have limitation of HW control but single LED can still be controlled separately.
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Individually, I can only turn them on/off. That is enough for software control but not for hardware control. When you set a LED group to blink on link activity, all LEDs will be affected.
Assuming we have the same 2005 datasheet, yes the LED situation is complex for this switch. (If you have something better please link)
I wouldn't say complex, but limited.
The manual for rtl8365mb
(https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/gh/libc0607/Realtek_switch_hacking@files/Realtek_Unmanaged_Switch_ProgrammingGuide.pdf,
page 64) shows the vendor API for controlling LEDs. It is similar for both families.
You have only 3 functions:
int32 rtk_led_blinkRate_set(rtk_led_blink_rate_t blinkRate)
int32 rtk_led_groupConfig_set(rtk_led_group_t group, rtk_led_congig_t config) int32 rtk_led_enable_set(rtk_led_group_t group, rtk_portmask_t portmask)
rtk_led_blinkRate_set sets the blink rate but it does not mention group or port, so it is global.rtk_led_groupConfig_set defines the HW trigger but only by group. rtk_led_enable_set uses a mask to manually set a LED
It closely matches the register behavior.
Quoted 29 lines
Quoted 21 lines
Quoted 5 lines
Also consider this situation, it's the first LED touched that enables HW control that drive everything. LED configuration are not enabled all at once. You can totally introduce a priv struct that cache the current modes and on the other LEDs make sure the requested mode match the cache one.
Considering that I can externally check that all LEDs have a netdev trigger settings compatible with the HW control, once the last LED is configured, I could return true for the
hw_control_is_supported. Whenhw_control_setis called, I could configure the hardware accordingly, which would affect all LEDs in that group. However, the OS will still use the software control for the other LEDs in that same group. That way, once a netdev event turns off one LED, that message is the same clue the LED driver receives to disable the hardware control. It will undo the hardware change I just made. I could useled_brightness_set(OFF)on those other LEDs duringhw_control_setto disable their software controlled triggers (actually changing the trigger to "none"), but it might be a race condition of who stops the other. And even then, the other LEDs will keep an inconsistent configuration state, with "none" as their trigger.Quoted 7 lines
I need:
1) expose the required info or allow an external caller to test a LED configuration for compatibility (avoiding recursion).
2) something fromhw_control_set()that stops the software triggers in other LEDs without destroying their configuration.
3) something that could enablehw_controlon those other LEDs
Quoted 4 lines
I think it would be problematic for other LED to do changes. I need to check how LED multicolor work... In a sense they are LED group so maybe in LED core we have a way to group LED and share some info with the others.
That's the main issue. I can expose the needed info to check if all LEDs agree in a compatible configuration. However, once that happens, I must stop all sw control and enable the hw control. Something like:
lock a group of leds
for all leds
if not devname is correct
fallback to sw control
if settings are not compatible
fallback to sw control
if settings is different from other LEDs
fallback to sw control
for all leds
stop sw control work
for all leds
enable hw control
set the group hw trigger
unlock the group of leds
And I need something that would also work to disable hw control once the first LED changes anything, breaking the compatibility.
Quoted 17 lines
Quoted 17 lines
Quoted 16 lines
Quoted 10 lines
BTW, during my tests with a single LED, ignoring the LED group situation, I noticed that the OS was sending a
brightness_set(LED_OFF)after I changed the trigger to netdev, a moment afterhw_control_setwas called. It doesn't make sense to enable hw control just to disable it afterwards. The call came fromset_brightness_delayed(). Maybe it is because my test device is pretty slow and the previous trigger event always gets queued. Touching any settings after that worked as expected without the spuriousbrightness_set(LED_OFF). Did you see something like this?Consider that
brightness_setis called whatever a trigger is changed, the logic is in the generic LED handling. Setting OFF and then enabling hw control should not change a thing. In other driver tho I notice an extra measure is needed to reset any HW control rule already applied by default.
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 5 lines
It would be OK to call
brightness_set(LED_OFF)if that is guaranteed to happen beforehw_control_set(). The problem is that thebrightness_set(LED_OFF)happens *after*hw_control_set()was called. It looks like a race condition.Totally require some further investigation, it seems strange tho that the your system is that slow.
