Skip to contentSkip to conversation

booting w/o initrd

linux-lvm Ulf Bartelt 2 participants 3 messages Dec 22, 1999 – Dec 23, 1999

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hi!

We're searching ppl with some time to try this out...

;-)

Bye!
Ulf.

==============================================================================
The Idea (and Definition) of a Partition Alias for a LV
------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Required reading:
LVM-HOWTO
http://www.freenet.de/y.e.t.i./LVM-experimente.txt (sorry, only in german
at the moment)
sfdisk(8)

Partitions and Logical Volumes
------------------------------

Partitions of disks are normally contiguuous blocks of disk space, starting at a specific cylinder and ending at another one.
They allow for addressing raw data blocks by translation through filesystem facilities. However, this doesn't have to be so with LVM. Since this logical layer between the raw disk and the filesystem allows for online allocation of more disk space it is quite normal that Logical Volumes as counterpart to traditional partitions are spread non-contiguuous over the disk(s). This poses no threat on an LVM system - it is just normal.

Booting with partitions vs. LVM
-------------------------------

Booting on a PC is a relatively simple thing: the partition only has to be flagged bootable and - it has to be contiguuous.
This is required by all conventional PC Hardware and OSes. Therefore different approaches have been done to overcome this limitation, some of them are also used to boot the system with LVM activated. This includes initrd with its two-phase boot concept as well. But there is another, simpler and easier technique to make a system boot with initial LVM support.

Prerequisites
-------------

Imagine a LV lying in some VG of your PV.
This LV has to be allocated in a continuous range of PEs, especially it must not cross the border between two disks. With these requirements fullfilled, the LV could be described completely by the number of the its beginning sector on the disk and its length in sectors. This information can be obtained by looking up the start of the LV relative to the partition which is the PV containing this LV and the offset of this partition on your harddisk:

iason:~# pvdisplay -v /dev/sda3
--- Physical Volume ---
PV Name		 	 		 /dev/sda3
VG Name		 	 		 vg00
PV Size		 	 		 9996.22 MB / NOT usable 223 KB [LVM: 121 KB]
PV#		 	 		 1
PV Status				 available
Allocatable		 		 yes
Cur LV		 	 		 7
PE Size	 (KByte)	 		 4096
Total PE		 		 2498
Free PE	 		 		 1043
Allocated PE		 		 1455

--- Distribution of physical volume ---
LV Name LE of LV PE for LV
/dev/vg00/root 2 2

--- Physical extents ---
PE LV LE Disk sector
00000 /dev/vg00/root 00000 446
00001 /dev/vg00/root 00001 8638
iason:~#

Adding the values for the start Disk sector of the LV to the start value of the partition in which the LVM lives gives the absolute position of the boot sector of the LVM-ized system.
Now imagine entering start (on the disk) and length of this LV in the partition table of this disk (maybe using sfdisk) as another (normally in a LVM system unused) partition.

What would you get?

You could access this LV via an ordinary partition device like /dev/hda1.

Partition Alias and Booting a Linux Installation
------------------------------------------------

Prerequisites:

* you partitioned (nearly) your whole harddisk as one partition with the right ID (0xFE) to be recognized by LVM.

* you created two LVs /dev/vg00/boot and /dev/vg00/root fullfilling the requirements mentioned above and a lot of other LVs to contain the other filesystems of your linux installation.

* you created partition aliases for /dev/vg00/boot and /dev/vg00/root and use only the partition aliases in /etc/lilo.conf and /etc/fstab.

* you put some script to start and stop LVM in some /etc/init.d-script.

So you would be able to boot your root in a conventional way, activate LVM and mount the other LVs.

And when bringing the system down, LVM can be stopped cleanly because the root filesystem is only addressed via the partition alias.

But what if ...
---------------

... you want to resize the root?

It is not much more complicated to do this compared to booting via initrd. Even when booting via initrd, you cannot resize the root while it is mounted. So this way is not responsible for the main problem in resizing the
root.

Using initrd, you would bring up a initrd with all tools to resize the root or create another secondary root with all these tools.

Using a partition alias you can do this the same way. The only thing you have to remember is to recalculate the values for the partition alias and put those in your partition-table again. And even this can be done by a script.

So this is not really a drawback.

Installing...
-------------

Installing a LVM-only system is the main problem even when using an initrd.

If you managed to get a system up with all filesystems in LVs and temporarily boot using a syslinux-disk with an initrd, creating the partition aliases is no hard task and the next reboot could succeed without bootfloppy.

==============================================================================

Ok -- you mean what I know... ;-)

There's a lot to do in getting such a system up and running but it was sucessfully done with two systems @home as well as with a notebook and another desktop system. With the notebook system it was also possible to use an LVMized Linux system in a multiboot- configuration with Windows NT4.0 and Windows 95.

Comments?

==============================================================================
1999-12-22

Ulf Bartelt, [email protected]
Peter Wuestefeld, [email protected]
==============================================================================

#1 lore raw

there are some good ideas here, i will only point the problems. On Wed, Dec 22, 1999 at 02:25:37PM +0100, Ulf Bartelt wrote:
<snip>

Quoted 2 lines

And when bringing the system down, LVM can be stopped cleanly because the root filesystem is only addressed via the partition alias.

add mirrored LV to the equation and you'll obtain a mess.

Quoted 9 lines

But what if ...
---------------

... you want to resize the root?

It is not much more complicated to do this compared to booting via initrd. Even when booting via initrd, you cannot resize the root while it is mounted. So this way is not responsible for the main problem in resizing the root.

it is, you are adding one more constraint, that the root must be contiguous. enjoy pvmoving things around (if you have 2 disks) btw you can resize a mounted filesystem, and i hope this wil become standard practice.

what's the problem with initrd, just look at it as a very big __initfunc(), just easier to debug.

L.

Signature · 2 lines
Luca Berra -- [email protected]
    Communication Media & Services S.r.l.
#2 lore raw
Quoted 9 lines · Luca Berra

there are some good ideas here, i will only point the problems. On Wed, Dec 22, 1999 at 02:25:37PM +0100, Ulf Bartelt wrote:
<snip>

Quoted 2 lines

And when bringing the system down, LVM can be stopped cleanly because the root filesystem is only addressed via the partition alias.

add mirrored LV to the equation and you'll obtain a mess.

The idea works for now. When I get in touch with mirrored LVs, I sure have to rethink a lot.

Quoted 2 lines

what's the problem with initrd, just look at it as a very big __initfunc(), just easier to debug.

I dont see the clean __exitfunc().

Maybe I don't "see the forest because of too many trees" (we'd say in german...)...

Bye!
Ulf.