I got some stacks. When I change the trigger to netdev, I get 2 calls to set the hw control:
[ 625.601449] CPU: 0 PID: 2607 Comm: ash Not tainted 6.1.59 #0 [ 625.607153] Stack : 809b0000 77e70000 00000000 800c1e80 00000431 00000004 00000000 00000000 [ 625.615627] 80c45c74 80980000 80850000 806ffc2c 80e23b88 00000001 80c45c18 f51e58b8 [ 625.624094] 00000000 00000000 806ffc2c 80c45b48 ffffefff 00000000 00000000 ffffffea [ 625.632561] 00000112 80c45b54 00000112 807c99c0 00000001 806ffc2c 809ec080 00000005 [ 625.641029] ffff7fff 80840000 809b0000 77e70000 00000018 8039785c 00000000 80980000 [ 625.649495] ... [ 625.651965] Call Trace: [ 625.654422] [<80066e4c>] show_stack+0x28/0xf0 [ 625.658848] [<8061b800>] dump_stack_lvl+0x38/0x60 [ 625.663599] [<8189b890>] rtl8366rb_cled_hw_control_set+0xdc/0xf8 [rtl8366] [ 625.670578] [<8041dfb0>] netdev_trig_notify+0x114/0x280 [ 625.675867] [<80450d14>] call_netdevice_register_net_notifiers+0x54/0x104 [ 625.682729] [<804542dc>] register_netdevice_notifier+0x98/0x130 [ 625.688702] [<8041dbf8>] netdev_trig_activate+0x160/0x1b0 [ 625.694152] [<8041b948>] led_trigger_set+0xf8/0x254 [ 625.699070] [<8041c2a4>] led_trigger_write+0xd4/0x148 [ 625.704163] [<8026966c>] sysfs_kf_bin_write+0x80/0xbc [ 625.709263] [<80268438>] kernfs_fop_write_iter+0x118/0x244 [ 625.714801] [<801e787c>] vfs_write+0x1fc/0x3c0 [ 625.719301] [<801e7bdc>] ksys_write+0x70/0x124 [ 625.723791] [<8006e1e4>] syscall_common+0x34/0x58
[ 625.761665] CPU: 0 PID: 2607 Comm: ash Not tainted 6.1.59 #0 [ 625.767374] Stack : 809b0000 77e70000 00000000 800c1e80 00000431 00000004 00000000 00000000 [ 625.775848] 80c45c74 80980000 80850000 806ffc2c 80e23b88 00000001 80c45c18 f51e58b8 [ 625.784315] 00000000 00000000 806ffc2c 80c45b48 ffffefff 00000000 00000000 ffffffea [ 625.792782] 00000130 80c45b54 00000130 807c99c0 00000001 806ffc2c 809ec080 00000001 [ 625.801249] ffff7fff 80840000 809b0000 77e70000 00000018 8039785c 00000000 80980000 [ 625.809716] ... [ 625.812186] Call Trace: [ 625.814643] [<80066e4c>] show_stack+0x28/0xf0 [ 625.819068] [<8061b800>] dump_stack_lvl+0x38/0x60 [ 625.823820] [<8189b890>] rtl8366rb_cled_hw_control_set+0xdc/0xf8 [rtl8366] [ 625.830800] [<8041dfb0>] netdev_trig_notify+0x114/0x280 [ 625.836088] [<80450d94>] call_netdevice_register_net_notifiers+0xd4/0x104 [ 625.842950] [<804542dc>] register_netdevice_notifier+0x98/0x130 [ 625.848923] [<8041dbf8>] netdev_trig_activate+0x160/0x1b0 [ 625.854374] [<8041b948>] led_trigger_set+0xf8/0x254 [ 625.859300] [<8041c2a4>] led_trigger_write+0xd4/0x148 [ 625.864401] [<8026966c>] sysfs_kf_bin_write+0x80/0xbc [ 625.869502] [<80268438>] kernfs_fop_write_iter+0x118/0x244 [ 625.875040] [<801e787c>] vfs_write+0x1fc/0x3c0 [ 625.879539] [<801e7bdc>] ksys_write+0x70/0x124 [ 625.884030] [<8006e1e4>] syscall_common+0x34/0x58
That is not really a problem but I my guess is that it is calling for both NETDEV_REGISTER and NETDEV_UP as both eventually call set_baseline_state(). Shouldn't we avoid one of them?
But after that, I get:
[ 625.900712] CPU: 0 PID: 2626 Comm: kworker/0:2 Not tainted 6.1.59 #0 [ 625.907154] Workqueue: events set_brightness_delayed [ 625.912178] Stack : 81000205 81a4ab40 817f9da4 800c1e80 8199e4e0 806ffc2c 807c0000 81a4ab00 [ 625.920652] 81000200 00000000 80c08c5c 800c1f7c 80e21cc8 00000001 817f9d60 f37f8d2c [ 625.929119] 00000000 00000000 806ffc2c 817f9c78 ffffefff 00000000 00000000 ffffffea [ 625.937587] 00000148 817f9c84 00000148 807c99c0 00000001 806ffc2c 00000000 81000200 [ 625.946054] 00000000 80c08c5c 81000205 81a4ab40 00000018 8039785c 00000000 80980000 [ 625.954521] ... [ 625.956990] Call Trace: [ 625.959448] [<80066e4c>] show_stack+0x28/0xf0 [ 625.963873] [<8061b800>] dump_stack_lvl+0x38/0x60 [ 625.968624] [<81899ec8>] rtl8366rb_cled_brightness_set_blocking+0x68/0x88 [rtl8366] [ 625.976389] [<8041a018>] set_brightness_delayed+0x84/0xec [ 625.981833] [<8009f724>] process_one_work+0x254/0x484 [ 625.986934] [<8009fed0>] worker_thread+0x178/0x5a4 [ 625.991766] [<800a61a0>] kthread+0xec/0x114 [ 625.996004] [<800620b8>] ret_from_kernel_thread+0x14/0x1c
This one is the issue. It turns off the LED, forcing me to disable the hw control I just configured (twice). Unfortunately, a scheduled work breaks the stack, not showing who actually requested it.
I only saw set_brightness_delayed being used by a work created in led_init_core(), called by led_classdev_register_ext. That work might be scheduled by led_set_brightness(). So, a call to led_set_brightness() moments before setting netdev trigger might reproduce the issue I see.
I'll try to get who scheduled the work and the stack from there. It might already pinpoint the cause. Checking if the work is pending during netdev trigger activation might also help. I'll also try to flush (or cancel) the work before activating the new trigger. I just don't know if I can flush (and that way, blocking) inside led_set_brightness().
I just bricked my device and I couldn't continue the tests. I might need to reserve an extra hour to fix that in the next days.
Regards,
Luiz
Luiz Angelo Daros de Luca
maintainerQuoted 7 lines
I'll try to get who scheduled the work and the stack from there. It might already pinpoint the cause. Checking if the work is pending during netdev trigger activation might also help. I'll also try to flush (or cancel) the work before activating the new trigger. I just don't know if I can flush (and that way, blocking) inside
led_set_brightness().
Hi Christian,
I got it. It was actually from the netdev trigger. During activation we have:
/* Check if hw control is active by default on the LED.
* Init already enabled mode in hw control.
*/
if (supports_hw_control(led_cdev)) {
dev = led_cdev->hw_control_get_device(led_cdev);
if (dev) {
const char *name = dev_name(dev);
set_device_name(trigger_data, name, strlen(name));
trigger_data->hw_control = true;
rc = led_cdev->hw_control_get(led_cdev, &mode);
if (!rc)
trigger_data->mode = mode;
}
}The set_device_name calls set_baseline_state() that, at this point, will start to monitor the device using sw control (trigger_data->hw_control is only set afterwards). In set_baseline_state(), it will call led_set_brightness in most codepaths (all of them if trigger_data->hw_control is false). With link down (and other situations), it will call led_set_brightness(led_cdev, LED_OFF). If that led_set_brightness takes some time to be processed, it will happen after the hw control was configured, undoing what it previously just did.
Is there any good reason to call set_device_name before the led mode and hw_control are defined? Will this break anything?
(quoted diff) +0 -0
b/drivers/leds/trigger/ledtrig-netdev.c
index d76214fa9ad8..6f72d55c187a 100644
drivers/leds/trigger/ledtrig-netdev.c +0 -0
@@ -572,12 +572,13 @@ static int netdev_trig_activate(struct
led_classdev *led_cdev)
if (dev) {
const char *name = dev_name(dev);- set_device_name(trigger_data, name, strlen(name));
trigger_data->hw_control = true;
rc = led_cdev->hw_control_get(led_cdev, &mode);
if (!rc)
trigger_data->mode = mode;
+
+ set_device_name(trigger_data, name, strlen(name));
}
}With this patch, it will not undo the trigger setting in hardware anymore. However, it now calls the hw_control_set 3 times during activation:
1) set_device_name
2) register_netdevice_notifier on NETDEV_REGISTER
3) register_netdevice_notifier on NETDEV_UP
Anyway, calling it multiple times doesn't break anything.
Regards,
Luiz
Quoted 63 lines · Luiz Angelo Daros de Luca
Quoted 7 lines
I'll try to get who scheduled the work and the stack from there. It might already pinpoint the cause. Checking if the work is pending during netdev trigger activation might also help. I'll also try to flush (or cancel) the work before activating the new trigger. I just don't know if I can flush (and that way, blocking) inside
led_set_brightness().Hi Christian,
I got it. It was actually from the netdev trigger. During activation we have:
/* Check if hw control is active by default on the LED. * Init already enabled mode in hw control. */ if (supports_hw_control(led_cdev)) { dev = led_cdev->hw_control_get_device(led_cdev); if (dev) { const char *name = dev_name(dev); set_device_name(trigger_data, name, strlen(name)); trigger_data->hw_control = true; rc = led_cdev->hw_control_get(led_cdev, &mode); if (!rc) trigger_data->mode = mode; } }The
set_device_namecallsset_baseline_state()that, at this point, will start to monitor the device using sw control (trigger_data->hw_controlis only set afterwards). Inset_baseline_state(), it will callled_set_brightnessin most codepaths (all of them iftrigger_data->hw_controlis false). With link down (and other situations), it will callled_set_brightness(led_cdev, LED_OFF). If thatled_set_brightnesstakes some time to be processed, it will happen after the hw control was configured, undoing what it previously just did.Is there any good reason to call
set_device_namebefore the led mode andhw_controlare defined? Will this break anything?drivers/leds/trigger/ledtrig-netdev.c +2
-1@@ -572,12 +572,13 @@ static int netdev_trig_activate(struct led_classdev *led_cdev) if (dev) {const char *name =dev_name (dev); -set_device_name (trigger_data, name,strlen (name)); trigger_data->hw_control = true; rc = led_cdev->hw_control_get (led_cdev, &mode);if (!rc) trigger_data->mode = mode; + +set_device_name (trigger_data, name,strlen (name)); } }
Quoted 4 lines
With this patch, it will not undo the trigger setting in hardware anymore. However, it now calls the
hw_control_set3 times during activation:
This is addressed by the following patch, it should show up in linux-next after the merge window.
Quoted 10 lines
1)
set_device_name
2)register_netdevice_notifieronNETDEV_REGISTER
3)register_netdevice_notifieronNETDEV_UPAnyway, calling it multiple times doesn't break anything.
Regards,
Luiz
Luiz Angelo Daros de Luca
maintainerQuoted 4 lines
This is addressed by the following patch, it should show up in linux-next after the merge window.
Hello Heiner,
Yes, exactly that. Thanks. I wish it had appeared some days ago. :-)
Regards,
Luiz
Hi Luiz,
Quoted 17 lines · Luiz Angelo Daros de Luca
The rtl8366rb switch family has 4 LED groups, with one LED from each group for each of its 6 ports. LEDs in this family can be controlled manually using a bitmap or triggered by hardware. It's important to note that hardware triggers are configured at the LED group level, meaning all LEDs in the same group share the same hardware triggers settings.
The first part of this series involves dropping most of the existing code, as, except for disabling the LEDs, it was not working as expected. If not disabled, the LEDs will retain their default settings after a switch reset, which may be sufficient for many devices.
The second part introduces the LED driver to control the switch LEDs from sysfs or device-tree. This driver still allows the LEDs to retain their default settings, but it will shift to the software-based OS LED triggers if any configuration is changed. Subsequently, the LEDs will operate as normal LEDs until the switch undergoes another reset.
Quoted 7 lines
Netdev LED trigger supports offloading to hardware triggers. Unfortunately, this isn't possible with the current LED API for this switch family. When the hardware trigger is enabled, it applies to all LEDs in the LED group while the LED API decides to offload based on only the state of a single LED. To avoid inconsistency between LEDs, offloading would need to check if all LEDs in the group share the same compatible settings and atomically enable offload for all LEDs.
I think these patches look great, and the driver certainly look better after these changes than before them so if you resend without RFC, please feel free to add my:
HW triggers may be hard to implement but plain software control is not bad either so this is already way better than what we had before.
HW control can always be discussed and added later.
Yours,
Linus Walleij